TOP 30 Best Unique thrift finds in New York

J&D Thrift Shop And Cargo Express is a unique institution located at 39 North Street in Middletown, New York. This one-stop shop offers a wide variety of thrift items including clothing, furniture, household goods, and more. In addition to their thrift offerings, they also provide cargo express services for shipping packages domestically and internationally. Whether you're looking for a bargain or need to send a package, J&D Thrift Shop And Cargo Express has you covered with their convenient location and friendly service.

The Thrift Shop & Barn @ St. Gerard Majella is a charming store located at 316 Terryville Road in Port Jefferson Station, New York. This institution offers a wide variety of second-hand items, including clothing, accessories, household goods, and more. Visitors can browse through the aisles of the barn and shop for unique treasures at affordable prices. The proceeds from sales at The Thrift Shop & Barn @ St. Gerard Majella support the mission and programs of the St. Gerard Majella Parish. Stop by today to find great deals and support a worthy cause!

New To You Thrift Store is a hidden gem located at 726 Washington Street in Utica, New York. This store is a treasure trove for those looking to find unique and affordable items. From clothing and accessories to household items and furniture, you never know what you might discover at New To You Thrift Store. Whether you're on the hunt for a vintage statement piece or just browsing for a good deal, this store has something for everyone. Come visit us today and see what treasures you can find!

Uncle Al's Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 3275 Franklin Avenue in Millbrook, New York. This hidden gem offers a wide variety of secondhand treasures, from vintage clothing and accessories to unique home decor items and collectibles. Whether you're looking for a one-of-a-kind piece or just love the thrill of the hunt, Uncle Al's is the perfect place to browse and discover something special. With friendly staff and affordable prices, this thrift shop is a must-visit destination for bargain hunters and vintage enthusiasts alike.

CAREERS Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 208 New York 52 in Carmel Hamlet, New York. This unique institution offers a wide variety of gently used items, including clothing, accessories, home goods, and more. All proceeds from the thrift shop go towards supporting individuals with disabilities in finding meaningful employment opportunities through the CAREERS organization. Visit us today to shop for a cause and discover hidden treasures while supporting a great cause!

Christ Episcopal Church Thrift Store, located at 65 Washington Avenue in Suffern, New York, is a store that offers a variety of gently used items at affordable prices. The store has recently reopened its Housewares section, which has been fully redesigned and beautifully decorated. In addition to housewares, the store also offers a selection of men's and women's clothing and shoes. The store is currently accepting donations of kitchenware, small appliances, cookware, pots and pans, utensils, men's clothing, and shoes. Donations can be dropped off on Tuesdays and Saturdays during the store's operating hours. It is important to note that the store does not accept furniture, hazardous materials, TVs, mattresses, pillows, toys for children under nine years of age, or weapons of any kind.

Grace's Thrift Shop, located at 10 South Broadway in Nyack, New York, is a beloved institution that has been serving the community since 1968. Founded by members of Grace Episcopal Church, Nyack, the shop is an integral part of the Church's outreach program. The shop offers a wide range of items including clothing, shoes, housewares, art, collectibles, toys and games, jewelry, and more. At Grace's Thrift Shop, cleanliness and quality are top priorities. Only items that are in good condition and suitable for resale are accepted. Donations are carefully curated to ensure that customers find great deals on unique and affordable items.

St. Luke's Thrift Shop, located at 409 Pine Street in Jamestown, New York, is a charitable store operated by St. Luke's Episcopal Church. This outreach ministry transforms donated items into funds that benefit the Jamestown community. With the help of dedicated volunteers from the parish and the community, the thrift shop donates around $25,000 annually to local organizations that support education, food assistance, and community services. The shop is open for shoppers on Wednesdays through Fridays from 10 am to 2 pm, and accepts donations on Tuesdays from 9 am to noon. Visit St. Luke's Thrift Shop to shop for a cause and support the local community.

Commack Methodist Church Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 484 Town Line Road in Commack, New York. Offering a wide array of gently used items at affordable prices, this thrift shop is run by the local Methodist church and serves as a wonderful resource for the community. From clothing and accessories to household goods and furniture, you never know what treasures you may find at this hidden gem. Stop by and support a good cause while scoring great deals on unique items.

The Country Monkey Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 322 Main Street in Schoharie, New York. This hidden gem offers a wide selection of unique and affordable items, including clothing, home decor, accessories, and more. Whether you're looking for a vintage treasure or a one-of-a-kind gift, you're sure to find something special at this cozy thrift shop. Come browse our shelves and see what treasures you can uncover at The Country Monkey Thrift Shop!

The Thrift Shop for Mather Hospital, located at 75 North Country Road in Port Jefferson, New York, is a store that supports the renowned Mather Hospital. Mather Hospital has been recognized as one of America's 250 Best Hospitals for 2024, placing it in the top 5% nationwide. The hospital has received a generous $50,000 gift from its medical staff towards the construction of a new Emergency Department. The institution has recently changed the name of its physician practices to Mather Medical Group, further enhancing its connection to the community. The Thrift Shop offers a variety of items for sale, with proceeds benefiting the hospital's initiatives. Additionally, the hospital hosts events such as the PJCC Health & Wellness Fest and informational seminars on topics like bariatric surgery. Free services such as Medicare counseling and blood pressure screenings are also available to the public. Visit The Thrift Shop for Mather Hospital to support a leading healthcare institution while finding great deals on quality items.

Hearts Thrift Store - Hearts for the Homeless Thrift Store is a unique institution located at 2217 Sheridan Drive, Buffalo, New York, United States. This is not your average thrift store, as it offers a friendly staff, encouraging music, and unique secondhand treasures that you can't find in big box stores. All proceeds from the store go directly to Hearts for the Homeless®, which provides meals with dignity through their mobile soup kitchen and homeless shelter partnerships in Western New York. You can support their mission by shopping, donating gently used items, or joining their Loyalty Program for exclusive discounts and rewards. With a color-coded tag system offering 50% off on selected items, shopping at Hearts Thrift Store is not only a great deal but also a way to give back to the community. Customers have praised the quality of merchandise, affordable prices, and the charitable work done by Hearts for the Homeless. Overall, this thrift store is a wonderful establishment that Buffalo should be proud to have.

SK Odds & Ends Thrift Shop is a charming and eclectic thrift store located at 10 Main Street in Kings Park, New York. Our shop offers a wide variety of clothing, home goods, and unique items at affordable prices. Whether you're looking for trendy fashion pieces or one-of-a-kind treasures for your home, you're sure to find something special at our store. Stop by and browse our ever-changing inventory to discover hidden gems and great deals. Shop with us and support sustainable shopping practices while scoring amazing finds.

Thrift 2 Fight is a unique store located at 48 Broadway in Tivoli, New York, United States. This institution is not just your typical thrift store - it is a place where you can shop for a cause. With a wide variety of gently used clothing, accessories, household items, and more, Thrift 2 Fight offers a sustainable shopping experience that also supports a great cause. By shopping at Thrift 2 Fight, you are not only finding great deals on quality items, but you are also contributing to the fight against poverty and supporting local communities in need. So come visit Thrift 2 Fight and shop with purpose!

Dream Finds Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 333A Crescent Street in New York, United States. This unique thrift shop is a treasure trove of pre-loved items waiting to be discovered. From vintage clothing and accessories to home decor and collectibles, there is something for everyone at Dream Finds. With a constantly changing inventory, every visit is sure to uncover new and exciting finds. Come explore and uncover your own dream finds at this hidden gem of a thrift shop.

Upper EastSide Thrift shop is a charming store located at 1670 1st Avenue in the heart of New York City. This hidden gem offers a wide selection of pre-loved clothing, accessories, home goods, and more at affordable prices. Whether you're looking for a vintage piece to add to your wardrobe or searching for unique home decor items, this thrift shop has something for everyone. Come explore the treasures waiting to be discovered at Upper EastSide Thrift shop today!

Welcome to Family Finds & Consignment Shop, located at 4807 Lee Valley Road in New York, United States. We are excited to have you explore our hidden gem in Taberg, New York. Whether you are a seasoned bargain hunter or a first-time consignment shopper, we promise you an unforgettable experience. At Family Finds, we take pride in curating a diverse collection of pre-loved items, including fashion-forward clothing, unique home decor, and much more. Our shelves are always stocked with carefully selected consignment treasures, just waiting to find their new loving homes.

Topsy Turvy Thrift is a unique thrift store located at 960 Violet Avenue in Haviland, New York. Our store offers a wide variety of gently used clothing, accessories, household items, and more at affordable prices. With a constantly changing inventory, you never know what treasures you might find at Topsy Turvy Thrift! Visit us today and experience the thrill of shopping in a store where things are always a bit topsy-turvy.

A Second Chance Thrift Shop is a charming store located in Colonie, New York, United States. We offer a wide selection of gently used clothing, accessories, home goods, and more at affordable prices. Our mission is to give items a second chance at life while also giving back to the community. Shop with us and support a great cause!

Rescued Treasures Elmore SPCA Thrift Store is a unique and heartwarming store located at 37 Clinton Street in Plattsburgh, New York. This special institution offers a wide variety of gently used items, including clothing, furniture, home decor, and more, all at affordable prices. By shopping at Rescued Treasures, customers not only find great deals but also support the Elmore SPCA in their mission to rescue and care for animals in need. With every purchase, visitors are helping to make a difference in the lives of animals while also finding their own treasures. Visit Rescued Treasures Elmore SPCA Thrift Store today and shop for a cause!

Nothing New Thrift Shop is a unique and trendy store located at 4885 Arthur Kill Road in New York, United States. Our shop offers a wide variety of gently used clothing, accessories, home goods, and more at affordable prices. With a constantly changing inventory, you never know what hidden gems you may find at Nothing New Thrift Shop. Whether you're looking to update your wardrobe, decorate your home, or just enjoy a fun shopping experience, our store has something for everyone. Visit us today and discover the thrill of thrifting at Nothing New Thrift Shop.

Barn Again Thrift Store is a unique institution located at 853 Dutchess Turnpike in Arlington, New York, United States. This establishment is a combination of a clothing store, general contractor, and home goods store, offering a wide variety of items for shoppers to browse and purchase. For any general inquiries, customers can contact The Barn at (845) 635-9630 or Barn Again at (845) 473-1501. If you have items to donate, please call (845) 473-1501 for more information. Visit Barn Again Thrift Store for a one-of-a-kind shopping experience and to support a good cause.

Glorybeezzz Thrift With Atwist is a unique and eclectic institution located at 861 Merrick Road in Baldwin, New York. This one-of-a-kind establishment is a clothing store, home goods store, jewelry store, and more, all rolled into one. Offering a wide variety of gently used and vintage items, Glorybeezzz Thrift With Atwist is the perfect place to find hidden treasures and unique pieces to add to your wardrobe or home decor. With a constantly changing inventory, you never know what gems you'll discover at this must-visit destination. Come explore and shop at Glorybeezzz Thrift With Atwist today!

Tool Thrift Shop is a one-of-a-kind store located at 122 Fairport Village Landing in Fairport, New York. This unique institution specializes in selling a wide variety of new and gently used tools at affordable prices. Whether you're a professional tradesperson or a DIY enthusiast, Tool Thrift Shop has everything you need to tackle any project. From power tools to hand tools, gardening equipment to automotive supplies, you'll find it all at this hidden gem in Fairport. Visit Tool Thrift Shop today and discover the perfect tool for your next job!

Free to Thrift is a unique thrift store located at 1050 Morton Boulevard in Kingston, New York, United States. Our mission is to elevate our community by creating opportunities for neighbors to share what's good with each other. We believe in sharecycling, or wecycle, where items that come through our store are passed on to others rather than being sent to a donation bin or landfill. By keeping resources circulating, we are preserving the value of the labor, sacrifice, and commitment that went into creating these items. At Free to Thrift, we are committed to fostering an inclusive environment where everyone is welcome and valued. We ensure that our staff are paid a living wage and work in humane conditions. Additionally, we donate a minimum of 10% of our gross sales to local organizations, charities, families, or individuals in need. This is our way of showing our community that they are seen, valued, and supported.

Explosive Bargains & Thrift is a one-of-a-kind store located at 127 Smithtown Boulevard in Nesconset, New York. Our institution offers a unique shopping experience with a wide variety of items at unbeatable prices. From clothing and accessories to home decor and electronics, you'll find everything you need and more at Explosive Bargains & Thrift. Our friendly staff is always ready to help you find the perfect deal, so come visit us today and see why we're the go-to destination for savvy shoppers in the United States.

Village Thrift is a charming store located at 12 North Road in Bloomingburg, New York, offering a wide selection of second-hand clothing, home goods, and unique treasures. With a welcoming atmosphere and affordable prices, Village Thrift is the perfect place to find hidden gems and support sustainable shopping practices. Whether you're on the hunt for vintage fashion pieces or looking to furnish your home on a budget, Village Thrift has something for everyone. Visit us today and discover the joy of thrift shopping!

Tappan Zee Thrift Shop is a charming store located at 454 Piermont Avenue in Piermont, New York. This hidden gem offers a wide variety of gently used items at affordable prices, including clothing, accessories, home decor, and more. Whether you're on the hunt for unique vintage pieces or searching for a bargain, Tappan Zee Thrift Shop has something for everyone. Stop by and browse their ever-changing inventory to find your next great find!

Thrift NYC is a unique store located at 226 East 14th Street in New York City, offering a wide selection of secondhand clothing, accessories, and home goods. With a focus on sustainability and affordability, Thrift NYC provides a curated collection of pre-loved items for shoppers looking to reduce waste and find one-of-a-kind treasures. Whether you're searching for vintage clothing, retro furniture, or quirky knick-knacks, Thrift NYC has something for everyone. Visit us today and discover the joy of thrift shopping in the heart of New York City.

Saint Francis Thrift Store is a hidden gem located on 202 West 97th Street in New York City. This quaint store offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, household items, and accessories at affordable prices. With a mission to serve the community and support local charities, Saint Francis Thrift Store is a place where you can shop for a cause. Whether you're looking for unique vintage finds or everyday essentials, you'll be sure to find something special at this beloved neighborhood store. So come on in and shop with a purpose at Saint Francis Thrift Store.