Valentina's Pizzeria & Wine Bar 25783 Huntsville Brownsferry Road, Madison, AL 35756

"This might be the 2nd worst pizza I’ve ever ordered. I ordered for pick up. The pizza was burnt and I’m not talking the nice Fiero wood-fired pizza oven char. I’m talking BURNT. In addition, I actually had to look for the cheese on the pizza…. Threw it away and made hot dogs for dinner."

"Pizza was amazing!! Service was outstanding by everyone there. A must try in the area. Had the garlic knots, the godfather and tropical mix pizza."

"We've been a few times, but the quality has been steadily declining each time we visit. The first two times we went (in the old location), they were still using the wood fire oven, and the pizzas were easily the best we'd had in Alabama. The last two times (once in the old location, and tonight in the new), however, they are only cooking them in an oven. The pizza is notably worse, and definitely not worth the near $30 price tag. I feel like all the awards they tout are a little misleading now, since they definitely aren't cooked the same way they used to. Overall, it's not the worst, but I don't think we'll be back."

"Valentina’s is hands down the best Pizza around. From the Garlic Knots & meatballs to the crafted cocktails, you will enjoy the experience. Joe Carlucci hit a home run with his fabulous pizzas and gorgeous new restaurant. Make the drive…you won’t be disappointed!"

"Our team had a great time at Valentina's! Some of the best pizza in the Huntsville area. Appetizers (especially the 5 Boroughs and the Meatballs), desserts, and drinks were all fantastic. Every pizza was great, but the Award Winner stole the show. Joseph & team took very good care of us for the 2.5 hours we were there. Apparently our team spent enough money to unlock "Sicilian Status", where they bring out the Valentina's merch. Hopefully you'll see our picture on the wall when you visit Valentina's over the holidays."