TOP 10 Best island restaurant in New City, New York

Welcome to All Seasons Catering Inc, your premier choice for exceptional catering services on Shelter Island, New York. Nestled at 23 North Ferry Road, we are dedicated to bringing culinary excellence and personalized service to your events, no matter the season. Our expert chefs craft delightful menus using the freshest local ingredients, ensuring a memorable dining experience for you and your guests. Whether you're planning an intimate gathering, a grand wedding, or a corporate event, All Seasons Catering Inc promises to deliver impeccable service tailored to your unique needs. We pride ourselves on our creativity, attention to detail, and commitment to making your occasion truly special.

Welcome to Isola, your premier dining destination nestled in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, New York. Located at 15 Grand Avenue, our charming restaurant invites you to embark on a culinary journey that captures the essence of both local and international flavors. At Isola, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu crafted from the freshest ingredients, celebrating the bounty of Long Island and beyond. Our talented chefs bring passion and creativity to every dish, ensuring a memorable dining experience for our guests. Whether you're joining us for a casual lunch, a romantic dinner, or a special celebration, our warm and inviting atmosphere provides the perfect backdrop for any occasion.

Welcome to The Eccentric Bagel, your go-to destination for delightful culinary experiences nestled in the heart of Shelter Island. Located at 25 West Neck Road, New York, The Eccentric Bagel is more than just a bakery—it's a vibrant cafe, a cozy restaurant, and a unique food store all rolled into one. Step inside and discover a world of freshly baked goods that tantalize the senses. Our artisan bagels are crafted with passion and creativity, offering a variety of flavors that cater to both traditional tastes and adventurous palates. Whether you're in the mood for a classic plain bagel or something more daring, we promise a delightful twist on every bite.

Welcome to The 1901 Grill, a cherished dining destination nestled in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, New York. Located at 26 Sunnyside Avenue, our restaurant promises an unforgettable culinary experience, blending authentic flavors with traditional dishes that celebrate the rich heritage of our locale. As a beloved Shelter Island institution, The 1901 Grill prides itself on maintaining local integrity, exceptional service, and mouthwatering cuisine. Whether you're planning a family gathering or a romantic date night, our welcoming atmosphere and stunning views of the golf course and bay provide the perfect backdrop for any occasion.

Welcome to Chez Marie, a newly established gem nestled within The Shelter Island House Inn at 11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, New York. This sophisticated restaurant, bar, and lounge invites you to indulge in an extraordinary culinary journey. Our expert culinary team meticulously crafts each dish, ensuring a symphony of flavors that will captivate your taste buds and leave you craving more. At Chez Marie, we pride ourselves on offering an exquisite dining experience that goes beyond just food. Our chic decor, featuring elegant antique furniture, creates a charming and refined atmosphere. The carefully subdued lighting and thoughtfully curated background music set the perfect mood for a relaxing and intimate evening.

Welcome to Little Fish, a charming culinary gem located in the heart of Southold, New York, at 50 North Sea Drive. Nestled in the picturesque surroundings of Long Island's North Fork, Little Fish offers a delightful dining experience that celebrates the freshest local seafood and seasonal ingredients. Our restaurant is a haven for food enthusiasts who appreciate the art of simple yet exquisite flavors. At Little Fish, we take pride in crafting each dish with care, ensuring that every bite is a testament to our commitment to quality and sustainability. Our menu features an array of seafood specialties, complemented by locally-sourced produce and a selection of fine wines.

Welcome to Commander Cody's Fish Shoppe, your go-to destination for fresh seafood delights on Shelter Island! Nestled in the heart of Shelter Island at 41 Smith Street, Commander Cody's offers a unique blend of a food market, meal takeaway, and restaurant all in one. Whether you're a local or a visitor, you'll find a warm, welcoming atmosphere that celebrates the bounty of the sea. Our menu features a wide variety of freshly caught seafood, prepared with care and creativity. From our famous fish and chips to succulent crab cakes and mouth-watering lobster rolls, every dish is crafted to showcase the natural flavors of the ocean. We pride ourselves on sourcing only the freshest ingredients, ensuring a dining experience that is both delicious and sustainable.

Welcome to SALT Waterfront Bar & Grill, your premier dining destination located at 63 Menantic Road, Shelter Island, New York. Nestled along the picturesque waterfront, our vibrant bar and grill offers a delightful escape with stunning views and a relaxed atmosphere. Indulge in our diverse menu featuring fresh, locally-sourced ingredients and expertly crafted cocktails, perfect for any occasion. Please note that we do not allow dogs in our awning or dining room, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable experience for all our guests. For those exploring the area, we invite you to visit our sister restaurant conveniently located just off the North Ferry in Greenport, where you can continue your culinary adventure.

Welcome to Touch of Venice, a charming culinary haven nestled in the heart of Cutchogue, New York. Located at 28350 Main Road, our restaurant offers an exquisite blend of authentic Italian flavors and local charm, making it a must-visit destination for both locals and travelers alike. At Touch of Venice, we pride ourselves on delivering an exceptional dining experience with a menu that celebrates the rich traditions of Italian cuisine. Our skilled chefs use the freshest ingredients to craft dishes that are as visually stunning as they are delicious. From classic pasta creations to innovative seafood dishes, every meal is a celebration of taste and tradition.

Welcome to Braun Seafood Company, your premier destination for the finest fresh seafood on Long Island. Located at 30840 Main Road, Cutchogue, New York, our family-owned business has proudly served the Suffolk County and Twin Forks communities for nearly 100 years. What began as a small fishmonger on the eastern end of Long Island has grown into a trusted and beloved local hub for seafood enthusiasts. At the heart of Braun Seafood Co. is our Fish Market, where we supply our community with the freshest seafood and a warm, friendly atmosphere. We are dedicated to providing our customers with the highest quality seafood, sourced daily to ensure unmatched freshness and flavor.

Welcome to Cluckman's, your ultimate destination for delicious, mouth-watering culinary delights in the heart of Sag Harbor, New York. Located at 22 Long Island Avenue, our restaurant offers a cozy and inviting atmosphere where you can savor an array of expertly crafted dishes that celebrate the rich flavors and vibrant ingredients of the region. At Cluckman's, we pride ourselves on providing a unique dining experience that combines the warmth of a local eatery with the sophistication of gourmet cuisine. Our menu features a diverse selection of dishes, from classic comfort foods to innovative creations, all prepared with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty meal or a light snack, our talented chefs are dedicated to satisfying your cravings with their culinary expertise.

Welcome to Meat's Meat BBQ Shop, a haven for barbecue enthusiasts located at 9095 Sound Avenue, Mattituck, New York. As a local gem, we pride ourselves on delivering authentic, mouth-watering BBQ experiences that cater to any occasion. Whether you're celebrating a milestone or simply craving some comforting BBQ, we have you covered. Our talented team, led by Pit Master Larry Mondello, serves up traditional American barbecue with a dedication to the "low and slow" method that ensures every bite is packed with flavor. Larry, a self-taught Long Island native, honed his skills over several years, diving deep into the art of BBQ by learning from the best pit masters across the United States.

Welcome to Michelangelo Pizzeria, your go-to destination for authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Mattituck, New York. Located at 10095 Main Road, our charming pizzeria invites you to savor a delightful array of traditional and contemporary Italian dishes. At Michelangelo Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft our mouthwatering pizzas, pastas, and classic Italian entrees. Whether you're in the mood for a crispy, wood-fired pizza topped with premium mozzarella and fresh basil or a hearty plate of homemade lasagna, our menu offers something to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to Clam Bar @ Alize Brewing, your go-to destination for exceptional food, refreshing drinks, and unforgettable events. Nestled in the heart of Mattituck, New York, at 10560 Main Road, our unique establishment combines the best of a bar, restaurant, and brewery experience. At Clam Bar @ Alize Brewing, we pride ourselves on offering a delightful menu featuring fresh, locally-sourced ingredients, perfectly paired with our handcrafted brews. Whether you're stopping by for a casual meal with friends or planning a special event, our inviting atmosphere and attentive service ensure an enjoyable experience for all.

Welcome to By Hand Catering, where culinary excellence meets personalized service! Located in the heart of Mattituck, New York, at 13550 Main Road, we are your go-to destination for exceptional catering services on Long Island. Our passion for food and dedication to quality shine through in every dish we create, ensuring your event is not only memorable but also delicious. At By Hand Catering, we specialize in crafting bespoke menus that cater to your unique tastes and dietary preferences. Whether you're planning an intimate gathering, a corporate event, or a grand celebration, our talented team is committed to delivering a seamless and delightful dining experience. We use only the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients to create dishes that are as visually stunning as they are flavorful.

Welcome to Jamesport Farm Brewery, your ultimate destination for a unique and refreshing craft beer experience in the heart of Riverhead, New York. Located at 5873 Sound Avenue, our brewery is nestled in the picturesque landscapes of Long Island's North Fork, offering a perfect blend of rustic charm and modern brewing excellence. At Jamesport Farm Brewery, we pride ourselves on crafting a diverse range of artisanal beers using locally sourced ingredients. Our commitment to quality and innovation is evident in every sip, whether you're enjoying a classic lager, a hoppy IPA, or one of our seasonal specialties. Our farm-to-pint approach ensures that each brew reflects the rich agricultural heritage of the region.

Welcome to RGNY, a unique destination where tradition meets innovation in the heart of North Fork. Located at 6025 Sound Avenue, Riverhead, New York, RGNY is not just a winery; it's a celebration of our rich Mexican heritage and the Rivero González family tradition. Since acquiring the renowned Martha Clara Vineyards in 2019, we have been dedicated to crafting exceptional wines while honoring our roots and embracing sustainable practices. Our journey is defined by a commitment to quality, innovation, and community. With 25 years of winemaking in Parras, Coahuila, Mexico—America's oldest wine-growing region—we bring a deep respect for our heritage to every bottle we produce on the North Fork. We strive to create a harmonious blend of old-world quality and new-world innovation, ensuring that each visit and every sip surpasses expectations.

Welcome to Pete's Taverna and PT's Back Bar @ The Red Barn, a charming culinary destination nestled in the heart of Riverhead, New York. Located at 3225 A Sound Avenue, our restaurant offers a unique dining experience that combines the warmth of a traditional taverna with the casual elegance of a back bar setting. At Pete's Taverna, we pride ourselves on serving a diverse menu that celebrates the rich flavors of Mediterranean and American cuisine. Our dishes are crafted with the freshest local ingredients, ensuring a delightful taste experience with every bite. Whether you're in the mood for a hearty meal, a light snack, or a refreshing drink, our menu is designed to cater to every palate.

Welcome to Jamesport Vineyards | Little Oak Wood Fired Kitchen, a delightful blend of culinary excellence and scenic charm located in the heart of Jamesport, New York. Nestled along the picturesque New York 25, our establishment offers a unique experience that combines the rustic elegance of a vineyard with the warmth of a wood-fired kitchen. At Jamesport Vineyards, we pride ourselves on crafting exquisite wines that capture the essence of our region's terroir. Our vineyards, set against the stunning backdrop of Long Island's North Fork, produce a variety of wines that are perfect for both casual sips and celebratory toasts. Whether you're a seasoned wine enthusiast or a curious newcomer, our tasting room invites you to explore and savor our diverse selection.

Welcome to Terra Vite North Fork Winery & Vineyard, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Long Island's renowned wine country. Located at 250 Manor Lane, Jamesport, New York, our establishment offers a unique blend of exquisite wines, delectable dining, and unforgettable experiences for both locals and tourists alike. At Terra Vite, we pride ourselves on our passion for crafting exceptional wines that reflect the unique terroir of the North Fork. Our vineyard produces a diverse range of varietals, each carefully cultivated and expertly blended to create wines that delight the senses. Whether you're a seasoned wine enthusiast or a curious newcomer, our knowledgeable staff is eager to guide you through a tasting journey that highlights the best of our offerings.

Welcome to Jason's Vineyard, a charming oasis nestled in the heart of Long Island's wine country at 1785 Main Road, Jamesport, New York. As both a delightful food destination and a captivating tourist attraction, Jason's Vineyard offers a unique experience for visitors seeking the perfect blend of relaxation and indulgence. At Jason's Vineyard, we pride ourselves on producing exquisite wines that reflect the rich terroir of the North Fork. Our lush vineyards are home to a variety of grape varietals, carefully nurtured to create wines that are both distinctive and memorable. Whether you're a seasoned wine enthusiast or a curious newcomer, our knowledgeable staff is excited to guide you through a tasting journey that highlights the best of our handcrafted wines.

Welcome to Bobby Van's Steakhouse, a premier dining destination located at 2393 Montauk Highway, Bridgehampton, New York. Known for our exceptional cuisine and warm ambiance, we invite you to experience the best in steakhouse dining. Join us for dinner on Friday and Saturday evenings from 5pm to 10pm, where reservations are required and can be made up to two weeks in advance. For lunch, enjoy open seating or make a reservation for parties of five or more.

Welcome to The Watershed Kitchen and Bar, your premier dining and event destination located at 46 Front Street, Jamesport, New York. Nestled in the heart of Long Island's North Fork, we offer an exquisite culinary experience that blends the rich flavors of our local region with the unique spice blends of international comfort cuisine. Whether you're planning a birthday party, an office function, or any special occasion, The Watershed Kitchen and Bar is here to bring your event to life, just as you imagined. Our versatile space can accommodate a wide range of functions, from intimate dinners to lively cocktail receptions. For your convenience, our VIP room is equipped with a flat-panel TV for presentations, while our talented kitchen team is ready to craft special menus tailored to your event's unique needs.

Welcome to Lenny's Pizza & Bistro, affectionately known as Lenny's of Jamesport, where the taste of Brooklyn meets the charm of Long Island. Conveniently located at 1451 Main Road in Jamesport, New York, our establishment has been a beloved culinary destination for over 30 years. Owner Lenny Lubrano brings his authentic Brooklyn New York City Recipe Pizza to the residents and visitors of Jamesport, Riverhead, Mattituck, and the wider Suffolk and Nassau County areas. At Lenny's, we pride ourselves on offering a delightful dining experience with our Original Brooklyn Recipe Pizza, expertly crafted in our brick-oven and wood-fired ovens. Whether you're dining in or taking out, our traditional pizzeria promises the finest Italian flavors. Our cozy dining room, open Wednesday through Sunday from 4 p.m. to closing, invites you to enjoy a full menu of Italian specialties, daily specials, and a full-service bar.

Welcome to Little Lucharitos, your go-to destination for delicious food and a vibrant dining experience in Aquebogue, New York. Located at 487 Main Road, our restaurant offers a unique blend of flavors that will tantalize your taste buds. Whether you're looking to enjoy a meal with family and friends or order takeout, we’ve got you covered. Simply tap the location you wish to order from to the right. At Little Lucharitos, we are proud to collaborate with Joe Ocasio, a professional wrestler, motivational speaker, athlete, fitness trainer, and brand ambassador for the Long Island Coalition Against Bullying (LICAB). Through this partnership, we aim to support LICAB's mission to combat bullying and empower children across Long Island. To learn more about Joe Ocasio, donate, or get involved with this incredible cause, tap below.

Welcome to Maple Tree BBQ, your go-to destination for mouthwatering BBQ and delicious drinks located at 820 West Main Street, Riverhead, New York. Nestled in the heart of Long Island's East End, our restaurant is dedicated to serving up the finest lunch and dinner options for dine-in, take-out, and catering services. At Maple Tree BBQ, we pride ourselves on our flavorful and authentic BBQ dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. Whether you're looking to enjoy a casual meal with friends or need catering for your next event, we've got you covered.

Welcome to Farm Country Kitchen, a charming culinary gem nestled in the heart of Riverhead, New York. Located at 513 West Main Street, our restaurant offers a delightful escape where rustic charm meets modern cuisine. At Farm Country Kitchen, we pride ourselves on serving fresh, locally-sourced ingredients that celebrate the rich agricultural heritage of Long Island. Our menu features a diverse array of dishes, from hearty farm-to-table classics to innovative creations that cater to all palates. Whether you're joining us for a leisurely lunch, a cozy dinner, or a special occasion, you’ll find a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like a home away from home.

Welcome to Jerry & The Mermaid, your family-owned seafood haven located at 469 East Main Street, Riverhead, New York. Since 1994, we've been serving up smiles and unforgettable memories alongside our delicious seafood and American classics. Founded by our visionary parents, our restaurant has become a beloved staple in Long Island, and we're proud to continue their legacy by passing the seafood baton to the next generation. At Jerry & The Mermaid, our menu is a heartfelt tribute to the ocean, showcasing the freshest catches and local treasures. Indulge in a symphony of flavors crafted with care and passion, featuring locally sourced ingredients from craft beer and spirits to fresh produce and the finest fish and shellfish. Each bite and sip tells the story of our commitment to supporting local businesses and celebrating the unique flavors of our region.

Welcome to Goldbergs Bagels, a cherished local gem nestled at 138 East Main Street, Riverhead, New York. Established in 1949, our bakery, food store, and restaurant have been a staple in the community, bringing the authentic taste of New York bagels to the heart of Long Island. Our story begins with Arthur 'Artie' Goldberg, a pioneer in the bagel industry and a key figure in the original bagel union. Over four generations, the Goldberg family has mastered the art of bagel-making, blending tradition with innovation to serve you the finest bagels. Marc Goldberg, following in his father's footsteps, has expanded the family legacy across the North and South forks of Long Island. With a deep-rooted commitment to quality and service, we offer a diverse selection of deli and bakery options that cater to every palate. Whether you're a local or just passing through, our welcoming atmosphere and mouthwatering menu will make you feel right at home.

Welcome to J and R's Steakhouse, where we've been perfecting the essence of The Great American Steakhouse for over 20 years. Located at 4362 Middle Country Road, Calverton, NY, we're proud to serve Long Island with some of the finest steakhouse fare. From our legendary 24 oz Double “Cowboy” Cut Ribeye to our tender Filet Mignon, our menu is a celebration of premium USDA Choice Steaks, hand-trimmed and cooked to perfection by our expert butchers and chefs. Whether you prefer your steak straight from the butcher block to the grill or marinated in our Super Secret J and R’s Steak Marinade, you'll savor every bite of our flavorful and tender cuts. Our offerings don't stop at steaks; indulge in our slow-roasted Prime Rib, fall-off-the-bone BBQ Ribs, and seafood combos that define our signature dining experience.