Gallagher's Pizza - East Green Bay

"Currently staying at the St John's Ministries homeless shelter and want to give a shout out to the fine people at Gallaghers West Mason who provided the food for all the guys tonight. It was delicious and greatly appreciated. Good on you!"

"During my recent visit to Gallagher’s Pizza in Green Bay, WI, I ventured into their lunch buffet, an option that many locals seem to enjoy. Here's my take on it, rated at a solid 3 out of 5 stars. Upon entry, we were immediately asked if we were there for the buffet. In hindsight, we should've inquired about the full menu, but we went ahead with the buffet. This was a learning moment for us - always ask for options! The buffet was "ok" – it served its purpose of filling us up, but it didn't leave a lasting impression. While the food was satisfactory, it lacked a certain special touch that would compel me to return specifically for the buffet or recommend it to visitors. On the brighter side, the pricing was very reasonable, and the service was commendable. The servers were kind and attentive, ensuring a comfortable dining experience. Now, let's talk about the highlight - the oatmeal cookies. These delightful treats were a standout, absolutely delicious, and were the one item we found ourselves going back for, again and again. They certainly deserve a special mention. The salad bar, while fresh, could do with a bit more variety in terms of fixings and toppings. It was well-stocked with the basics, but a few more options would elevate it significantly. Overall, Gallagher’s Pizza seems like a place with potential, especially given its popularity among locals. If they could enhance the quality and flavor profile of their buffet offerings, it would definitely bump up the overall experience. For now, it's a decent option for a quick, no-frills meal, especially if you're in the mood for some excellent oatmeal cookies."

"Makayla was very attentive and quick to answer any questions we had. The food was warm and arrived promptly. We got the cheese curds, Gallagher bread, bread sticks, Chicken Alfredo pizza, and a deep dish pepperoni pizza. The cheese, as you would expect, was incredible and the sauce was very traditional tasting. Toppings were quality and it didn’t seem like they cut corners anywhere when it comes to their pizza! The environment of the restaurant was very clean and traditional feeling. Being located next to a brewery allowed a large selection for alcohol. Our experience at Gallagher was great and we would definitely be back!"

"Food was not amazing or anything, but it was decent. Service was a little lacking. One waitress seated us but then ended her shift without telling anyone. Eventually another waitress figured it out. She was pleasant but rather slow. My 7yo daughter loved the cheese curds and her bread stick, but wasn't nuts about the spaghetti. Pizza was alright."