TOP 10 Best Local grocery stores in West Islip, New York

Welcome to East Islip Paint, your trusted home goods store conveniently located at 60 West Main Street, East Islip, New York. As a proud retailer of Benjamin Moore products, we offer a wide range of premium paints and finishes to bring your creative visions to life. Whether you're embarking on a home renovation or simply refreshing a room, our expert staff is here to guide you every step of the way. Meet Betty, our virtual color consultant, ready to assist you in finding the perfect shade for your project. Click to continue your color journey with Betty and explore the endless possibilities. Please note that on-screen and printer color representations may vary from actual paint colors, so we recommend visiting us in-store to see our full range of options.

Southdown Marketplace in West Islip, NY is a bustling food and grocery store located at 460 Montauk Highway. This popular institution offers a wide range of fresh produce, meats, dairy products, and pantry staples for local residents and visitors alike. With a friendly and knowledgeable staff, Southdown Marketplace prides itself on providing top-quality products and excellent customer service. Whether you're looking for everyday essentials or specialty items, this supermarket has everything you need to stock your kitchen and pantry. Visit Southdown Marketplace in West Islip for a convenient and enjoyable shopping experience.

Best Market West Islip is a top-rated food and grocery store located at 9 Udall Road in West Islip, New York. This supermarket offers a wide selection of fresh produce, meats, dairy products, and pantry staples for all your shopping needs. With a reputation for quality products and excellent customer service, Best Market West Islip is a go-to destination for locals looking to stock up on essentials or pick up a quick meal. Visit us today to experience the best in shopping convenience and value.

Welcome to On a Whim Gift Store, your go-to destination for unique and thoughtful gifts in the heart of East Islip, New York. Nestled at 63 West Main Street, our charming store offers a delightful array of handpicked items perfect for any occasion. Whether you're searching for a special birthday present, a heartfelt thank-you gift, or a little something to treat yourself, you'll find an eclectic selection sure to inspire and delight. Our curated collection includes artisanal crafts, stylish home décor, personalized keepsakes, and much more. We pride ourselves on supporting local artisans and showcasing products that are not only beautiful but also meaningful. At On a Whim Gift Store, we believe that every gift should tell a story, and our friendly and knowledgeable staff are here to help you find the perfect item that speaks from the heart.

Welcome to 117 Deli, your go-to destination for mouthwatering sandwiches and delightful meals in the heart of East Islip, New York. Conveniently located at 117 West Main Street, we pride ourselves on serving a wide array of delicious options that are sure to satisfy any craving. Start your day with one of our hearty breakfast sandwiches, featuring combinations like 3 eggs with ham, peppers, and onions on a roll, or indulge in our health-conscious egg whites with turkey, tomato, and provolone. For a more substantial morning meal, try our breakfast platters served with toast and home fries.

Welcome to Saltwaters Bait & Tackle, your go-to destination for all your fishing needs! Conveniently located at 939 Montauk Highway, West Islip, New York, our store is a haven for both seasoned anglers and newcomers to the sport. We pride ourselves on offering a comprehensive selection of high-quality bait, tackle, and fishing gear to ensure you have everything you need for a successful day on the water. At Saltwaters Bait & Tackle, we are passionate about fishing and are committed to providing exceptional customer service. Our knowledgeable staff is always on hand to offer expert advice, share local fishing tips, and help you find the perfect equipment for your next adventure. Whether you're fishing in the nearby Great South Bay or heading out to the Atlantic, we have the right tools to make your outing memorable.

Welcome to Blinds To Go, your premier destination for high-quality window treatments located at 212 New York 59, Nanuet, New York 10954. As a trusted general contractor and home goods store, we specialize in providing a wide range of blinds, shades, drapes, and shutters that combine timeless style with superior functionality. Our Nanuet customers appreciate the unique customization options and energy-efficient solutions we offer. One of our most popular selections is our cellular shades, known for their contemporary style and the innovative honeycomb design that enhances energy efficiency for any window size or shape. Additionally, our faux wood blinds offer a durable and economical alternative to real wood, providing the same elegant look without the high cost.

Welcome to Grand Slam Corner, your one-stop destination for all your sporting needs located at 282 Higbie Lane, West Islip, New York. As a locally owned and operated store, we pride ourselves on offering a wide selection of high-quality sporting goods and apparel for athletes and sports enthusiasts of all ages. Whether you're gearing up for baseball, softball, or any other sport, our knowledgeable staff is here to help you find the perfect equipment and accessories to enhance your performance. At Grand Slam Corner, we are committed to providing exceptional customer service and a friendly shopping experience. Visit us today and discover why we are West Islip's favorite sporting goods store!

Best Farms is a premier food and grocery institution located at 9 Udall Road in West Islip, New York. As a top-rated store and supermarket, we are committed to providing our customers with the highest quality produce, meats, dairy products, and more. Our friendly staff is dedicated to ensuring that every shopping experience is pleasant and convenient. Visit Best Farms today for all your grocery needs and discover why we are the best choice for fresh, delicious, and affordable products in the area.

Welcome to Higbie Bagels, your go-to destination for delicious, freshly baked bagels in West Islip, New York. Conveniently located at 264 Higbie Lane, our charming bakery offers a wide variety of bagels, spreads, and other mouthwatering baked goods. Whether you're craving a classic plain bagel, a savory everything bagel, or something more unique, Higbie Bagels has something to satisfy every palate. Our commitment to quality is evident in every bite, as we use only the finest ingredients to create our delicious offerings. In addition to our bagels, we also offer an assortment of pastries, sandwiches, and beverages, perfect for breakfast, lunch, or a quick snack.

Welcome to Bagel Buzz! Nestled in the heart of West Islip at 498 Union Boulevard, Bagel Buzz is your go-to destination for freshly baked delights and friendly service. As a beloved local bakery, we specialize in crafting an array of delicious bagels and baked goods that are perfect for any time of day. Whether you're grabbing breakfast on the go, looking for a satisfying lunch option, or simply craving a tasty snack, our extensive menu offers something for everyone.

Stop & Shop is a well-known food, grocery, and supermarket store located at 400 Union Boulevard in West Islip, New York. Offering a wide variety of fresh produce, meats, dairy products, and pantry staples, Stop & Shop is a one-stop destination for all your grocery needs. With friendly staff, convenient hours, and competitive prices, this institution is a favorite among locals for their quality products and excellent customer service. Stop & Shop is committed to providing a pleasant shopping experience for all customers, making it a go-to destination for all your grocery shopping needs.

Welcome to the Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop, your go-to destination for unique finds and great bargains in East Islip, New York. Located at 87 West Main Street, our charming thrift store offers a wide selection of gently used clothing, home goods, books, and more, all at unbeatable prices. Whether you're on the hunt for vintage treasures, everyday essentials, or one-of-a-kind collectibles, you'll find something special among our ever-changing inventory. Our friendly staff and volunteers are dedicated to providing a welcoming and enjoyable shopping experience for everyone. Plus, your purchases support the local community and the charitable initiatives of the Church of St. Mary. Visit us today and discover the hidden gems waiting for you at the Church of St. Mary Thrift Shop!

Welcome to USA Petroleum, your one-stop destination for convenience and quality in West Islip, New York. Located at 410 Montauk Highway, USA Petroleum offers a comprehensive range of services to meet your daily needs. As a trusted local business, we pride ourselves on providing exceptional service in a welcoming environment. Our convenience store is stocked with a wide variety of everyday essentials, snacks, beverages, and groceries, ensuring you have everything you need at your fingertips. Whether you're on a quick stop or a longer visit, our friendly staff is here to assist you with any of your shopping needs.

Welcome to Bolla Market, your go-to convenience store located at 540 Sunrise Highway, West Islip, New York. At Bolla Market, we pride ourselves on offering a wide variety of quality products to meet all your daily needs. Whether you're stopping by for a quick snack, picking up essentials on your commute, or grabbing a cup of freshly brewed coffee, our friendly and efficient staff are here to serve you with a smile. Our store is stocked with an extensive selection of beverages, snacks, groceries, and household items, ensuring you can find exactly what you need. We also offer a range of fresh and delicious food options, perfect for breakfast, lunch, or a quick bite on the go. With convenient hours and a prime location, Bolla Market is dedicated to providing exceptional service and a seamless shopping experience for our community.

Welcome to Om Popular Cards & Gifts, your go-to destination for unique and heartfelt gifts in West Islip, New York! Conveniently located in the heart of the community, our store offers a delightful selection of greeting cards, gifts, and specialty items perfect for any occasion. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, anniversary, or just want to show someone you care, our curated collection ensures you'll find the perfect token of affection. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff are always on hand to assist you in finding exactly what you need. Visit us at Om Popular Cards & Gifts and discover why we are a beloved local treasure in West Islip. Your satisfaction is our top priority, and we look forward to serving you!

Welcome to Rite Aid, your go-to destination for all your convenience, health, and wellness needs in West Islip, New York. Located at 532A Union Boulevard, our store offers a wide range of products and services to make your life easier and healthier. As a trusted local convenience store and drugstore, we provide everything from everyday essentials and groceries to health and wellness products. At Rite Aid, we prioritize your health and safety. You can schedule or walk in for your flu shot today and stay up to date on COVID-19 and other essential vaccines. Our knowledgeable pharmacists are here to assist you with any questions you may have regarding state, age, and health restrictions.

Higbie Discount Liquor & Wines is a premier liquor store located at 226 Higbie Lane in West Islip, New York. Offering a wide selection of discounted liquors and wines, this store is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a knowledgeable staff and a convenient location, Higbie Discount Liquor & Wines is the perfect place to stock up on your favorite spirits for any occasion. Whether you're looking for a special bottle of wine or a unique craft spirit, you're sure to find it at this top-notch establishment.

Fairway Manor Apartments is a charming residential community located at 400 Montauk Highway in West Islip, New York. Situated in a peaceful and picturesque neighborhood, this institution offers spacious and well-maintained apartments for rent. Residents can enjoy a range of amenities including a swimming pool, fitness center, and on-site laundry facilities. With easy access to local shops, restaurants, and public transportation, Fairway Manor Apartments provides a convenient and comfortable living experience for its residents.