Fat Pappy's

"Decent pizza, really friendly staff. Clean bathrooms which is always great."

"I've enjoyed their pizza until the last order that I placed. I paid over $40 for two large pizzas that came without sauce. If the roads hadn't been covered in ice I would've taken them back and gotten my money back. And from the beginning whoever is cutting the pizzas has no idea what they're doing because there's little tiny slices and large slices, nothing is cut evenly. They need to be more attentive to training new people to make the pizzas correctly and how to actually cut them correctly. For the prices that they charge they need to at least come with sauce on them and cut evenly.. Not sure if I will order from them again."

"Girlfriend and I decided to appeal to our craving for pizza here at Fat Pappy's. We got fried pickles and two personal sized pizzas. One was buffalo chicken style, and the other was a pesto tomato style. The pickle fries were tasty, and each pizza maintained great flavors. Felt the pizza dough could have been a little crispier, but that's nit-picking and personal preference. Overall, it was a good place to grab a pie and some apps. Heard their sandwiches are a must. Will go back to try them out. They also have an ice cream shop connected to the building.Oh, and the Seinfeld fans will love the easter egg."

"We stopped here for lunch and so glad we did. The pizza was fresh, hot & tasty. My daughter’s grilled cheese looked really good. Fast service and friendly! We will be back for sure!"

"The pizza was very tough and didn't have very much cheese, The waitress was Lame... She was more into To go orders and never came by to check on us to see if we needed anything. I'm a Top 10 Reviewer for Google Maps and I Don't Recommend this Place."