The 30 Best Luxury fire island rentals in New York

Fire Island House Rentals is a premier real estate and travel agency located at 19 Dorothy Street in Nesconset, New York. Specializing in luxury vacation rentals on the beautiful Fire Island, our agency offers a wide range of stunning properties for visitors to choose from. Whether you are looking for a cozy beachfront cottage or a spacious oceanfront mansion, we have the perfect accommodations to suit your needs. Our team of experienced agents are dedicated to providing exceptional service and ensuring that your stay on Fire Island is nothing short of unforgettable. Contact us today to book your dream vacation rental!

Fire Island Vacation Rentals by Vacasa is a premier real estate and travel agency located at 510 Broadhollow Road in Melville, New York. Specializing in luxury vacation rentals on the beautiful Fire Island, they offer a wide range of accommodation options to suit every traveler's needs. From cozy beachfront cottages to spacious oceanfront villas, Fire Island Vacation Rentals by Vacasa has something for everyone. With top-notch customer service and a commitment to excellence, they are the go-to choice for those looking to experience the ultimate beach getaway on Fire Island. Book your dream vacation rental today with Fire Island Vacation Rentals by Vacasa and make memories that will last a lifetime.

Located at 22 Atlantic Walk in Fire Island, New York, The Madison Fire Island Pines is a luxurious lodging option in the heart of the vibrant gay resort community. Recommended by Travel and Leisure, this exclusive compound offers light-filled and modern rooms with amenities such as air conditioning, private bathrooms, mini fridges, streaming television, and high-speed internet. With 17-foot-high ceilings, custom wood floors, and a wall of glass providing ample sunlight, The Madison creates a welcoming and stylish atmosphere for guests to enjoy. The property boasts a beautiful swimming pool on the main deck, as well as a stunning roof deck and other outdoor spaces for relaxation.

Watch Hill Fire Island Campground & Safari Tent Glamping is a picturesque institution located on Burma Road in Patchogue, New York, United States. This campground and lodging facility offers a unique experience for those looking to immerse themselves in nature. Reservations for wilderness/backcountry camping can be made online at www.recreation.gov, with a cost-recovery fee required for each reservation. The campground is divided into two zones within the Otis Pike Fire Island High Dune Wilderness, the east, and west zones. Access to these camping areas can be obtained through the Wilderness Visitor Center or Watch Hill. For those looking for additional camping options, Smith Point County Park is also available.

The Fire Island Boatel Kismet is a charming lodging option located at 110 East Lighthouse Walk in Fire Island, New York. This unique establishment offers a cozy and comfortable stay for guests looking to unwind and relax in a picturesque setting. With its convenient location near the water, guests can enjoy easy access to the beach and stunning views of the surrounding area. The Fire Island Boatel Kismet is the perfect choice for those seeking a peaceful retreat away from the hustle and bustle of city life.

The Palms Hotel Fire Island is a charming lodging establishment nestled at 168 Cottage Walk in the picturesque Ocean Beach, New York. This boutique hotel offers a serene and comfortable retreat for guests looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life. With its prime location on Fire Island, guests can enjoy easy access to the beach, shops, and restaurants. The Palms Hotel boasts cozy rooms, friendly staff, and a relaxing atmosphere, making it the perfect destination for a peaceful getaway. Whether you're looking to unwind by the ocean or explore the vibrant local community, The Palms Hotel Fire Island is the ideal choice for your next vacation.

The Fire Island Beach House is a luxurious institution located at 25 Cayuga Street in Fire Island, New York, United States. This institution offers a unique combination of a bar, restaurant, food, and lodging services. The King Standard rooms provide ground floor or pool views through oversized Anderson windows, with easy access to the beach just steps away. Each room features a king bed, custom furniture, rain shower, bath products, and modern finishes. The Oceanview King Standard rooms offer stunning ocean views, while the Double Full Standard rooms are perfect for families or groups. The Queen Suite and King Suite rooms provide luxury and privacy, with spacious layouts and premium amenities. The Double Queen Suite Ocean View rooms offer breathtaking ocean views and the Double Queen Suite Superior is a one-of-a-kind room with direct beach access. For a laid-back beach experience, guests can stay in the Beach Bungalow, a two-bedroom bungalow with a private deck and easy beach access. With complimentary Wi-Fi, smartphone chargers, and top-notch services, the Fire Island Beach House is the perfect destination for a relaxing getaway.

Fire Island Living Inc is a premier institution located in Saltaire, New York, offering a range of services including lodging, real estate, and travel assistance. Situated at 207 Anchor Walk, this institution provides top-notch accommodations, expert real estate guidance, and personalized travel planning for those looking to experience the beauty and charm of Fire Island. Whether you are seeking a relaxing getaway, looking to invest in property, or planning your next vacation, Fire Island Living Inc is your one-stop destination for all your needs. Visit us today and let us help you make the most of your Fire Island experience.

D.Katen Fire Island Properties, Ltd. is a premier institution located at 42 Harbor Walk in New York, United States. Specializing in Fire Island rentals and sales, they offer a wide range of properties for vacationers looking to experience the beauty of Fire Island. As a general contractor, real estate agency, and travel agency all in one, D.Katen Fire Island Properties, Ltd. provides exceptional service and expertise to help clients find the perfect rental or purchase on this picturesque island. Whether you are looking for a weekend getaway or a permanent vacation home, D.Katen Fire Island Properties, Ltd. has the resources and knowledge to make your dream a reality.

Luxury Fire Island Homes is a premier institution offering top-notch services in Fire Island sales and Fire Island rentals. Located at 786 Evergreen Walk in Ocean Beach, New York, this institution is a one-stop shop for all your real estate needs. Whether you are looking to buy or rent a luxury property on Fire Island, their team of experts is here to help. With services ranging from finance and legal assistance to general contracting and travel arrangements, Luxury Fire Island Homes is dedicated to providing a seamless and stress-free experience for their clients. Contact them today to find your dream home on Fire Island.

Fire Island Vacation Homes is a premier lodging, real estate, and travel agency located at 38 Oneida Street on Fire Island, New York. Our institution specializes in providing luxurious vacation homes for your perfect getaway on this beautiful island. Whether you are looking for a cozy beachfront cottage or a spacious oceanfront villa, we have a wide range of options to suit your needs. Our dedicated team is committed to ensuring that your stay on Fire Island is unforgettable, offering top-notch customer service and personalized recommendations for dining, activities, and more. Book your dream vacation with Fire Island Vacation Homes today and experience the ultimate relaxation and luxury on this stunning island destination.

Fire Island Sales & Rentals is a reputable real estate agency located at 633 Bay Walk in Ocean Beach, New York. Specializing in property sales and rentals on the beautiful Fire Island, this agency offers a wide range of options for those looking to buy or rent a vacation home or investment property. With a team of experienced and knowledgeable real estate agents, Fire Island Sales & Rentals provides exceptional service and expertise to help clients find the perfect property to suit their needs. Whether you are looking for a beachfront bungalow or a luxury waterfront estate, Fire Island Sales & Rentals has the resources and expertise to make your real estate dreams a reality.

Welcome to Ocean Bay Park Sales and Rentals - Luxury Fire Island Homes, your premier destination for exquisite real estate opportunities in the heart of Fire Island. Nestled at 63 Bayview Avenue, Ocean Beach, New York, we specialize in providing unparalleled real estate services, including luxury home sales, rentals, and comprehensive property management. Our expert team, with extensive experience in finance, general contracting, and legal matters, ensures that every aspect of your real estate journey is handled with the utmost professionalism and care. Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or rent a stunning beachfront property, our dedicated agents are here to guide you through every step of the process.

Welcome to Fire Island Tiki Boat, your ultimate gateway to an unforgettable aquatic adventure! Nestled in the charming community of Ocean Beach, New York, at 89 Bungalow Lane, our travel agency specializes in crafting unique and memorable experiences on the picturesque waters surrounding Fire Island. At Fire Island Tiki Boat, we invite you to embark on a journey like no other aboard our one-of-a-kind tiki boat. Whether you're planning a relaxing afternoon cruise, a lively celebration, or a romantic sunset escape, our experienced crew is dedicated to ensuring your time with us is both enjoyable and extraordinary. Our tiki boat is designed to provide a laid-back, tropical atmosphere, complete with comfortable seating, a shaded bar area, and panoramic views of the stunning coastline.

Welcome to Atlantique Fire Island, a serene and picturesque park located in the heart of Fire Island, New York. Nestled at the address 11706, our park offers a perfect escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life, providing visitors with a unique blend of natural beauty and recreational opportunities. Atlantique Fire Island is renowned for its pristine beaches, lush greenery, and breathtaking views, making it an ideal destination for both relaxation and adventure. Whether you're looking to unwind on the sandy shores, explore the scenic trails, or enjoy a picnic with family and friends, Atlantique has something for everyone. Our park features well-maintained facilities, including picnic areas, restrooms, and designated spots for various outdoor activities. For those who love water sports, the surrounding waters offer ample opportunities for swimming, kayaking, and paddleboarding.

Welcome to Island Properties-Pines Inc, your trusted real estate agency located at 37 Fire Island Boulevard, Sayville, New York. Nestled in the heart of the picturesque Fire Island, we specialize in providing exceptional real estate services tailored to meet your needs. Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or rent a property on this beautiful island, our team of experienced professionals is here to guide you every step of the way. At Island Properties-Pines Inc, we pride ourselves on our deep local knowledge, personalized service, and commitment to helping you find your perfect island retreat or investment opportunity. Discover the unparalleled charm of Fire Island with us and let our expertise turn your real estate dreams into reality. Visit us today and experience the warmth and dedication that sets Island Properties-Pines Inc apart.

Welcome to VP Fire Island Pines, your premier real estate agency nestled in the heart of Fire Island, New York. Located at 36 Fire Island Boulevard, our agency is dedicated to helping you discover your dream property in this unique and vibrant community. Whether you are looking to buy, sell, or rent, our team of experienced professionals is committed to providing personalized service and expert guidance every step of the way. At VP Fire Island Pines, we understand the allure of this stunning location, known for its beautiful beaches, lively atmosphere, and tight-knit community. Our deep local knowledge and extensive network enable us to offer a diverse range of properties to suit various tastes and budgets. From charming beach cottages to luxurious waterfront estates, we have something for everyone.

Welcome to Douglas Elliman Real Estate Office in Ocean Beach, Fire Island, NY. Conveniently located at 937 Bay View Walk, Ocean Beach, our office is your trusted partner for all real estate needs in this beautiful coastal community. As a premier real estate agency, we specialize in helping clients find their dream homes, vacation properties, and investment opportunities in the picturesque surroundings of Fire Island. Our team of experienced and dedicated real estate professionals is committed to providing personalized service and expert guidance throughout the buying, selling, or renting process. We pride ourselves on our in-depth knowledge of the local market and our ability to offer tailored solutions that meet the unique needs of each client.

Welcome to Wallace Real Estate Fire Island Homes, your trusted partner in finding the perfect property on Fire Island. Located at 481 Bayberry Walk, Ocean Beach, New York, our family-owned and operated real estate agency has been serving the Fire Island community for over 50 years. With Dana, Megan, and Dylan at the helm, we are dedicated to meeting your real estate needs year-round. Explore the beauty and tranquility of Fire Island, a unique destination that seamlessly blends relaxation with adventure. Whether you’re seeking a summer retreat, a permanent home, or an investment opportunity, Fire Island offers a diverse range of properties. From charming beach cottages to luxurious waterfront estates, there's something for everyone. Our expert team is here to guide you through the real estate process, ensuring you find the perfect property to suit your lifestyle and budget.

HTR Niagara Campground & Resort is a premier camping destination located at 2659 Whitehaven Road, Grand Island, New York, United States. Conveniently situated between Niagara Falls and Buffalo, NY, HTR Niagara offers luxurious lodging options such as log cabin rentals, stylish yurts, spacious RV sites, and cozy tent campsites. Rated as one of the top lodging locations in the Greater Niagara Region, HTR Niagara is dedicated to providing a memorable family vacation experience. One of the most popular events at HTR Niagara is the Pumpkin Harvest Weekends, featuring activities such as campground bonfires, cider and donuts, wagon rides, pumpkin patches, scarecrow competitions, and more. Additionally, guests can enjoy amenities such as central heat and air conditioning, flat-screen smart TVs, Wi-Fi, kitchen appliances, outdoor grills, picnic tables, and fire pits in their accommodations.

BēKIN is a unique institution located at 45 Harbor Park in New York, United States. We offer a range of services including lodging, real estate agency, and travel agency. Discover Fire Island Pines like never before with our handpicked rentals that cater to every style, taste, and budget. Secure your perfect 2024 vacation rental for the most celebrated holiday weeks. From beachfront views to pet-friendly spaces, we have the perfect vacation rental for your Fire Island Pines getaway. Our institution was born from a vision during COVID to revolutionize the rental experience in The Pines. Partnering with The BēKIN Team at Berkshire Hathaway Home Services New York Properties means choosing an innovative, technologically forward-thinking ally for your vacation rentals. Our focus on inclusivity, respect, and commitment to serving homeowners with a tech-first strategy sets us apart. We aim to streamline the entire rental process, making it as effortless as possible for you.

Splash House is a premier real estate and travel agency located at 623 Shore Walk in Fire Island, New York. Specializing in luxury beachfront properties and vacation rentals, Splash House offers a personalized and unforgettable experience for all clients. Whether you are looking to purchase your dream beach house or plan the perfect getaway, our team of experts is dedicated to exceeding your expectations. Experience the ultimate in beachfront living with Splash House.

The Channel Club, located at 100 Waterview Road in Island Park, New York, offers a boutique luxury lifestyle that is truly unique to Long Island's south shore. Each home on the property was specifically designed with the active Long Islander in mind, featuring bright and open concept apartments with spacious private balconies. Residents have access to modern amenities and boat slips along the waterfront promenade. The property boasts an elevated outdoor swimming pool with a 4,000 square foot sundeck and views of the waterfront. Marina boat slips are available for tenant use, and the beautifully landscaped waterfront promenade features barbeques and fire pits. Indoor parking garage and additional outdoor parking spaces are also available.

A Summer Place Realty is a premier real estate agency located at 157 Bayview Walk in Fire Island, New York. Specializing in beachfront and luxury properties, our experienced team of agents is dedicated to helping clients find their perfect summer getaway or year-round home. With a focus on personalized service and attention to detail, we strive to make the buying and selling process as smooth and stress-free as possible. Whether you're looking for a vacation rental or a permanent residence, A Summer Place Realty is here to help you find your dream property in this beautiful coastal community. Contact us today to start your real estate journey!

Welcome to The Pines Club, your ultimate lodging destination nestled in the heart of Fire Island, New York. Located at 236 Bay Walk, The Pines Club offers a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Our charming accommodations provide the perfect blend of comfort and elegance, making it an ideal retreat for visitors seeking relaxation and rejuvenation. At The Pines Club, we pride ourselves on our exceptional hospitality and personalized service, ensuring that every guest enjoys a memorable stay. Our beautifully appointed rooms and suites are designed with your comfort in mind, featuring modern amenities and stunning views of the surrounding natural beauty.

Welcome to Eleven Ocean, your premier travel agency located at 11 Ocean Walk, Fire Island, New York. Nestled in the heart of this charming island paradise, Eleven Ocean is your gateway to unforgettable travel experiences. Our dedicated team of travel experts is passionate about crafting personalized itineraries that cater to your unique preferences and desires. Whether you're dreaming of a relaxing beach getaway, an adventurous island exploration, or a cultural city tour, we have you covered. At Eleven Ocean, we pride ourselves on exceptional customer service and insider knowledge of the best destinations and experiences. Let us help you create lasting memories with seamless travel planning and exclusive access to hidden gems. Explore the world with confidence and ease with Eleven Ocean, where your journey begins.

Welcome to Karen McCutcheon, Douglas Elliman Real Estate, your premier destination for exceptional real estate services on Fire Island, New York. Located at 1000 Bay Walk, our office is nestled in the heart of this beautiful island, offering unparalleled expertise and personalized service in one of the most sought-after locations in the United States. At Karen McCutcheon, we pride ourselves on our deep local knowledge and commitment to helping clients find their perfect home or investment property. Whether you're looking to buy, sell, or rent, our experienced team is dedicated to guiding you through every step of the real estate process with professionalism and integrity.

Welcome to William J. Newman Realty, your trusted partner in real estate on the picturesque Fire Island, New York. Conveniently located at 62 Bay Walk, Fire Island, NY 11706, our agency is dedicated to providing exceptional real estate services tailored to meet your unique needs. With a deep understanding of the local market, we specialize in helping clients buy, sell, and rent properties across this beautiful island. At William J. Newman Realty, we pride ourselves on our personalized approach and commitment to excellence. Our experienced team of real estate professionals is passionate about guiding you through every step of your real estate journey, ensuring a seamless and rewarding experience. Whether you're searching for a charming summer getaway, a permanent residence, or an investment property, we have the expertise and resources to help you make informed decisions.

Seashore Condo Hotel is a charming lodging institution located at 78 Bayview Avenue in Ocean Beach, New York, United States. Conveniently situated in Ocean Bay Park on Fire Island, the hotel is just steps away from the ferry, beach, and Great South Bay. The comfortable air-conditioned rooms, all privately owned, provide guests with the amenities and services expected from a Fire Island hotel for a relaxing beach vacation. Guests can enjoy stunning views of the Great South Bay, peaceful surroundings, and easy access to ocean beaches and restaurants. The hotel is centrally located near popular attractions such as Ocean Beach, the Sunken Forest, and other communities like Kismet, Cherry Grove, and The Pines. Fire Island offers a variety of activities for all ages, including swimming, surfing, hiking, wildlife observation, fishing, and more.

Swimply - Five Towns Woodmere, NY Heated Pool is a hidden gem located at 520 Woodmere Boulevard in Woodmere, New York. This unique institution offers a variety of private pools, hot tubs, sports courts, and gathering spaces for booking, allowing guests to #EscapeLocally and enjoy a relaxing day in the heart of the Five Towns, Long Island. The Awesome Family Amenities at this heated pool include a 6 person hot tub, gas fire pit, water slide, and more, all set in a beautifully landscaped country club-like setting. Guests can also enjoy a bathroom and changing room for their convenience.