Castiglia's Italian Restaurant

"Made reservations for a party of 20 for a Saturday dinner. The staff was very accommodating to our needs. We brought a 2 tier cake and asked them to store it while we ate dinner. The server took a picture to show us that the cake was stored safely. Our server, Tarah was wonderful with our group and was very quick with drink refills and with our meals. The food was delicious as always. The new renovations, making the eat in area bigger were perfect. We will continue to enjoy our experiences with this wonderful restaurant! Thank you Tarah for all that you did above and beyond our expectations!"

"Thank you so much to the entire team at Castiglia's tonight! Each of you made the appreciation meal for our leadership board, ministry staff, and spouses a fantastic time together! We praise the Lord for His gift of you to us and our community. Blessings Pastor Steve Front Royal Church of the Nazarene"

"Castiglias is my favorite restaurant! Their portions are huge for the price, and I've never been disappointed with a visit. They deliver out to the mountains (which is a huge plus, since many other restaurants in froro don't). The decor is nice, but simple. It's not over the top, which to me is preferable. I've never had any problem with the service, the couple times I've had issues (such as a mishap with online ordering) were handled quickly and without argument. The food isn't necessarily fancy looking in presentation, but that doesn't matter to me if it's delicious! I'd personally skip this location when it comes to pizza, but I highly recommend their generously filled calzones and strombolis, as well as their bread sticks, which are chewy and fluffy and perfectly seasoned. Heck, I don't even like fries that much, and I think theirs are great. However, when it comes to appetizers, I'd pass on the mozzarella sticks. They aren't terrible or anything, but the other options I suggested are much better (in my opinion). This is my go-to location for any celebration dinner or hangouts with friends. Great comfort food, great prices, and I've never left without feeling completely stuffed and satisfied. I highly recommend trying it out if you haven't already! Support local small businesses when you can, especially when they're as outstanding as this one! Pictured: Bread sticks, pepperoni roll"

"I wanna start off by saying I used to love this place and would recommend it to many people that live around town, relatives and the like. That being said, today was a very poor experience. A week and a half ago, I called and ordered the same thing as always: 2 hot subs and an appetizer sampler totaling out at $31.37 plus tip out the door. Fast forward to today, I made the exact same order for pickup and was totaled out to $41.xx. Upon arriving and speaking with staff, we discovered that they were actually inadvertently charging for toppings that come included in the items. Worked things out with them after discovering that a new point of sale system is being worked with. I understand that after working in the industry, new point of sale systems can be terrible. So I just pay and get on down the road. Get home and discover the wrong topping on one sub. I asked for a shake of red pepper flakes added into steak and cheese meat to give a little spice while cooking it up, reveived roasted red peppers at a nice upcharge. Noted as well that the cheese that was double charged for was all stuck to the paper of the sub wrapping. This required the removal of the cheese that was paid for to avoid eating the paper. Wrong sauce provided with app sampler. Just over all poor, overpriced, poor experience."

"Got to this restaurant on our way home from the Luray Caverns. Very simply looking restaurant but what a pleasant surprise! Very friendly service, amazing Italian food, each and every appetizer and meal we ordered was incredibly delicious! We enjoyed every piece and every slice! Not to mention the homemade bread (compliment from the restaurant) My family was pleasantly surprised. Definitely recommend this place!"