The 30 Best Indulgent eats in New York

Welcome to Nicky's On the Bay, your premier destination for exceptional waterfront dining in Bay Shore, New York. Located at 150 South Clinton Avenue, our restaurant offers a unique blend of delicious cuisine, breathtaking views, and a welcoming atmosphere that makes every visit feel like a mini vacation. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, hosting an office function, or planning any special occasion, Nicky's On the Bay brings your event to life with meticulous attention to detail. Our team ensures that your experience is seamless and memorable, allowing you to enjoy your event just as you imagined.

Welcome to Key West Islip Beach, your go-to destination for a delightful culinary experience right by the waterfront. Nestled at 600 South Bay Avenue in the charming town of Islip, New York, our restaurant offers a unique blend of vibrant flavors inspired by the tropical allure of Key West. At Key West Islip Beach, we pride ourselves on serving fresh, high-quality dishes that capture the essence of island cuisine. Our menu features a diverse selection of seafood, succulent meats, and refreshing salads, all crafted with a touch of Caribbean flair. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, or a family gathering, our inviting atmosphere and friendly staff ensure a memorable dining experience.

Welcome to Chiddy's Cheesesteaks of West Islip, your local destination for authentic Philly cheesesteaks and more! Conveniently located at 510 Union Boulevard, West Islip, New York 11795, we bring the iconic taste of Philadelphia right to your doorstep. No need for a road trip down I-95; the best cheesesteak experience is now available right here on Long Island. At Chiddy's Cheesesteaks, we pride ourselves on delivering the real-deal Philly flavor that you crave. Our menu is packed with mouthwatering options including our signature cheesesteaks, delectable beef and cheddar empanadas, creamy mac n’ cheese, spicy nachos, and crunchy mozzarella sticks. We cater to all tastes with a kid's menu, lighter fare, hot dogs, and even our unique spin on Mexican favorites. Don’t forget to indulge in our homemade desserts!

Welcome to Smoke Shack BBQ, your go-to destination for authentic and mouthwatering barbecue in Center Moriches, New York. Conveniently located at 792 Montauk Highway, our restaurant is a haven for food lovers seeking the rich, smoky flavors of traditional BBQ. At Smoke Shack BBQ, we pride ourselves on using the finest ingredients and time-honored techniques to craft our delicious menu. From tender brisket and juicy ribs to flavorful pulled pork and savory chicken, each dish is smoked to perfection, ensuring a delectable experience with every bite. Our sides, such as creamy coleslaw, tangy baked beans, and buttery cornbread, perfectly complement our main offerings, making for a satisfying meal you won't soon forget.

Welcome to Gourmet Garden, your go-to destination for exquisite dining and convenient meal delivery in the heart of Center Moriches, New York. Nestled at 802 Main Street, our charming establishment invites you to indulge in a culinary experience that marries the freshest local ingredients with innovative, mouth-watering recipes. At Gourmet Garden, we are passionate about crafting dishes that not only satisfy your cravings but also delight your senses. Whether you’re dining in our cozy restaurant or enjoying the convenience of our prompt meal delivery service, you can expect nothing less than exceptional quality and flavor.

Welcome to PawPaw Pop Up, your go-to culinary destination located on Main Street in the charming village of Greenport, New York. Nestled in the heart of the North Fork, PawPaw Pop Up is a vibrant and inviting restaurant that promises an unforgettable dining experience. Our menu is a delightful fusion of flavors, showcasing the freshest local ingredients and innovative culinary techniques. Whether you're a local resident or a visitor exploring the picturesque surroundings, PawPaw Pop Up offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere where you can indulge in a diverse selection of mouthwatering dishes. Join us for a delicious meal and discover why PawPaw Pop Up is the talk of Greenport. We look forward to serving you and making your dining experience truly special.

Welcome to Jennie’s at Drossos, a delightful culinary gem nestled in the heart of Greenport, New York. Located at 69125 Main Road, our charming restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where both locals and visitors can indulge in a memorable dining experience. At Jennie’s, we pride ourselves on serving an array of delectable dishes crafted from the freshest local ingredients, celebrating the rich flavors of our region. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast, a leisurely lunch, or an intimate dinner, our diverse menu has something to satisfy every palate. Our friendly staff is dedicated to providing exceptional service, ensuring that every visit is as enjoyable as it is delicious. Come and discover the unique taste of Greenport at Jennie’s at Drossos – where great food and good company await you.

Welcome to The Terrace at The Pridwin, a culinary haven nestled on the picturesque Shelter Island. Located at 81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, New York, our restaurant offers a delightful dining experience with a menu that caters to diverse tastes and dietary preferences. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty breakfast featuring New York strip steak and eggs or a light vegan meal with smashed avocado on sourdough, our menu is designed to satisfy. Our commitment to quality and variety shines through in our selection of gluten-free, vegan, and classic dishes. Savor the taste of our exquisite seafood platters, enjoy the zest of our vibrant salads, or indulge in one of our decadent desserts. Pair your meal with one of our signature cocktails or a choice from our extensive tea selection.

Welcome to Pizza Uno Inc, your go-to destination for mouthwatering pizzas and delectable dishes in Southold, New York. Located at 46455 County Road 48, Pizza Uno has been a beloved staple in the community, offering a diverse menu that caters to all tastes. Indulge in our signature thin crust pizzas topped with fresh plum tomatoes, basil, garlic, and mozzarella, or savor the rich flavors of our blended ricotta, Romano cheese, and parsley creation. For meat lovers, our hearty combination of tomato sauce, meatballs, sausage, pepperoni, and mozzarella is a must-try. Vegetarians will delight in our veggie-packed pizza loaded with mushrooms, onions, green peppers, olives, broccoli, and mozzarella.

Welcome to Pookaberry Cafe, a charming culinary haven nestled in the heart of Mattituck, New York. Located at 140 Pike Street, our cozy cafe offers a delightful escape where the aroma of freshly brewed coffee and the sizzle of delicious dishes fill the air. At Pookaberry Cafe, we pride ourselves on serving a diverse menu that caters to all taste buds, featuring everything from hearty breakfast classics to delectable lunch options and indulgent desserts. Our commitment to using locally sourced, high-quality ingredients ensures that every bite is a memorable experience. Whether you're looking for a relaxing spot to enjoy a leisurely meal or a quick coffee break, our friendly staff is dedicated to providing exceptional service in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Stop by Pookaberry Cafe today and discover why we're a beloved local favorite in Mattituck.

Welcome to Primavera Pizza, your go-to destination for mouthwatering Italian cuisine in Mattituck, New York. Nestled at 13500 Main Road, we offer a delightful array of food options that are sure to satisfy your cravings. As a beloved local pizzeria, we've been serving the community with passion and dedication, becoming a favorite spot for residents and visitors alike. At Primavera Pizza, we take pride in crafting delicious meals using only the freshest ingredients. Our menu features a variety of delectable options, from our classic cheese pizzas with thin crust to specialty creations like ricotta and baby spinach pizza, and BBQ chicken with mozzarella. Indulge in our savory sandwiches, fresh salads, and hearty calzones. Don't miss our signature garlic knots, a perfect accompaniment to any meal.

Welcome to Barrow Food House, your go-to destination for a delightful culinary experience in the heart of Riverhead, New York. Nestled at 452 Main Road, our charming restaurant invites you to indulge in a menu that celebrates the freshest local ingredients and the rich flavors of our region. At Barrow Food House, we pride ourselves on offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for a casual lunch, a cozy dinner, or a special gathering with friends and family. Our talented chefs craft each dish with passion and creativity, ensuring a memorable dining experience that will leave you coming back for more. Whether you're a local resident or visiting the beautiful North Fork, we invite you to join us and savor the taste of our community. Come and discover why Barrow Food House is a beloved staple in Riverhead's vibrant food scene.

Welcome to Hampton Coffee Company, your go-to destination for a delightful culinary experience in Aquebogue, New York. Nestled in the heart of the East End at 272 Main Road, our cozy establishment is more than just a café—it's a community hub where the aroma of freshly brewed coffee and baked goods welcomes you. At Hampton Coffee Company, we pride ourselves on serving exceptional coffee, sourced sustainably and roasted to perfection. Whether you're stopping by for your morning espresso, a leisurely lunch, or an afternoon pick-me-up, our menu has something to satisfy every palate. Indulge in our selection of freshly baked pastries, artisanal sandwiches, and wholesome salads, all crafted with the finest local ingredients.

Welcome to Tropical Smoothie Cafe, your vibrant oasis located at 1080 Old Country Road, Riverhead, New York 11901. We're more than just a cafe; we're a destination for delicious, feel-good food and a refreshing escape from the everyday. Our menu is bursting with craveable flavors, from our signature smoothies to mouthwatering wraps, flatbreads, and our exciting new Tropic Bowls. Indulge in our fan-favorite Bahama Mama™ Bowl, overflowing with the tropical goodness of pineapple, strawberry, and coconut, or power up with our new PB Protein Crunch Bowl, packed with 32 grams of protein. Whether you're starting your day with a breakfast flatbread or treating yourself to a smoothie, breakfast is served all day in our tropical paradise.

Welcome to VIP on the 19th Tee, your go-to destination for fantastic food and unforgettable experiences in Riverhead, New York! Located at 661 Riverside Drive, our restaurant is a haven for food lovers, sports fans, and families alike. At VIP on the 19th Tee, we pride ourselves on offering exceptional service through our convenient online ordering system, ensuring that you can enjoy our mouth-watering dishes with ease. Whether you're ordering for pick-up or delivery, we've got you covered with fast and efficient service.

Welcome to Jerry & The Mermaid, your family-owned seafood haven located at 469 East Main Street, Riverhead, New York. Since 1994, we've been serving up smiles and unforgettable memories alongside our delicious seafood and American classics. Founded by our visionary parents, our restaurant has become a beloved staple in Long Island, and we're proud to continue their legacy by passing the seafood baton to the next generation. At Jerry & The Mermaid, our menu is a heartfelt tribute to the ocean, showcasing the freshest catches and local treasures. Indulge in a symphony of flavors crafted with care and passion, featuring locally sourced ingredients from craft beer and spirits to fresh produce and the finest fish and shellfish. Each bite and sip tells the story of our commitment to supporting local businesses and celebrating the unique flavors of our region.

Welcome to Barrila's Pastaria Restaurant & Bar, located at 300 East Main Street, Riverhead, New York, where culinary artistry meets authentic Italian tradition. Immerse yourself in the gourmet world of Chef Marco Barrila, who invites you to experience an open kitchen concept, allowing guests to witness the creation of artisanal dishes crafted by hand and cooked fresh just for you. At Barrila's, we celebrate the rich and diverse culinary traditions of Italy, showcasing the best of authentic Italian cuisine. Our expansive antipasti bar, light-filled dining room with soaring ceilings, pasta laboratory, pizzaiola station, Italian dessert section, and take-away market create a unique dining journey. Each dish is a testament to our commitment to quality, flavor, and the vibrant culinary culture of Italy.

Welcome to Golden Jalapenos Cafe, your go-to destination for a delightful culinary experience in the heart of Calverton, New York. Conveniently located at 4486 Middle Country Road, our charming eatery invites you to savor the vibrant flavors of our diverse menu, crafted with love and the freshest ingredients. At Golden Jalapenos Cafe, we pride ourselves on offering a warm and inviting atmosphere where friends and family can come together to enjoy a memorable dining experience. Our menu features a delectable array of dishes that cater to a variety of tastes, with a special focus on bold, spicy, and savory flavors. From our signature jalapeno-infused creations to classic comfort foods, each dish is meticulously prepared to delight your taste buds.

Welcome to Johnny Rockets at Splish Splash Water Park in Calverton, New York! Located conveniently at 2549 Splish Splash Drive, our classic American restaurant offers a delightful escape into the nostalgic world of 1950s diners. Step inside and enjoy our timeless menu featuring juicy burgers, crispy fries, and hand-spun shakes, all prepared with the freshest ingredients and a generous helping of fun. Whether you're taking a break from the water park excitement or just passing by, Johnny Rockets is the perfect spot to relax and indulge in a delicious meal. Our friendly staff is ready to serve you with a smile and ensure you have a memorable dining experience. Come join us for a taste of Americana and a dose of good vibes!

Welcome to Nathan's Famous, your ultimate destination for iconic American cuisine located in the heart of Riverhead, New York. Situated at 318 Tanger Mall Drive, our restaurant is proud to serve the delicious flavors that have made Nathan's Famous a household name since 1916. Whether you're shopping at the Tanger Outlets or simply passing through, our convenient location makes it easy to indulge in our world-renowned hot dogs, crispy crinkle-cut fries, and mouthwatering burgers. At Nathan's Famous, we are committed to quality and tradition, bringing you the same classic recipes that have delighted generations. Our menu offers a variety of options to satisfy every craving, from hearty meals to quick bites. Enjoy a casual dining experience in a friendly and welcoming atmosphere where great food and excellent service are always on the menu.

Welcome to Slice of the Hamptons, your go-to destination for delicious, fresh, and satisfying meals in Southampton, New York. Conveniently located at 20 County Road 39, our restaurant is renowned for offering a delightful array of classic and innovative dishes that cater to all taste buds. Our diverse menu features a variety of mouthwatering options, from vibrant salads with spinach, broccoli, and balsamic vinaigrette to hearty heroes filled with grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, and roasted peppers. Indulge in our savory selections like fried chicken with American cheese and Russian dressing or try our signature pizza topped with vine-ripe tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and basil seasoned with olive oil.

Welcome to Four Oaks Cafe & Juice Bar, your serene escape nestled in the heart of Southampton, New York. Located at 42 Jagger Lane, our cozy cafe is the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy a delightful array of fresh, delicious offerings. Whether you're starting your day with a revitalizing juice, indulging in a wholesome breakfast, or savoring a leisurely lunch, our diverse menu caters to all tastes and dietary preferences. At Four Oaks, we pride ourselves on using only the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients to craft our dishes and beverages. Our inviting atmosphere, combined with friendly service, creates a warm and welcoming experience for all our guests. From our expertly brewed coffees to our vibrant salads and satisfying sandwiches, everything is made with care and passion.

Welcome to Meschutt Beach Hut, your go-to destination for delicious food and a relaxed dining experience in the heart of Hampton Bays, New York. Nestled at 1 Canal Road, our vibrant restaurant offers a delightful escape where you can indulge in mouth-watering dishes while enjoying the stunning views of Meschutt Beach. At Meschutt Beach Hut, we pride ourselves on serving a diverse menu that caters to all taste buds. Whether you're in the mood for fresh seafood, juicy burgers, or refreshing salads, our culinary team prepares each dish with the finest ingredients and a passion for flavor. Pair your meal with one of our signature cocktails or a refreshing beverage from our extensive drink menu.

Welcome to TASTY ZONE, your ultimate destination for delightful culinary experiences in Hampton Bays, New York. Conveniently located at 12 West Montauk Highway, our store is a haven for food enthusiasts and casual shoppers alike. At TASTY ZONE, we pride ourselves on offering an extensive selection of high-quality, delicious products that cater to all tastes and preferences. Whether you're looking for fresh ingredients to elevate your home-cooked meals or seeking gourmet treats to indulge in, we've got you covered. Our friendly and knowledgeable staff are always on hand to provide personalized recommendations and ensure your shopping experience is both enjoyable and satisfying. Visit us today and discover the vibrant flavors and exceptional quality that make TASTY ZONE the go-to food store in Hampton Bays.

Welcome to Antojitos Bakery, your go-to destination for delightful baked goods and authentic flavors in Hampton Bays, New York. Nestled at 40 West Montauk Highway, our bakery offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can indulge in a wide array of freshly baked pastries, breads, and desserts. At Antojitos Bakery, we pride ourselves on using the finest ingredients to create delicious treats that satisfy every craving. Whether you're stopping by for a morning coffee and pastry, picking up a freshly baked loaf of bread for dinner, or ordering a custom cake for a special occasion, our dedicated team is here to ensure every bite is a memorable one.

Welcome to Tropical Smoothie Cafe, located at 32 East Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays, New York 11946! Our cafe is your go-to destination for a delightful dining experience, offering a vibrant selection of smoothies, bowls, wraps, and flatbreads. We are passionate about serving fresh, made-to-order food that not only satisfies your cravings but also boosts your mood. Whether you're starting your day with one of our breakfast flatbreads or indulging in our new Tropic Bowls, like the Bahama Mama™ bursting with pineapple, strawberry, and coconut, or the protein-packed PB Protein Crunch Bowl, we ensure every bite feels like a vacation. Join us in spreading the sunshine by becoming a part of our enthusiastic team! We are looking for fun, energetic crew members to join us. Apply now under Cafe Opportunities.

Welcome to Hampton Gyro and Grill, your go-to culinary destination in the heart of Hampton Bays, New York. Located at 252 West Montauk Highway, our restaurant offers a delightful fusion of authentic Mediterranean flavors and classic American grill favorites. Whether you're craving a savory gyro wrapped in warm pita or a perfectly grilled burger, our diverse menu is designed to satisfy every palate. At Hampton Gyro and Grill, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft each dish with care and passion. Our cozy and inviting atmosphere is perfect for family dinners, casual lunches, or a quick bite on the go. With a commitment to exceptional service and delicious food, we strive to make every visit a memorable experience.

Welcome to The Hamptons Shore Shack, your go-to destination for delicious coastal cuisine in the heart of Hampton Bays, New York. Nestled at 72 Foster Avenue, our charming restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can savor the freshest seafood and classic American dishes. Whether you're in the mood for a casual lunch, a family dinner, or a relaxing evening with friends, The Hamptons Shore Shack promises a delightful dining experience just steps away from the beautiful shores. Our menu features a variety of mouthwatering options, from succulent lobster rolls and crispy fish tacos to juicy burgers and refreshing salads, all crafted with the finest local ingredients. Join us and indulge in the vibrant flavors of the coast, paired with our selection of craft beers and signature cocktails. We look forward to welcoming you to The Hamptons Shore Shack, where every meal is a celebration of good food and great company.

Welcome to Michelangelo of Speonk, a beloved culinary gem located at 295 Montauk Highway, Remsenburg-Speonk, New York. Proudly managed by Carlo Illiano since August 2023, Michelangelo of Speonk is where Southern Italian cuisine meets the beloved classics of New York. With roots in Napoli and a deep connection to Long Island, Carlo brings a unique blend of tradition and innovation to every dish. Our passion for quality is unwavering. We source fresh ingredients from local farmers whenever possible, ensuring that every meal is a testament to the finest flavors of the season. Whether you're dining in for the full experience or enjoying our dishes from the comfort of your home, we guarantee satisfaction. Order with ease through our website or your favorite delivery apps like DoorDash, GrubHub, and UberEats.

Welcome to Loco Lobster, your premier destination for the freshest and finest seafood in East Moriches, New York. Conveniently located at 223 Montauk Highway, our restaurant is committed to delivering an exceptional dining experience that celebrates the bounty of the sea. At Loco Lobster, we pride ourselves on serving only the highest quality seafood, sourced from trusted local suppliers. Our dedication to freshness and quality ensures that every dish we serve is a testament to the rich flavors and vibrant textures of the ocean's offerings.