The 30 Best Italian restaurant reviews in New York City, New York

Welcome to Royal Pizza, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Staten Island at 1757 Arthur Kill Road, New York 10312. We take pride in crafting delicious, mouth-watering pizzas and delectable dishes that cater to every palate. Our menu boasts a wide variety of options, from our signature fresh mozzarella cheese with marinara and parmesan to our innovative upside Sicilian pizza with mozzarella on the bottom and a savory sauce on top. Indulge in our specialty pizzas, featuring delightful combinations such as grilled chicken with Alfredo sauce and fresh spinach, or the zesty chicken breast with hot sauce and blue cheese dressing. For those who favor a classic approach, our pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, and mozzarella pizza is sure to satisfy.

Welcome to Rossville Best Pizza & Pasta, Staten Island's premier destination for authentic Italian cuisine. Conveniently located at 55 Gunton Place, Staten Island, New York, we pride ourselves on offering a delightful dining experience that combines the warmth of traditional Italian hospitality with the rich flavors of Italy. At Rossville Best Pizza & Pasta, we serve an extensive menu featuring a variety of delicious pizzas, freshly made pastas, and mouthwatering Italian specialties. Our chefs use the finest ingredients to craft each dish with love and precision, ensuring every bite is a celebration of taste. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty lasagna, or a fresh Caprese salad, we have something to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to your local Subway® Restaurant in Middle Island, New York, where bold new flavors meet timeless classics to delight your taste buds every day. Conveniently located at 1187 Middle Country Road, our Subway® offers a wide variety of delicious options, from our famous Footlongs and 6” sandwiches to wraps, salads, and more. With fresh veggies, protein choices, and freshly baked bread, you can always make your meal just the way you want it. Whether you're dining in, ordering online, or opting for convenient delivery, we make it easy to enjoy your favorite Subway® meal. Explore our catering services for your next event, featuring epic bundles of subs, drinks, chips, and cookies to satisfy any crowd.

Welcome to Lombardi's of Middle Island, where culinary excellence meets warm hospitality. Located at 175 Middle Country Road in the heart of Middle Island, New York, our restaurant is a cherished dining destination for both locals and visitors alike. At Lombardi's, we pride ourselves on offering an exquisite array of dishes that celebrate the rich flavors and traditions of Italian cuisine. Our menu features a delightful selection of handcrafted pastas, savory pizzas, and delectable entrees, all prepared with the freshest ingredients and a passion for quality. Whether you're joining us for a family dinner, a romantic evening, or a special celebration, our inviting atmosphere and attentive service ensure a memorable dining experience. We also offer a carefully curated wine list and a variety of signature cocktails to complement your meal. At Lombardi's of Middle Island, we are committed to providing an exceptional dining experience that keeps our guests coming back for more. We look forward to welcoming you to our table and sharing the timeless flavors of Italy with you.

Welcome to Sal Anthony's II, your go-to destination for delicious and authentic cuisine in Selden, New York. Conveniently located at 980 Middle Country Road, our restaurant is a beloved local gem known for its inviting atmosphere and mouthwatering menu offerings. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty meal with family and friends or a cozy dinner for two, Sal Anthony's II promises an unforgettable dining experience. Our menu features a delightful array of dishes crafted from the freshest ingredients, ensuring every bite is a burst of flavor. Join us for lunch or dinner and discover why Sal Anthony's II is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. We look forward to serving you and sharing our passion for great food and exceptional service.

Welcome to Andiamo's Pizzeria, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in Lake Ronkonkoma, New York. Conveniently located at 600 Portion Road, Andiamo's Pizzeria offers a delightful culinary experience whether you choose to dine in, take out, or have your meal delivered right to your doorstep. Our menu features a wide array of mouthwatering dishes that are sure to satisfy every palate. Savor the rich flavors of our sautéed mushrooms and diced prosciutto in a brown Marsala wine sauce, or indulge in our tubatini pasta with white cannellini beans, garlic, and prosciutto in a light tomato broth. For salad lovers, we offer fresh options like our Greek vinaigrette-dressed romaine and iceberg lettuce with tomatoes, red onion, cucumbers, olives, peppers, and feta cheese.

Welcome to Dragos Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, mouth-watering pizza located at 2312 North Ocean Avenue, Farmingville, New York. At Dragos Pizza, we pride ourselves on crafting the perfect slice using only the freshest ingredients and time-honored recipes. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita, a hearty Meat Lovers, or a veggie-packed delight, our diverse menu has something to satisfy every palate. Beyond our signature pizzas, we offer a wide array of Italian-inspired dishes, including savory pastas, crisp salads, and delectable appetizers. Our cozy and welcoming atmosphere is perfect for a casual family dinner, a quick lunch, or a gathering with friends. We also offer convenient takeout and delivery services for those nights when you want to enjoy our delicious offerings from the comfort of your own home.

Welcome to Tony's Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in Medford, New York! Conveniently located at 2277 New York 112, Tony's Pizza is a beloved local gem where families, friends, and food enthusiasts come together to enjoy mouthwatering pizzas, hearty pastas, and a variety of classic Italian dishes. At Tony's Pizza, we pride ourselves on using only the freshest ingredients and time-honored recipes to deliver a dining experience that's both satisfying and memorable. Whether you're craving a perfectly crispy, cheesy slice of pizza or a comforting bowl of pasta, our extensive menu has something to delight every palate.

Welcome to Subway® Holbrook, your local destination for fresh and delicious meal options at 315 Main Street, Holbrook, New York. Whether you're craving our iconic Footlongs, 6” sandwiches, wraps, or salads, we offer a delightful variety of flavors to satisfy your taste buds every day. Our menu is crafted with fresh-cut veggies, a selection of proteins, and freshly baked bread, ensuring a flavorful alternative to ordinary fast food. At Subway®, you can customize your meal just the way you like it with our Make it What You Want® options. Choose from our vast array of ingredients to create your perfect sandwich, wrap, or salad. For those with dietary restrictions, select locations offer a gluten-free bread option, and our Products and Ingredients guide provides comprehensive information on all menu offerings.

Welcome to Pizza Roma, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in Hauppauge, New York. Conveniently located at 180 Commerce Drive, we specialize in crafting mouth-watering pizzas and a variety of Italian dishes, all made with the freshest ingredients and a passion for flavor. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita, a hearty Meat Lovers, or a custom creation, our extensive menu has something to satisfy every palate. At Pizza Roma, we understand the importance of convenience, which is why we offer efficient meal delivery services straight to your door. Perfect for busy weeknights, family gatherings, or simply treating yourself, our delivery ensures you can enjoy our delectable offerings without leaving the comfort of your home.

Welcome to Nino's Pizzeria, your go-to spot for the best pizzas in Patchogue, New York! Conveniently located at 580 Medford Avenue, we are proud to serve the local community with a mouth-watering variety of pizzas, pasta, sandwiches, and more. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita or our signature Neapolitan-Style Meatball Pizza with a golden crust, our menu has something to satisfy every craving. At Nino's Pizzeria, we offer enticing meal deals perfect for any occasion. From our combo meals serving 2-8 people, which include large cheese pies, pasta, garlic knots, and soda, to special offers like a free 2-liter soda or 6 garlic knots with the purchase of two large cheese pizzas, we ensure you get the best value for your dining experience.

Welcome to Angelina's Pizza, a beloved culinary gem located at 1191 Grundy Avenue, Holbrook, New York. As a staple in the community, we invite you to experience the best pizza Holbrook has to offer. Our menu is brimming with a diverse selection of mouth-watering pizzas, savory pastas, and hearty sandwiches, each crafted with the freshest ingredients to satisfy your cravings and expand your culinary horizons. At Angelina's Pizza, we pride ourselves on offering a wide array of delicious options. From classic favorites like chicken parm, sausage parm, and meatball parm, to our unique creations such as the thin crust pie with mozzarella cheese and a garlic plum tomato sauce, there's something for everyone. For those seeking a hearty meal, try our deep dish pie topped with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, roasted peppers, and a drizzle of olive oil.

Welcome to Kiki Rico, your go-to destination for a delightful culinary experience in Central Islip, New York. Located at 189 Calebs Path, our restaurant is dedicated to serving mouth-watering dishes that are sure to satisfy your cravings. At Kiki Rico, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that features a blend of traditional and contemporary flavors, crafted with the freshest ingredients. Whether you're looking to enjoy a hearty meal with family or a quick bite with friends, our warm and inviting atmosphere makes every dining experience memorable. Our friendly staff is committed to providing exceptional service, ensuring that you feel right at home from the moment you step through our doors. Visit Kiki Rico today and discover why we're a local favorite in the community. We look forward to serving you!

Welcome to Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina, your go-to destination for authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Mastic Beach, New York. Conveniently located at 201 Mastic Beach Road, our family-owned restaurant is dedicated to serving the finest Italian cuisine with a warm and inviting atmosphere. At Nino's, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes to create mouthwatering dishes that will transport your taste buds straight to Italy. Our menu features a delicious selection of classic pizzas, handcrafted pastas, and savory entrees, all made with love and care. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty lasagna, or a fresh Caprese salad, we have something to satisfy every craving.

Welcome to Lempa, your go-to destination for an unforgettable culinary experience in Central Islip, New York. Nestled at 1561 Islip Avenue, Lempa is a vibrant and welcoming restaurant that serves a delightful array of dishes, crafted with love and the freshest ingredients. At Lempa, we are passionate about providing our guests with an exceptional dining experience. Our menu features a diverse selection of mouth-watering options that cater to a variety of tastes and preferences. Whether you're in the mood for traditional favorites or innovative new dishes, our talented chefs are dedicated to delivering flavors that will tantalize your taste buds.

Welcome to Gino's Pizza, your go-to destination for the best pizza in Patchogue! Located at 22 West Main Street, Patchogue, New York 11772, our family-owned restaurant has been delighting the community with mouth-watering pizzas and a variety of delicious dishes since 1975. At Gino's Pizza, we pride ourselves on using only the finest ingredients to craft our signature cheese pies, classic pizzas, and unique creations like our Sicilian pizza with tomatoes, chopped onion, garlic, and basil. Explore our menu and indulge in a range of flavorful offerings, from fresh mozzarella pizzas with tomato sauce and basil to our hearty Italian rice dish with beef, peas, and Romano cheese served alongside marinara sauce. Our salads, including the Fresh Mozzarella, Tomato & Roasted Red Peppers Salad and the classic Caesar, provide a refreshing complement to any meal.

Welcome to Italiano Pizza & Food Co., your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Patchogue, New York. Nestled at 75 East Main Street, our restaurant offers a delightful culinary experience that has everyone talking. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely dinner, we promise you'll leave satisfied. Indulge in our must-try dishes that have become local favorites. From our signature two-piece Chopmeat with garlic knots and fried onion drizzled in our secret sauce, to our 18-inch pizza topped with bleu cheese dressing, fried chicken, mozzarella, and buffalo sauce, each bite is a testament to our commitment to quality and flavor.

Welcome to Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe, where we serve Long Island's best pizza, as recognized by Newsday from 2019 to 2023. Nestled in the heart of Patchogue at 18 West Avenue, our cafe is a haven for pizza lovers seeking an unforgettable dining experience. At Donatina, we take pride in crafting pizzas with a thick, airy base and a crunchy, crispy cheese crust, cooked to perfection in a steel pan. Our unique secret cheese blend complements a tomato sauce with just the right amount of kick, delivering a burst of flavor in every bite.

Welcome to Pizza Roma, your go-to destination for delicious and authentic Italian flavors in Deer Park, New York! Conveniently located at 786 Grand Boulevard, we specialize in bringing the taste of Italy right to your doorstep with our exceptional meal delivery service. At Pizza Roma, we take pride in crafting mouthwatering pizzas, pastas, and a variety of Italian specialties using only the freshest ingredients. Our menu offers a wide selection of classic and gourmet pizzas, each made with our signature hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and premium toppings. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita, a savory Pepperoni, or something more adventurous, we have something to satisfy every craving.

Welcome to Route 27 Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious meals and exceptional service in Islip Terrace, New York. Conveniently located at 3279 Sunrise Highway North Service Road, we offer a delightful culinary experience that combines the warmth of a local restaurant with the convenience of meal delivery. At Route 27 Pizza, we pride ourselves on using fresh, high-quality ingredients to craft a menu that caters to every palate. From our signature pizzas with a variety of toppings to satisfy every craving, to our mouth-watering pastas, crisp salads, and hearty sandwiches, there's something for everyone to enjoy.

Welcome to Francesco's, your go-to destination for delicious meals and exceptional service in Islip Terrace, New York. Conveniently located at 64 Carleton Avenue, Francesco's offers a delightful dining experience whether you're joining us in our cozy restaurant or enjoying our convenient meal delivery service from the comfort of your home. At Francesco's, we pride ourselves on crafting a diverse menu that caters to all tastes and preferences. Our skilled chefs use only the freshest ingredients to prepare mouthwatering dishes that will satisfy your cravings, from classic Italian favorites to innovative culinary creations. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty pasta dish, a crisp salad, or a perfectly baked pizza, Francesco's has something to delight every palate.

Welcome to Vinnie's Mulberry Street, your go-to destination for delicious meals and convenient takeaways in the heart of East Islip, New York. Located at 42 West Main Street, our restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can enjoy a wide variety of mouth-watering dishes crafted with the freshest ingredients. At Vinnie’s, we pride ourselves on delivering exceptional food and excellent service. Whether you're craving a hearty meal to enjoy with family and friends or looking for a quick and satisfying takeaway, our diverse menu has something for everyone. From traditional Italian favorites to innovative culinary creations, each dish is prepared with love and care to ensure an unforgettable dining experience.

Welcome to Beyond Gluten Trattoria Italiana, your premier destination for authentic Italian cuisine crafted with a gluten-free twist. Nestled in the heart of Bay Shore, New York, at 635 East Main Street, our trattoria offers a delightful dining experience that caters to both dine-in guests and those seeking convenient meal delivery. At Beyond Gluten, we believe that everyone should enjoy the rich flavors of Italy without compromise. Our menu features a diverse array of traditional Italian dishes, all thoughtfully prepared without gluten, ensuring that those with dietary restrictions can savor every bite. From freshly made pasta and wood-fired pizzas to decadent desserts, our culinary creations are designed to delight your taste buds while prioritizing your health and well-being.

Welcome to Pulcinella on the Green, a delightful culinary destination nestled in the heart of Wading River, New York. Located at 141 Fairway Drive, our charming restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy an unforgettable dining experience. At Pulcinella on the Green, we take pride in serving an exquisite selection of authentic Italian dishes, crafted with the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes. Our menu features a variety of mouthwatering options, from classic pasta dishes and hand-tossed pizzas to delectable seafood and succulent meats. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner, our diverse offerings are sure to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to Caruso's Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Riverhead, New York. Conveniently located at 1104 Old Country Road, we pride ourselves on serving a wide variety of mouth-watering pizzas, pastas, and classic Italian dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. At Caruso's Pizzeria, we use only the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes to bring the rich flavors of Italy straight to your table. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty lasagna, or a fresh Caprese salad, our menu has something for everyone. Our cozy and welcoming atmosphere makes it the perfect spot for a family dinner, a casual lunch with friends, or a quick bite on the go.

Welcome to Marco's Sicilian Pizza & Pasta, where we serve up Riverhead's most beloved pizzas and pastas right in the heart of the city. Located at 300 East Main Street, Riverhead, New York 11901, our restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. We pride ourselves on offering some of the finest pizzas in the area, and once you try our delicious creations, you'll understand why Marco's is the go-to spot for pizza lovers in Riverhead. Our menu features a variety of mouthwatering options, including the popular meatball parmigiana hero, a perfect complement to any of our pizzas. At Marco's Sicilian Pizza & Pasta, we're dedicated to bringing you the best of Riverhead's culinary scene, with a focus on fresh ingredients and authentic flavors.

Welcome to Amalfi Coastal Kitchen & Cocktails, your newest waterfront gem in the heart of Hampton Bays. Located at 32 Lighthouse Road, our restaurant beautifully merges the allure of the Italian seaside with the timeless charm of the Hamptons. We offer an unparalleled dining experience, blending the vibrant flavors of the Mediterranean with the relaxed coastal ambiance that the Hamptons are famous for. Join us for both lunch and dinner, and let our culinary delights satisfy your cravings at any time of day. Whether you're seeking a leisurely midday meal or a memorable evening dining experience, Amalfi Coastal Kitchen & Cocktails is here to cater to your every need. Our menu is crafted to bring you the best of both worlds, ensuring a unique and delightful culinary journey.

Welcome to Casa Basso, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Westhampton, New York. Located at 59 Montauk Highway, our restaurant is a beloved destination for those seeking a memorable dining experience on Long Island. With a rich history and a commitment to excellence, Casa Basso offers a unique blend of classic and contemporary cuisine that delights the senses. Our menu features an array of thoughtfully crafted dishes, showcasing the finest local ingredients and authentic flavors. Whether you're in the mood for a romantic dinner, a family gathering, or a special celebration, Casa Basso provides the perfect setting with its charming ambiance and warm hospitality.

Welcome to Alitalia, your go-to destination for an authentic Italian dining experience in the heart of Center Moriches, New York. Conveniently located at 532 Montauk Highway, our charming restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere perfect for family gatherings, romantic dinners, or a casual meal with friends. At Alitalia, we pride ourselves on delivering a true taste of Italy by using the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes. Our menu features a wide array of classic Italian dishes, from mouth-watering pasta and risotto to savory seafood and perfectly cooked meats. Don't forget to explore our selection of delectable pizzas, crafted with a thin, crispy crust and topped with the finest ingredients.

Welcome to La Perla Restaurante, your premier dining destination located at 202 James Street, Utica, New York. Nestled in the heart of the city, La Perla offers an exquisite culinary experience that combines the rich flavors of traditional cuisine with a modern twist. Our menu features a diverse selection of gourmet dishes crafted from the freshest ingredients, ensuring every bite is a delightful journey for your taste buds. At La Perla, we pride ourselves on creating a warm and inviting atmosphere where guests can relax and enjoy exceptional service. Whether you're joining us for a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, or a special celebration, our dedicated team is committed to making your visit memorable.