Captain’s Creamery 24123 Peachland Boulevard, Port Charlotte, FL 33954

"Best I've had. Outstanding flavors to choose from all popping with rich well balanced flavor. All Homemade ice cream! Homemade waffle cones too! Love stopping in to treat myself, always greeted by happy employees. Great prices, selection, portions, and taste! Fresh! Glad to have them in the neighborhood!!! Dairy free choices are excellent too, definitely taste like the real thing! Highly recommend! Thank you Captain! See you guys soon!"

"We came here based on the reviews. Everyone’s ice cream was just alright but props for cheap prices and reasonable portions especially the double scoop. The people working there were very friendly as well. They do have some unique flavors and the coffee Oreo is apparently their best seller. I had chocolate peanut butter which was good not great and shipwreck which had a variety of things in it including cookie dough and oreo."

"Seriously so delicious! I was served with a smile and was refreshed to hear that their ice cream and waffle cones are homemade on-site! Captain's Creamery has absolutely exceeded my expectations."

"Delicious, good quality ice cream. Neat selection of flavors you don't always come across like pumpkin Oreo. Service was friendly and prompt."

"Tasty, homemade ice cream served with a smile. The treats at Captain’s Creamery were so good. They have tons of flavors featuring several of their own creations like Ship Wreck and Salty Sea. The waffle cones are made fresh, and the portions are generous. It is in a great location considering there are other eateries within walking distance. The staff was very friendly and helpful, and the facilities were clean and tidy."