Italian Affair Of Massapequa

"Italian Affair of Massapequa is a fresh take on an old school pizzeria. Very clean and bright and always decorated for the season, they offer a variety of slices and some old favorites that are difficult to find in other pizzerias these days like their cappellini cakes and sfincione. The staff are friendly and professional. I’ve been here a few times and will definitely be coming back!"

"the best slice is the one that Sotto Sopra gave them. Delivery took 2.5 hours despite living 10 blocks away because they have no delivery people and the person who took my order forgot to place the order then after two phone calls it finally showed up freezing cold. Stick to Leonardos until this place gets replaced again. Only reason I gave atmosphere 4 stars is because the young delivery driver Tom was the only one to show empathy about the botched order."

"In a sea of Broadway Pizzerias it takes more than a crisp regular to stand out and boy does Italian Affair hit every mark. From food to service to atmosphere, this place is firing on all cylinders. Have yet to have a slice that wasn't superb. The spicy vodka with pepperoni is easily the best slice on the Broadway stretch, oh sorry my mistake, the Rocco's Rumble. Heavenly. Chicken and broccoli rabe hero with creamy vinaigrette will put you in the best of possible food comas. This place is family owned and operated and everyone is as friendly and welcoming as you can imagine. Being lactose intolerant, you need to serve up a proper pie to get me to deal with well, you know, and this place has turned me from a once a month at best to a once a week pizza eater. All the staples, very clean, excellent regular slice, excellent specialty slices, excellent kitchen food, friendly faces, what more could you want? Stop on by and tell them the guy who crashed his food truck into a tree sent ya."

"We ordered a take out pizza from here on 11/8/23. We literally live 2 minutes away. When we got home and opened the pizza it was literally cold, and I mean room temperature or less. So it was obvious this pizza was made earlier and was just sitting around. Apparently they just put into the box and gave it to us. We threw the whole thing out. We will never order from here again. Terrible....."

"I stopped in for a few slices (got a vegetable, vodka, & a rice ball) and I didn’t have time to take a picture because I was too busy eating it on the ride home. This is honestly the best pizza I’ve ever had in a LONG time - I can’t wait to come back and eat everything else here!!! Hopefully I’ll be patient enough to take a picture next time :)"