The Pie Store 100 Watchung Avenue, Montclair, NJ 07043
About the Business
Welcome to The Pie Store, Montclair's cherished destination for all things delicious and doughy. Nestled at 100 Watchung Avenue, Montclair, New Jersey, our bakery is a haven for pie enthusiasts and lovers of British treats alike. While Americans may associate pies with Thanksgiving, the tradition of wrapping sweet or savory fillings in flaky dough hails from across the Atlantic. At The Pie Store, we bring this rich heritage to your table with ease—simply warm up our pies in your oven and enjoy.
Our key lime pie is legendary, earning accolades that place it above even those found in Key West, Florida. It's a must-try for anyone seeking the perfect balance of tangy and sweet. But that's just the beginning of what we offer. Our banoffee pie has become a local favorite, enticing visitors to leave with bags full of our delightful offerings.
Beyond pies, The Pie Store is a treasure trove for anyone missing the flavors of the UK. From Dairy Milk chocolates and classic British sodas to HP sauces, curries, beans, and golden syrup, our shelves are stocked with a variety of imported goodies. Whether you're a local or just passing through, our friendly staff is here to make your visit memorable. Come discover a slice of the UK in the heart of Montclair, and take home a taste of tradition.
Photos
Location & Phone number
100 Watchung Avenue, Montclair, New Jersey 07043, United States
Hours open
Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
11:00 - 17:00
Wednesday:
11:00 - 17:00
Thursday:
11:00 - 17:00
Friday:
11:00 - 17:00
Saturday:
11:00 - 17:00
Sunday:
11:00 - 15:00
Reviews
"Lovely shop, variety of pies including meat pies. I had the small key lime pie. I wish I had gotten the medium. It was so fresh and tart. The Graham cracker crust was fresh, and the lime was so good. Also had the chocolate chip scone warmed it up. It was really good."
"Great selection of British foods, fresh bakery items, snacks, etc. Counter staff is cordial & helpful. Street parking is limited. There is a step up into the entrance and the shopping area inside is rather small so the store is not handicap accessible."
"I was in the area today and I had to stop at this bakery. I bought the small apple pie and I have to say that it is delicious, the crust is amazing and the filling as well, is one of the best apple pies I have ever had in my life, and they have also suggested to warm it up before eating it, and honestly it is even better warm. I definitely recommend everyone to stop by this little bakery if you are in the area. I wish I would live close by…Thank you!"
"Their key lime pie was my favorite ever. Thick but not sweet cream on top, rich and tart middle layer with satisfying lime shavings, and a buttery graham cracker crust. Also tried a strawberry scone, and a steal ale & mushroom pie, both looked amazing and tasted merely good. So, 4.5 stars, rounded up to 5 since my girlfriend, who shared all these with me, seemed outraged that I considered anything other than 5. Other notes: -All items bought cold, need to be warmed up at home. -Maximum 4 people inside at a time, and there was a slow moving line since some orders were large."
List of local businesses, places and services in New Jersey
⭐ business help 🔍 services ☎ phones 🕒 opening times ✍️reviews 🌍 addresses, locations 📷 photos