Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom

"Last minute stop after thr big game. It took a bit for our server to greet us at our table. She was nice but wasn't too familiar with the beer options. We later found the type of beer we wanted on a table menu. Food was served promptly and was very good. We enjoyed our pizza and Buffalo chicken rolls. We'll be back for more goo eats."

"I recently visited Old Chicago and had a truly enjoyable experience. The ambiance of the restaurant is inviting, with a comfortable and casual setting that instantly made me feel at ease. The staff was friendly and attentive, ensuring that our needs were met throughout the meal. The menu offers a great variety of options, with a focus on pizza and American pub fare. I tried their signature pizza, and it was delicious - the crust was perfectly cooked, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful. The portion sizes were generous, providing good value for the price. While the restaurant was quite busy, the service was prompt and efficient. We didn't have to wait long for our food, and everything was served at the right temperature. The overall atmosphere was lively and welcoming, making it a great spot for both families and groups of friends. My critique is the pizza didn’t have as much cheese as I had hoped, which left much to be desired. We also tried to order salad but found that they were out of salad, which was quite disappointing. However, this is a minor issue compared to the overall quality of the food and service. I just really love cheese and salads. (-1 star) In conclusion, Old Chicago offers a delightful dining experience with tasty food, friendly service, and a warm atmosphere. I would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a good meal in a relaxed setting."

"The atmosphere was nice and felt like a more upscale bar. The food however was just okay. Not bad or good, but nothing special. I ordered a pepperoni pizza, which was fine. The fried pickles were pretty good however. It definitely wasn’t a bad experience though. Our server was very nice and attentive."

"Akward is the word that comes to mind for this review. When we arrived at 11:45 they may be had 3 small groups in the restaurant but we had to wait for them to clean a tBle to get us in. The service was ok but nothing spectacular for only being a small group and barely anyone in the restaurant. The food was bland and didn't really have a ton of flavor. No thrills is really what it is as it looks boring and not real exciting to eat. The waitress was nice but seemed bothered she had to wait on us. For a lunch hour on Thursday in Green Bay and barely anyone in the restaurant speaks to the atmosphere and reputation this restaurant has. Like I said the food was ok but nothing I would be hopeful to get weekly."

"Ate out with our 2 kids, & it was a very nice meal. My husband's chicken parmesan was better than most he's had (& he's a foodie lol). My burger was soooooo good! Hadn't been in years, but will definitely be back again."