Wild Pepper Pizza 2 25791 East Smoky Hill Road, Aurora, CO 80016

"Nice people, but the pizza is overpriced for what you get. Frozen crust and tasted like an overpriced frozen box pizza from the store. Ordered a double crust pizza online and they called and said they cannot so that even though it shows on their menu. Large is more like a medium size. Pizza left my stomach turning. Sausage tasted horrible. Pepperoni was fine. Sorry, but hope they can improve."

"Pretty good pizza, but EXTREMELY expensive. We got one "Large" and one "extra large" plus an order of garlic knots and it was over $70! On top of that, I ordered two sides of ranch for $1 extra each, and the staff was trying to give me a hard time and asking me to pay $1 extra AGAIN for each tiny side of ranch. If the pricing was more reasonable I'd probably eat here fairly often, but as it is there are better options in the area. Don't know how the "atmosphere" rating could be a 5 for some of these reviews, it's just a takeout restaurant with one or two tables."

"If you need all halal menu then this place is a must. I know the new owner and he has a great sense of taste. Cannot go wrong with his recommendation. Loved the gyros pizza , the best i have had till date. The wings in mango sauce was just amazing. overall service and quality of pizza is top notch. the guy seriously loves his craft."

"Came here for the first time and the owner was working. He was super friendly! The food was EXCELLENT as well. The dough and sauce are made on site, and our whole family loved the food. The 8” personal pizza is perfect size for kids, and the 12” pizzas are much bigger than you would think. The four cheese with a side of their homemade garlic sauce was fantastic. The regular pepperoni was also very good. Looking forward to trying more of their huge selection!"

"Pizza was Perry good but seemed small for a large. Wings are good. Breadsticks are god and give me a little Caesar’s vibe except crisper. Jalapeño poppers are disappointing. It seems to be a panco batter and baked, but it’s only crisped on one side so the other is raw and crumbly. The soda flavor was out and the only alternatives were tea and grape which are wild. They “found” An orange in the back but the bottle was a little deflated and so was the carbonation enough though we did break the seal. The god want ready when it was supposed to be and the wings were handed over with the wrong flavor originally until we cited corrected it. Service wasn’t bad but nothing overly great either."