Stone Soup Inn

"Loved this place. Loved David even more. So attentive, and willing to help! He truly loves his job and treats every guest like a celebrity. I’m so pleased with the cleanliness of the rooms, I never had to ask for anything extra, everything was exactly where it should be. We stayed in the carriage house, and it had plenty of room for the 3 of us for our girls trip. Breakfast was delicious and beautifully set up. The house was gorgeous. We will definitely be back next time we come to Indy!! Thank you Stone Soup Inn! Thank you David!!!"

"We stayed in one of the lofts, the room was great and spacious. Breakfast was continental with lots of choices and everything was fresh. The innkeeper, David, and all the staff were knowledgeable and and offered great ideas of things to do while we were in town. If I could leave more than 5 stars I would. This place is definitely going on the list of revisits."

"I stayed a night at the Stone Soup Inn with a group of gals for a girls night. We arrived mid afternoon on a Saturday and even though we were one of many group arriving at the same time, David the Innkeeper, welcomed us with a warm smile and took the time to talk to us and show us around the place. I was fascinated by how old the house was, and how the owner took great care in making sure that everything in the Inn felt warm and cozy, and it all matched the outside of the house. It was beautifully decorated. David answered all of our questions, and made sure we were comfortable, and knew that he was around if we needed anything. He definitely made our stay a good one. I can’t wait to come back with my husband and stay for more than a day."

"Our family booked three rooms for an overnight stay on a Saturday night in September and fell in love with the Inn. The staff at the Stone Soup Inn makes this a 5 star stay! David showed us through the Inn, how to access what we needed and even brought my sister-in-law a cup of coffee! The ladies who checked us in and out were great, we all felt welcome and right at home during our stay. The rooms, and the public areas are beautiful, we were lucky to have great weather and time to enjoy relaxing on the front porch. The breakfast table set up was elegant and the food was delicious. Wonderful experience, hope we can return for another stay soon."

"We were not sure whether to stay because a few of the reviews were mixed. But now that we’ve checked out, I can’t figure out how anyone had anything bad to say about the stone soup inn. The location was perfect, minutes from downtown. Close to the highway. We chose a loft for the private shower. The room was clean, and comfortable. The staff was so kind, even helped my husband lug our bags up both sets of stairs. There is also a self serve breakfast set up in the mornings 7-9:00, and 8-10 on saturdays. Another perk, is free off street parking. We would recommend this place again and again. I will preface this and say, if we had children with us, there wouldn’t have been enough room. But for 2 adults, this is the most perfect accommodations."