TOP 30 Best Comfortable island lodging in Garden City, New York

Welcome to Fainting Goat Island Inn Nestled at 1311 West River Road, Nichols, New York, the Fainting Goat Island Inn offers a unique lodging experience that blends history, nature, and a touch of the supernatural. Overlooking our 17-acre island in the Susquehanna River, this charming inn is conveniently located just a mile east of Tioga Downs Casino and a minute off Interstate 86/17, right on the NY/PA border.

Long Island National Cemetery Welcome to Long Island National Cemetery, a tranquil and dignified resting place dedicated to honoring the memory and service of our nation's Veterans. Located at 2040 Wellwood Avenue in Farmingdale, New York, our cemetery offers a serene environment for reflection and remembrance, serving as a testament to the bravery and sacrifice of those who have served in the armed forces.

Flynn's Garden Inn is a cozy and inviting bar located at 46-08 Skillman Avenue in New York, United States. With its laid-back atmosphere, friendly staff, and delicious drinks, it's the perfect spot to unwind after a long day or catch up with friends. The garden area adds a touch of charm and relaxation to your experience, making it a great place to enjoy a cold beer or cocktail. Whether you're looking for a casual night out or a fun gathering with friends, Flynn's Garden Inn is the place to be.

Hilton Garden Inn Watertown/Thousand Islands is a charming lodging establishment located at 1290 Arsenal Street in the picturesque city of Watertown, New York, United States. Situated near the stunning Thousand Islands region, this hotel offers comfortable accommodations and modern amenities for both leisure and business travelers. Guests can enjoy spacious rooms, a fitness center, indoor pool, on-site restaurant, and convenient access to local attractions. Whether you're visiting for a weekend getaway or a business trip, Hilton Garden Inn Watertown/Thousand Islands provides a welcoming and relaxing atmosphere for all guests.

Shelter Island House is a charming and cozy bar and lodging establishment located at 11 Stearns Point Road in Shelter Island Heights, New York. Nestled in a picturesque setting, this institution offers a peaceful retreat for guests looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life. With comfortable accommodations and a welcoming atmosphere, Shelter Island House is the perfect destination for a relaxing getaway. Enjoy a drink at the bar or unwind in one of the beautifully appointed rooms, all while taking in the stunning views of Shelter Island. Experience the beauty and tranquility of this hidden gem in the heart of New York.

Located in the heart of Stony Brook, New York, Hilton Garden Inn is a premier lodging destination offering modern amenities and exceptional service. Situated at 1 Circle Road, this hotel provides easy access to Stony Brook University, Stony Brook Village Center, and other local attractions. Guests can enjoy comfortable rooms, a fitness center, an indoor pool, and a delicious on-site restaurant. Whether visiting for business or leisure, Hilton Garden Inn Stony Brook is the perfect choice for a relaxing and enjoyable stay in Long Island.

The Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Garden City is a cozy and comfortable lodging option located at 700 Garden City Plaza in the picturesque town of Garden City, New York. This hotel offers spacious and well-appointed suites, perfect for both short and extended stays. Guests can enjoy amenities such as a complimentary hot breakfast, a fitness center, an indoor pool, and a stylish lobby lounge. The convenient location allows for easy access to nearby attractions, shopping centers, and dining options. Whether you are traveling for business or leisure, the Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Garden City is the perfect home away from home.

Hilton Garden Inn New York/Staten Island is a modern and stylish lodging establishment located at 1100 South Avenue in New York, United States. Situated in the vibrant Staten Island neighborhood, this hotel offers comfortable and spacious rooms with contemporary amenities. Guests can enjoy a variety of on-site facilities including a fitness center, restaurant, and meeting rooms. With its convenient location and excellent service, Hilton Garden Inn New York/Staten Island is the perfect choice for both business and leisure travelers visiting the area.

Homewood Suites by Hilton Carle Place - Garden City is a comfortable and welcoming lodging establishment located at 40 Westbury Avenue in Carle Place, New York. This hotel offers spacious suites equipped with modern amenities, perfect for both short and extended stays. Guests can enjoy complimentary breakfast, a fitness center, and a relaxing indoor pool. Conveniently located near shopping centers, restaurants, and attractions, Homewood Suites by Hilton Carle Place - Garden City is the ideal choice for travelers looking for a home away from home in the heart of Long Island.

Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island is a stylish and modern lodging institution located at 1 North Avenue in the charming town of Garden City, New York. This hotel offers comfortable accommodations and a range of amenities to ensure a pleasant stay for guests. The convenient location allows easy access to popular attractions and shopping destinations in the area. Whether you are visiting for business or leisure, Hampton Inn by Hilton Garden City Long Island provides a welcoming and relaxing environment for all travelers.

Welcome to Hilton Garden Inn Riverhead, your ideal lodging destination located at 2038 Old Country Road, Riverhead, New York. Nestled in the heart of Long Island’s beautiful North Fork, our hotel offers a perfect blend of comfort, convenience, and modern amenities to ensure a memorable stay. Whether you're visiting for business or leisure, you'll appreciate our well-appointed guest rooms, featuring plush bedding, complimentary Wi-Fi, and a spacious work area. Start your day with a delicious breakfast at our on-site restaurant, The Garden Grille & Bar, where you can also enjoy dinner and cocktails in the evening. Our 24-hour fitness center and indoor pool provide the perfect opportunity to relax and unwind. For business travelers, we offer fully equipped meeting spaces and a business center to cater to all your professional needs.

Emby Island Bed and Breakfast is a charming lodging establishment located in Hammond, New York, United States. Situated on a picturesque island, guests can enjoy stunning views of the surrounding natural beauty and peaceful atmosphere. The cozy rooms are tastefully decorated and equipped with modern amenities to ensure a comfortable stay. Guests can start their day with a delicious homemade breakfast served in the dining area or out on the deck overlooking the water. The friendly and attentive staff are always on hand to provide personalized service and recommendations for exploring the area. Whether you're looking for a relaxing getaway or a romantic retreat, Emby Island Bed and Breakfast is the perfect destination for a memorable stay.

Wyndham Garden Long Island City is a modern and stylish lodging option located at 44-29 9th Street in New York, United States. Situated in the vibrant neighborhood of Long Island City, this hotel offers comfortable accommodations and top-notch amenities for both business and leisure travelers. Guests can enjoy spacious rooms, on-site dining options, a fitness center, and easy access to popular attractions in the city. With its convenient location and excellent service, Wyndham Garden Long Island City is the perfect choice for a memorable stay in New York.

The Red Roof PLUS Long Island - Garden City is a cozy and comfortable lodging facility located in Westbury, New York. Situated at 699 Dibblee Drive, this institution offers a convenient and affordable accommodation option for travelers visiting the area. With modern amenities and friendly staff, guests can enjoy a relaxing stay in a peaceful environment. Whether you are in town for business or leisure, the Red Roof PLUS Long Island - Garden City provides a welcoming and enjoyable experience for all guests.

Plant Island is a unique lodging institution located in the heart of New York City. Situated in a lush and tranquil setting, this oasis offers a peaceful escape from the hustle and bustle of the city. The accommodations at Plant Island are designed to provide guests with a relaxing and rejuvenating experience, with comfortable rooms and beautiful gardens to explore. Whether you are looking for a quiet retreat or a romantic getaway, Plant Island is the perfect destination for those seeking a peaceful and serene environment. Come and experience the beauty and tranquility of Plant Island in the vibrant city of New York.

Coliseum Inn & Suites - Garden City Long Island is a charming lodging establishment located at 1650 A Hempstead Turnpike in East Meadow, New York. This cozy inn offers comfortable and affordable accommodations for travelers visiting Long Island. The convenient location provides easy access to nearby attractions, shopping centers, and dining options. Guests can enjoy spacious rooms, complimentary breakfast, and friendly service during their stay. Whether you're in town for business or leisure, Coliseum Inn & Suites is the perfect choice for your stay in Long Island.

Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast is a luxurious lodging and spa institution located at 8900 Main Road, East Marion, New York, United States. Guests are welcomed to the Long Island North Fork Bed & Breakfast in Greenport, NY where they can eat, drink, play, and stay in style. Enjoy delicious gourmet breakfasts each day in our romantic and comfortable rooms. We offer spa services and romantic getaways for special occasions such as anniversaries, birthdays, engagements, honeymoons, and holidays. Guests can also book a VIP or self-guided wine tour to explore the vineyards in New York's newest wine region. Our wine-varietal-themed rooms add a unique touch to your stay. Guests can also enjoy our "Paint and Pour" retreats and indulge in a Valentine's Romantic Getaway Package. Nearby, Noah's Restaurant in Greenport offers farm-to-table dining for a truly exquisite culinary experience. Whether you're looking for a short weekend break or an extended holiday, Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast provides modern comforts in a traditional setting. Contact us at (631) 477-8440 or innkeeper@arborviewhouse.com to book your stay now.

Welcome to J & S Reeve Cottages, your premier destination for waterfront vacation rentals on Long Island, NY. Located at 28 White's Lane, Aquebogue, New York 11931, our charming cottages offer a tranquil escape nestled along the serene shores of Reeves Creek and the Peconic Bay. Discover a unique lodging experience with our selection of six beautifully appointed cottages, each designed to provide you with the utmost comfort and relaxation. Whether you're seeking a cozy retreat or a spacious getaway, our cottages cater to all your needs, offering self-catering facilities and stunning waterfront views.

Shorecrest Bed & Breakfast is a charming lodging located in Southold, New York. Situated at 54300 County Road 48, this cozy bed and breakfast offers a relaxing and peaceful retreat for guests looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life. The institution features comfortable rooms, delicious breakfast options, and a warm and inviting atmosphere. With its convenient location and attentive staff, Shorecrest Bed & Breakfast is the perfect choice for a tranquil getaway in the beautiful surroundings of the North Fork of Long Island.

Cider Mill Inn is a charming lodging located at 207 Glenwood Road in Pine Island, New York. Nestled in the picturesque countryside, this cozy inn offers a peaceful retreat for travelers looking to relax and unwind. The rooms are tastefully decorated and equipped with modern amenities to ensure a comfortable stay. Guests can enjoy a delicious breakfast in the dining area or take a stroll through the beautiful gardens surrounding the inn. With its warm hospitality and serene atmosphere, Cider Mill Inn is the perfect destination for a tranquil getaway in the United States.

Fina's Farmhouse is a charming cafe, food store, and restaurant located at 20 Ellis Street in the heart of New York City. Our cozy and inviting farmhouse-style setting offers a unique dining experience where guests can enjoy delicious homemade meals made with fresh, locally-sourced ingredients. From hearty breakfast options to mouth-watering lunch and dinner selections, Fina's Farmhouse has something to satisfy every craving. Our store also offers a variety of specialty food items and gifts for purchase. Come visit us at Fina's Farmhouse for a taste of home-cooked comfort in the bustling city!

Harbor House Bed & Breakfast is a charming lodging establishment located at 1 Hylan Boulevard in New York, United States. Nestled in a picturesque setting, this cozy bed and breakfast offers a tranquil retreat for guests looking to relax and unwind. With comfortable accommodations, warm hospitality, and a delicious homemade breakfast served each morning, Harbor House is the perfect choice for a peaceful getaway in the bustling city. Whether you're visiting for business or pleasure, you'll feel right at home at Harbor House Bed & Breakfast.

Welcome to Wells House Bed & Breakfast, your charming home away from home nestled in the heart of Greenport, New York. Located at 530 Main Street, our historic B&B offers a perfect blend of comfort, elegance, and warm hospitality. Whether you're here for a romantic getaway, a relaxing retreat, or to explore the vibrant local area, Wells House is the ideal destination. Our beautifully appointed rooms are designed to provide a cozy and inviting atmosphere, ensuring a restful night's sleep. Each morning, awaken to the delightful aroma of a freshly prepared breakfast, featuring locally sourced ingredients that highlight the flavors of the region.

Candle Lite Inn & Guest House is a charming lodging establishment located at 3 South Ferry Road on Shelter Island in New York, United States. This cozy and inviting guest house offers comfortable accommodations in a serene and picturesque setting. Guests can enjoy a peaceful stay surrounded by lush gardens and quaint decor. The inn provides a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for those looking for a relaxing getaway. With its convenient location and friendly staff, Candle Lite Inn & Guest House is the ideal choice for travelers seeking a tranquil retreat on Shelter Island.

Located at 75 North Station Plaza in Great Neck, New York, The Andrew Hotel is a boutique lodging institution offering a refined and contemporary escape on Long Island's North Shore. Just a short 35-minute train ride from the bustling city of New York, The Andrew Hotel provides a convenient location to access the city's vibrant atmosphere while enjoying the charm of a small-town setting. Guests can relax in boutique-style rooms featuring high-quality oak furniture, comfortable bedding, and modern amenities such as flat-screen TVs and complimentary Wi-Fi. Indulge in personalized service and contemporary comfort during your stay at The Andrew Hotel.

Two South Ferry B&B is a charming bed and breakfast located at 2 South Ferry Road on Shelter Island in New York, United States. This cozy lodging offers a warm and welcoming atmosphere for guests looking for a peaceful retreat. The B&B features comfortable rooms, delicious breakfast options, and personalized service to ensure a relaxing stay. Situated in a beautiful and tranquil setting, Two South Ferry B&B is the perfect destination for a weekend getaway or a longer vacation. Experience the charm and hospitality of this lovely establishment during your next visit to Shelter Island.

Welcome to Blue Iris Bed & Breakfast, a charming retreat nestled in the heart of Cutchogue, New York. Located at 1100 Skunk Lane, our delightful establishment offers a tranquil escape in the picturesque setting of Long Island's North Fork. Blue Iris Bed & Breakfast combines the warmth of a cozy inn with the amenities of a modern lodging experience, making it the perfect destination for a relaxing getaway. Our beautifully appointed rooms provide a serene and comfortable atmosphere, each thoughtfully designed to ensure a peaceful night's sleep. Wake up to the aroma of a delicious homemade breakfast, crafted with fresh, local ingredients to kickstart your day. Whether you're exploring the nearby vineyards, enjoying the scenic beaches, or simply unwinding in our lush gardens, Blue Iris offers a serene base for your adventures.

Avis Car Rental at Buffalo Niagara International Airport (BUF) in Cheektowaga, New York, offers a seamless and convenient car rental experience for both leisure and business travelers. Located at 4200 Genesee Street, our rental counter is within the terminal, providing easy access upon your arrival, with a short walk to the car lot for vehicle pick-up. Whether you're planning a family vacation, business trip, or a local getaway, Avis has a variety of vehicles to suit your needs. Choose from compact cars, sedans, SUVs, minivans, and even luxury vehicles for added comfort and style. For larger groups, we offer 12- and 15-passenger vans, ensuring everyone travels together comfortably.

Located in the heart of Brooklyn, Best Western Plus Brooklyn-Prospect Park offers comfortable and modern lodging for both business and leisure travelers. Situated at 928 Coney Island Avenue, this hotel is conveniently located near popular attractions such as Prospect Park, Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and Barclays Center. The hotel features well-appointed rooms, complimentary breakfast, a fitness center, and a business center. Whether you are visiting New York for work or pleasure, Best Western Plus Brooklyn-Prospect Park provides a convenient and welcoming place to stay.

West Neck Guesthouse is a charming lodging establishment located at 31 West Neck Road in Shelter Island Heights, New York. This quaint guesthouse offers a peaceful retreat for visitors looking to unwind and relax on beautiful Shelter Island. The guesthouse features comfortable rooms, modern amenities, and a welcoming atmosphere. Guests can enjoy the picturesque surroundings, explore nearby attractions, or simply unwind in the cozy accommodations. Whether you're seeking a weekend getaway or a longer stay, West Neck Guesthouse is the perfect choice for a memorable stay on Shelter Island.