Top 30 Best Italian food places in Oyster Bay, New York

Mama Mia’s Pizza & Pasta (Formerly Pietro’s Oyster Bay) is a beloved restaurant located at 342 Lexington Avenue in Oyster Bay, New York.

Bacaro Italian Tavern, located at 1020 Park Boulevard in Massapequa Park, New York, brings the tradition of 'andar a cicheti' from Venice to the United States.

Sal's Place is a cozy and inviting bar and restaurant located at 1495 Hicksville Road in North Massapequa, New York. Known for its delicious food and friendly atmosphere, Sal's Place is the perfect spot to grab a bite to eat or enjoy a drink with friends.

Iavarone Italian Kitchen & Pizzeria is a popular dining destination located at 1575 Old Country Road in Plainview, New York. This restaurant offers delicious Italian cuisine, including traditional pasta dishes, gourmet pizzas, and mouthwatering desserts.

Italian Affair of Massapequa is a charming restaurant located at 624 Broadway in Massapequa, New York. Specializing in authentic Italian cuisine, this establishment offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere for diners to enjoy a delicious meal.

Carlo's Pizza of Glen Head is a popular Italian restaurant located at 689 Glen Cove Avenue in Glen Head, New York.

Flora's Pizza Cafe is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 637 Jericho Turnpike in Syosset, New York.

GIOIA is a charming pasta shop and restaurant located at 94 South Street in Oyster Bay, New York. As the Italian word for joy, GIOIA embodies the spirit of bringing happiness and delicious food together.

Acqua e Farina Pizzeria is a charming Italian restaurant located at 43 Berry Hill Road in Syosset, New York.

Angelina's is a charming Italian restaurant located at 1017 Oyster Bay Road in East Norwich, New York.

La Spezia is a charming Italian restaurant located at 400 Glen Cove Avenue in Sea Cliff, New York. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, this institution offers a menu filled with delicious and authentic Italian cuisine.

Leonardo's Pizza is a popular food institution located at 20 Broadway in Massapequa, New York.

Dalers Pizza Parlor is a cozy and welcoming restaurant located at 331 Main Street in Farmingdale, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas, this establishment offers a wide variety of toppings and specialty pies to satisfy every palate.

Saverio's Authentic Pizza Napoletana is a renowned institution located at 929 North Broadway in North Massapequa, New York. Specializing in traditional Neapolitan pizza, we use only the finest San Marzano D.O.P.

Piñons Pizza Company is a beloved restaurant located at 23 Birch Hill Road in Locust Valley, New York.

Mulberry St. Pizza is a renowned food institution located at 287 North Broadway, Jericho, New York, United States. Specializing in meal delivery and restaurant services, Mulberry St.

Bella Vista Pizza & Pasta is a cozy Italian restaurant located at 154 Manetto Hill Road in Plainview, New York. We specialize in delicious pizzas and mouthwatering pasta dishes that are sure to satisfy your cravings.

Sababa Pizza Inc. is a popular food institution located at 1012 Old Country Road in Plainview, New York. This restaurant offers a delicious selection of freshly made pizzas that are sure to satisfy any craving.

Chris & Tony’s is a popular bar, food, and restaurant located at 352 Jericho Turnpike in Syosset, New York. This cozy establishment offers a wide range of delicious food options, refreshing drinks, and a welcoming atmosphere for patrons to enjoy.

Vincent's Pizza is a popular food institution located at 47 Boundary Avenue in Farmingdale, New York.

Joseph's Pizzeria & Kitchen is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 575 Underhill Boulevard in Syosset, New York. Serving up delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine, this establishment is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Raimo's Pizza Hicksville is a popular food institution located at 380 Woodbury Road in Hicksville, New York. Known for their delicious and freshly made pizzas, Raimo's offers a wide variety of toppings and specialty pies to satisfy every craving.

Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings is a popular restaurant located in Woodbury, New York. Known for its delicious coal-fired pizzas and wings, this eatery offers a unique and flavorful dining experience.

Two25 Restaurant is a charming dining establishment located at 225 Birch Hill Road in the picturesque town of Locust Valley, New York.

Steve's Piccola Bussola II is a charming bar and restaurant located at 41 Jackson Avenue in Syosset, New York. This cozy establishment offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where guests can enjoy delicious Italian cuisine and handcrafted cocktails.

Fredo's Pizza & Pasta is a cozy Italian restaurant located at 4855 Merrick Road in Massapequa Park, New York.

Located at 5280 Sunrise Highway in Massapequa Park, New York, Phils Pizza 2 offers true Italian-style pizza with a variety of toppings and crust options.

Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a cozy dining establishment located at 188 Merritts Road in Farmingdale, New York.

Giovanni's Pizza and Restaurant is a popular dining destination located at 5612 Merrick Road in Massapequa, New York. This family-owned establishment offers a wide variety of mouthwatering Italian dishes, including freshly made pizza, pasta, and more.

Francesco's of Farmingdale is a charming Italian restaurant located at 107 Northwest Drive in Farmingdale, New York.