Arni's New Albany

"Always great at making my companies big lunch order. They come right out to the car. Everyone is always friendly."

"This was a go to place for my family growing up. I loved taking my family as an adult to. Nothing like a fresh pizza from the oven covered with plenty of toppings. Now pizza is a shadow of its former self. To make it worse they have decided to close on site dining and the style of pizza they serve is warm to cold by the time you get it home. The other local competitor with similar pizza that was always considered #2 now surpasses this establishment in quality and atmosphere. It’s a true shame."

"We ordered several pizzas. Only one out of 5 pizzas was baked correctly. The other 4 pizzas were overcooked and partially burnt. This is the first time I've ever been disappointed. Our money was wasted on 4 of the pizzas, as they really weren't edible."

"This is still a pickup only place. For me, that dies not work. To drive some distance to get there, I don't like eating hot pizza in the car. Worse yet, I hate taking hot pizza home, and it is sort of warm by then. Bad experience. On top of that, this pizza was not what this Arni's built its reputation on. Their deluxe pizza was ok, but not worth driving 30 minutes to get. It was a bit overdone, & the ingredient were a bit sparse, especially cheese. You could hide the lack of ingredients with generous cheese on top, like they used to do. The pizza was just so-so, it was ok. But not enough to make want to rush back. They used to do better, I hope the return to their successful previous self. Note-the Arni's Junior salad was good as normal."

"The food was as good as could reasonably be expected for a pizza place. The salad is actually fantastic, which is a shocking change for a pizza joint. The interior is closed to the public, so you'll have to place your order in advance over the phone, or call the number taped to the window. There are a few picnic tables set up outside nearby, but it's not exactly picturesque nor private."