Pier 49 Pizza

"We had a FANTASTIC experience eating here! The staff were extremely kind and accommodating (we had a gluten-free person in our group, and they went out of their way to make sure the food she ordered was okay for her). The all-you-can-eat option had tons of options; the staff even kept telling us when they were going to bring new pizza so we could get fresh slices. Every pizza we got had plenty of toppings. The taste of the pizza is absolutely second to none (we personally loved the Tourist pizza best of all). The pizzas here are definitely on the pricy side, but if we wanted cheap pizza, we would have gone somewhere else; we came here for gourmet pizza, and boy did we get it! Such a great experience; we will definitely be coming here again!"

"My favorite place in the world. The service is wonderful and the staff is so friendly. They feel like family. I would recommend this place 200%. The buffalo chicken is amazing"

"Pretty disappointed with the unlimited all you can eat lunch. The price is now up to $14.99. They had 2 pizza pans worth of pizza to choose from. As well, we were asked if we wanted a salad.... the sign says unlimited pizza, salad, and drinks---$14.99. But then when we said yes they told us that would be an extra dollar. That needs to be updated it that was the case. Didn't feel like the pizza had that much flavor or was special, prices were high for what you got, disappointed in the selection of options, and was sad that they didn't even have breadsticks for the unlimited lunch. If you're looking for a buffet style pizza lunch... this is not the right place for that. We had to wait for a worker to come up to the counter and tell them what pizza slice we wanted from the warming cabinet. Just different than what we were expecting. Also something weird is that they have multiple signs saying you get free breadsticks with the biggest pizza size purchase but others said you got breadsticks for $1. The marketing was confusing because they were everywhere but had conflicting information."

"Hands down, best restaurant experience I have had in MONTHS. Friendly from the start, I asked for something they didn’t “traditionally do” which I wasn’t aware of, and they told me they’d do it anyways for me. Impeccable service off the get go with that. Then upon delivering my pizza the person who rang me up at the register informed me that they were out of bacon which was on one of the slices I ordered and so they upgraded me to a large to make up for it….. without me even asking. This is hands down the BEST service I’ve gotten, potentially ever. They anticipated my needs, the pizza was PHENOMENAL, and overall I’d give this a 10 star review if I could. Thank you!!"

"So glad we came! There is new ownership and they are great, very friendly and customer oriented. The restaurant is clean and a complete vibe. There are so many specialty pizza options, made with sourdough! We did the “dinner for 2” special and definitely had leftovers. The cheese bread was divine! The restaurant is closed on Sundays and is partnered with Doordash, Grubhub, & Slice. Family friendly! 10/10 recommend"