Justino's Pizzeria

"Cant recommend high enough! These folks took on a very ambitious delivery order for an event I was doing at Columbus circle, and were so professional and easy to work with. They accommodated every kind of allergy including dairy free and gluten free (even gave us new, wrapped pizza cutters for the GF pizza to avoid any cross contamination!). I only had to tell them the delivery times once, and they were punctual all 7 times throughout the day. And the pizza was delicious!"

"Came here after a show at Terminal 5, looking for any pizza place, and the pizza here was great! I got 2 margherita pizzas and a soda. The crust had the perfect crunch; the cheese was good; it was all well seasoned; and I got a big slice for $4-5. All in all, a damn good slice of pizza. The workers were also very nice and chill. There were a couple aggressive people trying to fight (for no reason), and they handled them like pros. The only con was that the crust could have had more seasoning, because it felt lacking. But overall, I really enjoyed this slice and the vibe at this pizzeria. What a happy surprise this was!"

"Too greasy!! Like it was dripping and all the grease collected on my plate. Slices are probably 30% bigger than other places. The cheese slice had less flavor and less sauce than other places and good amount of cheese with grease. There is a decent amount of space inside to sit and eat but the AC was not turned on. The door was kept open and I have no idea why one would have a hot slice in so much heat and humidity in month of July."

"A simple corner spot with good NY style pizza slices. Ordered 1 cheese slice and 1 pepperoni. Cost $8.05. Both slices were large and one slice would've sufficed. Thin crust, good outer crunch, melty cheese, flavorful sauce that wasn't too sweet or tangy. Indoor seating, customer restroom, and an ATM. They serve pasta, wings, and salads too."

"First time stop by, the store is very clean, service people are very nice, a slice of the pizza is big enough for a meal, very convenient location, restroom is available for customer. I like it, will try other slices next time."