One if by Land, Two if by Sea

"Exceptional service with amazing food. Some of the best food I have had in NY. You are going to spend more here but you will not be disappointed. Live piano was very nice as well."

"Went here because it was my birthday and we were also celebrating my 1st year anniversary! I was not disappointed with the ambience. The atmosphere was perfectly romantic. The history of restaurant spoke for itself. The service was immaculate! Nick took care of us for the evening and let me tell you! He gave us the best service I’ve ever received to date. He was very timely with our meals and a big plus was that he showed us around the restaurant and give us a little history lesson. Nick thanks for making my birthday special. The kitchen did a fantastic job! I don’t know who the chef is but the food was well seasoned, well balanced, and the flavors paired so well with each other. Each meal was like an explosion in my mouth. I was not disappointed. Need less to say I did not need to put any salt and pepper on the food. Plus they surprised me with a complimentary dessert for my birthday. Management if you are seeing this, send compliments to the chef! Don’t think twice about booking a reservation. Totally recommend, the front of the house will take well care of you! Will be visiting again.✨"

"Now I understand why they call it the most romantic restaurant in NY! We celebrated our anniversary here and it was better than I expected. I can’t say I was blown away with the food, but doesn’t even matter. It was good and the menu was very different and creative. But the atmosphere, the ambiance, the way they host you… Our server was wonderful, pleasant and friendly. The same was for the busboys and food runners. They also let us take our time with our meals, let us enjoy our night and our conversation, which I appreciate very much. For the end they brought us a dessert saying “happy anniversary” which really put smile on our faces. Highly recommended!"

"Celebrated my 10 year wedding anniversary here this week and it was AMAZIN. From the moment we walked in we were greeted kindly and taken care of completely. The atmosphere is very romantic and really special. The food was very good. I enjoyed everything. Cannot wait to come back here and enjoy the experience again."

"This place is absolutely out of this world, the most magical romantic vibes. We had the tasting menu and every single course was beautifully flavored and presented. The courses were not rushed as they can be at other establishments so you really got to thoroughly enjoy each dish. It’s pricey but not as expensive as other tasting menus out there. The star of the show is the beef Wellington, it was absolute perfection. They also gave me a free dessert with a candle for my birthday, cute!"