The 30 Best Island vacation rentals in New York

Welcome to The Pines Club, your ultimate lodging destination nestled in the heart of Fire Island, New York. Located at 236 Bay Walk, The Pines Club offers a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Our charming accommodations provide the perfect blend of comfort and elegance, making it an ideal retreat for visitors seeking relaxation and rejuvenation. At The Pines Club, we pride ourselves on our exceptional hospitality and personalized service, ensuring that every guest enjoys a memorable stay. Our beautifully appointed rooms and suites are designed with your comfort in mind, featuring modern amenities and stunning views of the surrounding natural beauty.

Welcome to South Shore Bay Bikes, your premier destination for bicycle rentals and sales on Fire Island, New York. Conveniently located at 25 Cayuga Street, South Shore Bay Bikes is your gateway to exploring the stunning landscapes and scenic trails that make Fire Island a beloved destination for outdoor enthusiasts. At South Shore Bay Bikes, we offer a wide range of high-quality bicycles to suit riders of all ages and skill levels. Whether you're looking for a leisurely ride along the beach, an adventurous mountain biking experience, or a reliable commuter bike, our diverse selection ensures you'll find the perfect match for your needs. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff are always on hand to provide expert advice and personalized service, ensuring that your biking experience is both enjoyable and memorable.

Welcome to Pouch Camporee Field, your premier destination for outdoor adventure and relaxation located at 1285 Manor Road, Staten Island, New York. Nestled in the heart of Staten Island, our campground offers a serene escape from the hustle and bustle of city life, providing a perfect blend of natural beauty and modern amenities. At Pouch Camporee Field, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse range of experiences for families, groups, and solo adventurers. Our spacious campgrounds are ideal for tent camping, giving you the chance to reconnect with nature and enjoy the great outdoors. For those seeking a more comfortable stay, our lodging options provide cozy accommodations with all the necessary conveniences.

Welcome to Cedar Grove Beach, your serene escape nestled in the heart of Staten Island, New York. Located at Cedar Grove Beach Place, Staten Island, New York 10306, this picturesque park offers a perfect blend of relaxation and recreation for visitors of all ages. Cedar Grove Beach is renowned for its pristine sandy shores, gentle waves, and tranquil atmosphere, providing a peaceful retreat from the hustle and bustle of city life. Whether you're looking to soak up the sun, enjoy a leisurely stroll along the shoreline, or engage in beachside activities, Cedar Grove Beach is the ideal destination. The park features well-maintained picnic areas, inviting visitors to enjoy a meal with family and friends amidst the natural beauty of the surroundings. With convenient amenities and a family-friendly environment, Cedar Grove Beach ensures a memorable experience for all.

Welcome to Costa Corner, your ultimate destination for unforgettable experiences on Fire Island, New York! Nestled in the heart of this idyllic coastal paradise, Costa Corner is a premier tourist attraction offering a perfect blend of natural beauty, adventure, and relaxation. Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat or an action-packed day by the beach, our vibrant location has something for everyone. Explore the stunning landscapes, enjoy a variety of water sports, or simply unwind on the pristine sandy shores. Our friendly staff is dedicated to ensuring your visit is memorable, providing insider tips on the best local spots and activities. Don't miss out on our seasonal events and community gatherings that capture the true essence of Fire Island's charm.

Welcome to Eleven Ocean, your premier travel agency located at 11 Ocean Walk, Fire Island, New York. Nestled in the heart of this charming island paradise, Eleven Ocean is your gateway to unforgettable travel experiences. Our dedicated team of travel experts is passionate about crafting personalized itineraries that cater to your unique preferences and desires. Whether you're dreaming of a relaxing beach getaway, an adventurous island exploration, or a cultural city tour, we have you covered. At Eleven Ocean, we pride ourselves on exceptional customer service and insider knowledge of the best destinations and experiences. Let us help you create lasting memories with seamless travel planning and exclusive access to hidden gems. Explore the world with confidence and ease with Eleven Ocean, where your journey begins.

Welcome to Klenawicus Airfield, your gateway to Shelter Island and the beautiful surroundings of New York. Conveniently located at 17 North Cartwright Road, Shelter Island, our airfield offers a unique and accessible entry point to this picturesque region. As a local airport, Klenawicus Airfield provides a seamless and efficient travel experience for both residents and visitors alike. Whether you're arriving for a weekend getaway, a business trip, or a special event, our dedicated team is committed to ensuring your journey is smooth and enjoyable. Explore the charm and tranquility of Shelter Island with ease, thanks to Klenawicus Airfield's strategic location and exceptional service. We look forward to welcoming you to our friendly and accommodating airfield.

Welcome to Landing Beach Silver, your premier destination for relaxation and adventure on Shelter Island, New York. Nestled at 80 Peconic Avenue, our stunning beach offers the perfect escape for tourists and locals alike. Known for its pristine sands and breathtaking views, Landing Beach Silver provides a serene backdrop for sunbathing, beachcombing, and picnicking. Whether you're looking to unwind with a good book, take a refreshing swim, or explore the natural beauty of Shelter Island, our beach is the ideal spot. With convenient access and a family-friendly atmosphere, Landing Beach Silver is a must-visit attraction for anyone seeking a memorable seaside experience. Come and discover the charm and tranquility of Shelter Island's hidden gem.

Welcome to our charming hotel, conveniently located at 112 Rhode Island Avenue, Bay Shore, New York. Nestled in the heart of the vibrant Bay Shore community, our hotel offers a relaxing retreat for both business and leisure travelers. Experience the perfect blend of comfort and convenience with our well-appointed rooms, modern amenities, and friendly service. Our prime location provides easy access to local attractions, dining, and shopping, making it an ideal base for exploring the area. Whether you're visiting for a weekend getaway or an extended stay, our dedicated team is committed to ensuring your visit is memorable and enjoyable.

Welcome to William J. Newman Realty, your trusted partner in real estate on the picturesque Fire Island, New York. Conveniently located at 62 Bay Walk, Fire Island, NY 11706, our agency is dedicated to providing exceptional real estate services tailored to meet your unique needs. With a deep understanding of the local market, we specialize in helping clients buy, sell, and rent properties across this beautiful island. At William J. Newman Realty, we pride ourselves on our personalized approach and commitment to excellence. Our experienced team of real estate professionals is passionate about guiding you through every step of your real estate journey, ensuring a seamless and rewarding experience. Whether you're searching for a charming summer getaway, a permanent residence, or an investment property, we have the expertise and resources to help you make informed decisions.

Welcome to Wisteria, your serene retreat nestled in the heart of Fire Island, New York. Located at 37 Bayview Walk, our charming lodging offers a perfect blend of comfort and tranquility, making it an ideal getaway for those seeking relaxation and natural beauty. At Wisteria, we pride ourselves on providing a warm and inviting atmosphere, where guests can unwind and enjoy the picturesque surroundings. Our accommodations are thoughtfully designed to cater to your every need, ensuring a restful and rejuvenating stay. Each room is tastefully decorated, featuring modern amenities while preserving the rustic charm that makes Fire Island so special.

Welcome to Azalea House, your serene retreat nestled in the heart of Shelter Island, New York. Located at 1 Thomas Avenue, our charming lodging offers a peaceful escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. At Azalea House, we pride ourselves on providing a cozy and inviting atmosphere, perfect for relaxation and rejuvenation. Whether you're planning a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a solo retreat, our accommodations are designed to cater to your every need. Immerse yourself in the tranquil surroundings and enjoy the natural beauty of Shelter Island.

Welcome to North Fork Oasis 4b Beach House, a serene retreat nestled in the heart of Laurel, New York. Located at 1025 Peconic Bay Boulevard, our beautiful beach house offers the perfect getaway for families and friends seeking relaxation and adventure. Just steps away from the pristine beaches of Peconic Bay, our property provides an idyllic setting for sunbathing, swimming, or simply enjoying the stunning waterfront views. Our spacious accommodation features four beautifully appointed bedrooms, ensuring a comfortable stay for all guests. Dive into relaxation with our heated pool and unwind in the soothing hot tub, perfect for rejuvenating after a day of exploring the nearby attractions.

The Cliffside Resort Condominiums, located at 61475 North Road in Greenport, New York, offers luxurious and comfortable lodging in a stunning waterfront setting. Guests can enjoy breathtaking views of the Long Island Sound from their spacious condos, complete with modern amenities and stylish decor. The resort also features a range of on-site facilities including a swimming pool, fitness center, and private beach access. Whether you're looking for a relaxing getaway or a fun-filled vacation, The Cliffside Resort Condominiums is the perfect choice for your next stay in Greenport.

Welcome to Medford Pond Luxury Apartments, located at 1100 Lake Drive in Medford, New York. Our beautifully appointed one-, two-, and three-bedroom apartments offer a country-club lifestyle without the country-club price tag. Enjoy extensive amenities and warm, attentive service from Heatherwood Communities. Our tree-lined grounds provide a secluded feel, yet we are conveniently located near dining, shopping, and recreation, just a mile from the Long Island Expressway. Schedule a visit to see our living spaces and amenities for yourself.

East End Charters is a premier tourist attraction and travel agency located at 1100 Manhasset Avenue in Greenport, New York. Specializing in providing unforgettable charter experiences along the picturesque East End of Long Island, our expert team is dedicated to creating custom itineraries that cater to every traveler's unique preferences. Whether you're looking to explore the stunning coastline, indulge in local cuisine, or simply relax on a luxury yacht, East End Charters has you covered. Book your next adventure with us and discover the beauty of the East End like never before.

The New York Boat Company is a travel agency located at 30 Hudson Avenue in Peekskill, New York. Specializing in boat tours and excursions, the company offers a unique way to explore the beautiful waterways of New York State. Whether you're looking for a relaxing cruise along the Hudson River or an adventurous sailing trip on the Long Island Sound, the New York Boat Company has something for everyone. Their experienced staff and top-of-the-line fleet of boats ensure a safe and enjoyable experience for all passengers. Book your next nautical adventure with the New York Boat Company today!

Empire Home Realty of L.I. is a reputable real estate agency located in Lake Grove, New York. With a prime location on Middle Country Road, this agency specializes in helping clients buy, sell, and rent residential properties in the Long Island area. Their team of experienced agents is dedicated to providing top-notch service and guidance throughout the entire real estate process. Whether you are looking for your dream home or trying to sell your current property, Empire Home Realty of L.I. is the go-to agency for all your real estate needs.

Harbor Landing at Garvies Point is a premier real estate agency located at 350 Herb Hill Road in Glen Cove, New York. Situated in the picturesque Garvies Point waterfront community, this institution offers luxury waterfront residences with stunning views of Long Island Sound. With a focus on providing high-quality service and top-notch amenities, Harbor Landing at Garvies Point is the ideal choice for those seeking a sophisticated and upscale living experience. Whether you are looking to buy, sell, or rent a property, their team of experienced professionals is dedicated to helping you find your dream home. Visit Harbor Landing at Garvies Point today and discover the beauty and elegance of waterfront living in Glen Cove.

Sail Caribbean, located at 256 Main Street, Northport, New York, United States, is a travel agency specializing in empowering teens and college-aged students through summer adventure camps since 1979. Each program offers experiential learning in various areas such as sailing, scuba diving, marine biology, and community service. Participants are not just passengers but active sailors and athletes, engaging in activities like snorkeling, paddleboarding, wakeboarding, and more. The institution focuses on environmental stewardship, visiting stunning natural locations and contributing to local conservation efforts. Students have the opportunity to explore the underwater world, learn about marine life, and broaden their horizons while living and learning aboard a yacht with their crewmates. Testimonials from past participants highlight the transformative experiences, personal growth, and lifelong memories created through Sail Caribbean's unique programs.

Truman Beach is a beautiful waterfront park located at 19340 Main Road in East Marion, New York. This serene and picturesque park offers stunning views of the Long Island Sound and a sandy beach perfect for sunbathing and swimming. Visitors can enjoy picnicking on the grassy areas, hiking along the scenic trails, or simply relaxing and taking in the peaceful surroundings. With its convenient location and tranquil atmosphere, Truman Beach is the ideal destination for a day of outdoor recreation and relaxation.

Coastal Insurance Solutions is an insurance agency located at 333 Route 25A, Rocky Point, New York, United States. Unlike other home insurers, we cater specifically to high-end residential homeowners who may require specialized coverage. Our expertise lies in providing tailored homeowners and flood insurance for properties in coastal states such as Florida, New York, New Jersey, Connecticut, and California. We understand that insurance rates for luxury homes can vary widely, which is why we work with A , AM Best rated carriers to offer competitive pricing and affordable quotes for homeowners in Nassau and Suffolk County, NY. Whether you own a waterfront property, a coastal secondary home, or a typical family home, we have customized programs to suit your needs.

The Chateau On The Lake is a stunning institution located at 15 Allens Alley in Bolton, New York, United States. This establishment offers a unique combination of a bar, food, liquor store, restaurant, and store all in one place. With their Early Bird Menu, Le Premier, guests can enjoy a delicious 3-course meal for $45 served daily from 3 pm to 5 pm (excluding holidays). The institution also offers a Military discount, so be sure to mention if you are a current or retired member of the military.

Picone Realty, located at 8870 New York 97 in Callicoon, New York, is a reputable general contractor specializing in property management, leasing, development, maintenance, and real estate sales. As a family-owned and operated business with roots dating back to 1946, Picone Acquisition Corp. has a long-standing history of providing exceptional real estate services in Long Island. Their expertise in both commercial and residential properties, combined with their dedication to customer satisfaction, has earned them a stellar reputation in the industry. Whether you are looking to lease, rent, buy, or develop real estate, Picone Realty is the go-to choice for all your real estate needs. Contact them today at 631.293.0003 to learn more about their services.

Southern Sails LLC is a renowned general contractor located at 157 Park Street in Jamestown, New York, United States. With years of experience in the industry, Southern Sails LLC specializes in providing top-notch construction and renovation services to residential and commercial clients. From building custom homes to remodeling existing spaces, their team of skilled professionals is dedicated to delivering high-quality craftsmanship and exceptional customer service. Trust Southern Sails LLC for all your construction needs and watch your vision come to life.

ISM Rent-A-Car & Auto Repair is your one-stop shop for all your automotive needs in Spring Valley, New York. Conveniently located at 129 Maple Avenue, our institution offers top-notch car rental services as well as expert auto repair and maintenance. Whether you need a vehicle for a day trip or a week-long vacation, our wide selection of cars will suit your needs. Our skilled technicians are also available to provide high-quality repairs and servicing for your vehicle. Visit us today and experience exceptional service and reliability at ISM Rent-A-Car & Auto Repair.

LUXURIOUS TRAVEL AGENCY LLC is a premier travel agency located at 63 Washington Drive in Woodbury, New York, United States. As a leading provider of luxury travel services, we specialize in creating unforgettable experiences for our clients. From exotic destinations to exclusive accommodations, our team of experienced travel experts is dedicated to curating personalized itineraries that exceed expectations. Whether you're seeking a relaxing beach getaway or an adventurous expedition, LUXURIOUS TRAVEL AGENCY LLC is your go-to resource for all your travel needs. Book your next dream vacation with us and let us help you create memories that will last a lifetime.

Pacific Holidays Inc. is a premier travel agency located in the heart of New York City at 12 West 32nd Street. With a focus on providing exceptional travel experiences to destinations across the Pacific region, this agency offers a wide range of vacation packages, tours, and cruises to exotic and culturally rich locations. Whether you're looking to explore the stunning beaches of Hawaii, immerse yourself in the vibrant cultures of Asia, or embark on an adventure in Australia and New Zealand, Pacific Holidays Inc. has the expertise and resources to make your dream vacation a reality. With a team of knowledgeable travel specialists and a commitment to customer satisfaction, Pacific Holidays Inc. is your go-to agency for creating unforgettable travel memories.

Caesar's Travel LLC is a premier travel agency located at 126 Heather Circle in Newburgh, New York. With a team of experienced travel professionals, we specialize in creating customized travel experiences for our clients. Whether you're looking to book a relaxing beach getaway, an adventurous safari, or a romantic European vacation, we have the expertise to make your travel dreams a reality. Contact us today to start planning your next unforgettable journey with Caesar's Travel LLC.

The Palisades Information Center is a travel agency located on the Palisades Interstate Parkway in Tomkins Cove, New York. This center serves as a hub for travelers seeking information on local attractions, accommodations, and activities in the area. Visitors can stop by to pick up brochures, maps, and other resources to help plan their trip. The knowledgeable staff at the Palisades Information Center are available to provide recommendations and assistance to ensure a memorable and enjoyable visit to the beautiful Palisades region.