Island Thrift

"I've been coming here for years, and uses to find decent items at affordable prices. Not sure what has happened lately, but the prices are beyond out of control. Like $98 for a pair of jeans thar retail for $225, $68 for old undesirable lululemon. $38.99 for multiple patagonia fleece zip ups that the size tags have even faded and fleece is matted. Some of the stuff is priced at more than what it costs online. No thanks. I wish NY had bins like Goodwill in other states because this stuff would end up in them for pennies on the dollar."

"Employees are nice and store is pretty clean... But they don't have furniture anymore (?) And items are INSANELY overpriced... These are from the 1$ dollar store up the road, but they're trying to sell them 4$ each? If its not cheaper than new its just not worth it - no idea who is pricing these things or why they are pricing them way too high. try another thrift store or just try a regular store....tons of stuff you can buy new for WAY LESS MONEY somewhere else. Disappointed."

"This place used to be my favorite thrift shop. They used to have many antiques stuff with affordable prices. The prices of their merchandises went so high to the point that it’s cheaper to buy it new than buy it from them. Even though I never bought clothes from there, I was so curios to check the price on some of items. Thrift shop items are donations and it should be affordable to everyone. I saw a diversity of people looking at the price and shaking their heads. It’s so disappointing to see disadvantaged communities being embezzled from a place that should be their way to go for their basic needs. I give less than one star for the affordability of their prices."

"Really cool thrift store with a ton of options. I originally dropped by to drop off a mirror that we had and weren’t using but I figured I would take a look around while I was there and I was pleasantly surprised with how many things they were in stock. Everything is well laid out, everything appeared in great condition, and all the sections were laid out in a coherent manner."

"Absolutely love this place. Aside from being a thrift shop, they keep their items very clean and the place isn’t as dusty as others I’ve visited. All tags are different colors and on Some days certain colors go on sale 50% off. On Sundays there are the most colors on sale just a heads up in case you are planning to visit and that’s the best place to go. Bring your own bag, although they do provide bags you never know what kind of bag you’re going to get ( they have random ones you can reuse) and it’s best to bring a tote. I use heavy duty garbage bags because I always fill up atleast one with great finds. I spent $100 and got atleast $300-$400 worth of stuff. New shoes for work and button downs, clothes for vacation, cute bags and tons of home goods."