Mary's Pizza Shack

"Mary's quality seems to have gone downhill a bit. Pizza was ok, large salad is a fraction of the size it used to be, pesto bread sticks were ordered "crispy", but came out doughy and soggy. All of course for increased prices. Maybe just not worth the cost anymore. It's a shame because Mary's used to be awesome, what happened?"

"The pizza is absolutely worth the visit! So delicious. I got the vegetarian pizza and would absolutely get it again. The salad is not worth the price at all and the service was lacking at times. But highly recommend a visit for the pizza. I believe they offer fully vegetarian and vegan."

"Ok the Tuscan pizza is usually good. I said no chicken or carmalized onion. They had no sauce on it and an un godly amount of garlic muck on here. It was un edible. Also only got a ten dollar credit back when it was also 30 dollars."

"Love going here! I grew up in Windsor and going to Mary’s , moved away for 10 years and was so happy to see it was still there. Still delicious and our service from our waitress was just amazing. She had so much personality and was helpful to us at our table. I can’t remember her name and wish I did but she was a brunette and was taller and she was just great ! We ordered the chicken wings and pesto breadsticks on happy hour. Love the happy hour. 5 stars ( and of course their ranch is the best). Yum!! Worth every penny."

"Mary’s pizza has been a staple for us however recently they have declined. The food is actually pretty good when it’s hot. Upon arriving for my take out order the food was ready which was great but the pizza and breadsticks were cold and I arrived before the recommended time for pick up. I would rate Mary’s higher if they were more accurate with their time frames and they had better consistency."