Jim's Deli 2554 Montauk Highway, Brookhaven, NY 11719

"Went in this morning with my son to order breakfast. I asked my son if they had any energy drinks, he says no...then this gremlin of a woman turns around and tells me, "maybe you should look harder before you speak"... 1st of all I wasn't even speaking to her and the nerve of her to talk to people like that. I believe her name is Georgia. Really boiled my blood this morning. If this is who represents this establishment, I most definitely will not go here again nor would I advise anyone else to."

"6/25/24 This place is no good!!! Not the first time it had happened it’s like a normal thing now. Placed an order at 11:20 and went to pick up at 12:00 and the forgot to make the order. If you plan on ordering anything with bacon CHECK it breakfast or lunch because when I order it’s NEVER on the sandwich but they have no problem charging you extra for it. Jim’s is a no go for me permanently!!"

"$12 for ham and Swiss on a roll? This place used to be my go to deli at the old location. Always a little pricey, but worth it. But today I stop in and decide to go for one of the specials, which is just ham with Swiss melted on top, on a roll. No sides, no drink, $11.94. And let's be clear, if it was worth $12, I'd just keep my mouth shut and enjoy it, but this? No. Mostly without taste, and it wasn't so packed that I would have had to save half. It was just lackluster and overpriced. This was my last time coming here."

"Randomly stopped in for an egg sandwich and they make a proper one at a fair price. The inside is an old school Long Island deli. Perfect, don’t change anything."

"I ordered a dozen sandwiches from here to take to the beach with my family and placed my order online and picked up the next day. The sandwiches were so perfectly wrapped and then also wrapped in plastic so transporting to the beach was so easy. Every sandwich was plentiful, dressed properly, had everything they were supposed to have. There was not one error or issue, and the quality was superb. This is my first time ordering from here, and I will not order from anywhere else going forward. It was a great experience, very pleased. I’m also very picky and have high standards. I manage food service so I tend to expect a lot and was not disappointed at all. Thank you to the staff for making our beach trip even better."