Heidi's Inn

"My husband, two dogs and I had an EPIC stay at Heidi's Inn and will return soon! All boxes checked for a 5 star rating! Easy access to and from Interstate 84, super clean and spacious rooms, kind, friendly, helpful, and welcoming staff, beautiful, well-kept grounds with large, pet friendly areas. A private entrance to our room made our stay with dogs much more comfortable and accommodating. Great restaurants, a grocery, and gas stations nearby. Heidi's Inn is a WINNER!"

"Keep in mind I lived in Brewster for the better part of going on 69 years. Most people who know me know I'm NOT a sensitive  type of guy. I've slept in open air on top of a picnic table and woke up more refreshed then I did here. BUT..... Good things: The door locked, the water got hot & the tub drain worked. Bad things: Everything else. No water pressure so what good is plenty of hot water. Q-tips are not really necessary because you lack enough water pressure to enter the ear canal. Filthy. Still flattened humongous mosquito on wall in bathroom that kind of resembles the thing on top of the entrance sign. I "assume" it was killed by last tenant because the cleaner had just left. Looks like blood on bathroom entrance moulding. Some soap was supplied but damned if I could get it to become soapy. Ac worked but sounded like a diesel truck starting all night long every time it fired up for cooling. The mattress, which was covered by a top comforter thing with holes in it, felt like it is leftover from maybe the 70's with no support and tends to try to make you roll onto the floor which we attempted to keep anything of value including skin from touching. In order to maintain bed contact we slept towards the center of the bed so being charged for a king size bed is ridiculous when you can only use the twin bed size area in the center. Flickering lights, all of em, every time they were on for any reason. All this "after" we checked in and then found the door was left open on 90° day after cleaning with no cleaner in sight. Closed door after turning ac on 72° and had to leave to stay cool for a few hours. Informed the front desk personel. Came back after those few hours and someone had entered our room and switched the ac OFF. Place is a real dump and for the money you pay it definitely was not worth it but this time we had no choice. Probably should have tried for another room OR MOTEL but supposedly this was the only available room."

"Do not let the price fool you. This is a dirty, dank, musty motel that threatens to make you and your belongings smell, and your dreams die. This is not nice, cute, or modern. It was 30 years ago, it is now dirty and overpriced. Our room smelled like mildew, had literal trash that hadn’t been cleaned (used soap, wrappers), the sheets and blankets were far past their prime, and the power was out for most of our stay. Some rooms had access to a back up generator. Ours did not. We asked to move to another room and the hotel offered us nothing. Clearly riding on an old legacy, now gross and no one seems to care."

"We came from Canada for a 4-night stay, to see family and revisit the area where I grew up. Our stay at Heidi's was delightful. The garden areas were lovely, the staff friendly and helpful, the room modern and attractive, and so immaculately CLEAN!! I cannot stress enough how clean Heidi's Inn is. This will be our go-to place whenever we're in the Westchester-Putnam area."

"Excellent choice to stay in the area. Room was very clean, loved the retro feel of the motel setting. Huge fireplace in sitting area, shame it was summer and wasn't in use. The Mexican restaurant next door was a bust. So busy you couldn't find parking. Continental breakfast was great in comparison to other hotels. I would definitely stay again."