The 30 Best Authentic italian dining experience in New York City, New York

Welcome to JC Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Shirley, New York. Conveniently located at 55 Surrey Circle, our family-owned restaurant has been serving the community with passion and dedication, offering a warm and inviting atmosphere for all our guests. At JC Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft our mouth-watering pizzas, pastas, and classic Italian dishes. Whether you're in the mood for a traditional Margherita pizza, a hearty lasagna, or a crisp Caesar salad, our diverse menu has something to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to Milano Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Bellport, New York. Conveniently located at 10 Farber Drive, our cozy and welcoming restaurant offers a delightful dining experience for pizza lovers and food enthusiasts alike. At Milano Pizza, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes to craft mouthwatering pizzas, pastas, salads, and more. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita, a hearty Meat Lover's, or a specialty gourmet creation, our diverse menu has something to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to Mama Bella's Pizzeria & Restaurant, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Medford, New York. Located at 1600 New York 112, our family-owned establishment brings you the finest flavors of Italy with a modern twist. Whether you're in the mood for a delicious meal at our cozy restaurant or prefer the convenience of meal delivery, Mama Bella's has something for everyone. Our menu boasts a wide array of mouthwatering dishes, from our signature thin crust pizzas topped with fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, and tomato sauce, to hearty options like deep dish pizzas loaded with meats, cheeses, and savory sauces. Indulge in our delectable fried chicken cutlets with honey mustard dressing, or savor the rich flavors of our pasta dishes featuring fresh vegetables, creamy sauces, and premium meats.

Welcome to Medford's Pizza & Deli, your go-to destination for delicious food and exceptional service in the heart of Medford, New York. Conveniently located at 1699 Medford Avenue, we pride ourselves on offering a wide variety of mouth-watering options that are sure to satisfy every palate. At Medford's Pizza & Deli, we specialize in crafting authentic, hand-tossed pizzas topped with the freshest ingredients. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita, a hearty Meat Lover's, or a custom creation of your own, our pizzas are baked to perfection and guaranteed to delight.

Welcome to Carlo's Pizza Oven of Holbrook, your ultimate destination for a delightful culinary experience in Holbrook, New York. Nestled at 480 Patchogue-Holbrook Road, our establishment offers a unique blend of bar, food, meal delivery, and takeaway services, all wrapped up in a cozy restaurant atmosphere. At Carlo's Pizza Oven, we pride ourselves on serving an extensive menu that caters to every palate. Our signature pizzas are crafted with the finest ingredients, offering a variety of toppings including meatballs, mushrooms, onions, pepperoni, peppers, and sausage. For those with a penchant for seafood, our whole clams and breaded shrimp are sure to tantalize your taste buds.

Welcome to El Migueleño, where we elevate your dining experience with an exquisite blend of flavors from Mexico, El Salvador, and Spain. Conveniently located at 34 Wheeler Road, Central Islip, New York, our family-owned restaurant is your go-to destination for authentic and delicious meals. Whether you're craving the vibrant spices of Mexican cuisine or the hearty warmth of Salvadoran dishes, El Migueleño delivers an unforgettable culinary journey right to your table. Our menu is crafted with authentic recipes, ensuring every bite is a genuine taste of tradition. We invite you to try our signature pupusas, a beloved Salvadoran specialty. These thick griddle cakes are made from cornmeal or rice flour, embodying the rich cultural heritage of El Salvador, where they are celebrated as the national dish.

Welcome to Nino's Pizzeria & Cucina, your go-to destination for authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Mastic Beach, New York. Conveniently located at 201 Mastic Beach Road, our family-owned restaurant is dedicated to serving the finest Italian cuisine with a warm and inviting atmosphere. At Nino's, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes to create mouthwatering dishes that will transport your taste buds straight to Italy. Our menu features a delicious selection of classic pizzas, handcrafted pastas, and savory entrees, all made with love and care. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty lasagna, or a fresh Caprese salad, we have something to satisfy every craving.

Welcome to Anthony's Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Mastic Beach, New York. Conveniently located at 520 Mastic Road, our family-owned restaurant has been serving the community with passion and dedication, offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere for all our guests. At Anthony's Pizza, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft mouthwatering pizzas, savory pastas, and a variety of classic Italian dishes. Our menu features something for everyone, from our signature hand-tossed pizzas to hearty calzones, flavorful salads, and delectable desserts.

Welcome to Montauk Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious and authentic Italian cuisine in East Patchogue, New York. Conveniently located at 1407 Montauk Highway, our family-owned restaurant is dedicated to serving the community with a warm and welcoming atmosphere. At Montauk Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft our mouthwatering pizzas, pastas, and traditional Italian dishes. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty plate of spaghetti, or one of our specialty pies, our diverse menu has something for everyone. Our skilled chefs bring a touch of Italy to every dish, ensuring a memorable dining experience for all our guests.

Welcome to Sin Frontera Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic pizza in Patchogue, New York! Conveniently located at 1407 Montauk Highway, we pride ourselves on serving up a delightful blend of traditional flavors and innovative creations that cater to all tastes. Whether you're dining in, picking up a meal to go, or opting for our convenient delivery service, Sin Frontera Pizzeria is committed to providing you with a satisfying and memorable experience. Our menu features a wide variety of pizzas, from classic Margherita to gourmet specialties that push the boundaries of flavor. We also offer an array of mouth-watering appetizers, fresh salads, and delectable pasta dishes, ensuring there's something for everyone. At Sin Frontera Pizzeria, we use only the freshest ingredients and time-honored recipes to create meals that are not only delicious but also bring people together.

Welcome to Rocco's Pizza, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in Patchogue, New York. Located at 253 Medford Avenue, our family-owned restaurant offers an extensive menu that promises to tantalize your taste buds and satisfy your cravings. Known for serving some of the best pizza in Patchogue, Rocco's Pizza combines fresh ingredients and traditional recipes to deliver a truly unforgettable dining experience. Our diverse menu features a variety of mouth-watering options. From classic toppings like sausage, pepperoni, and extra cheese to gourmet creations featuring buffalo chicken, ricotta, and fresh basil, there's a pizza for every palate. But our offerings don't stop at pizza. Indulge in our succulent chicken cutlets, savory meatballs, and a selection of pasta dishes that range from creamy Alfredo to tangy marinara sauces. For those looking for lighter fare, we offer fresh salads and delicious sandwiches filled with premium meats and cheeses.

Welcome to The Pepperoni Grill Pizzeria & Restaurant, your ultimate destination for authentic Italian cuisine in Patchogue, New York. Located at 485 Waverly Avenue, our cozy and inviting restaurant offers a delightful array of Italian-inspired dishes, perfect for a casual meal or a special occasion. At The Pepperoni Grill, we pride ourselves on our delicious assortment of salads featuring a variety of fresh ingredients and unique flavors. Indulge in our Italian cold cut salad with salami, ham, provolone, roasted peppers, and more, all served over a bed of mixed greens with a side of our house Italian dressing. For a twist, try our Sopressata and provolone salad, complemented by homemade fresh mozzarella and mesculin greens, or our savory grilled chicken salads with artichoke hearts, capers, and a fresh lemon drizzle.

Welcome to Nonna's Pizzeria, your go-to destination for authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Patchogue, New York. Conveniently located at 499-27 Sunrise Highway, our family-owned restaurant invites you to experience the warm and inviting atmosphere reminiscent of a classic Italian kitchen. At Nonna's Pizzeria, we take pride in serving a wide variety of delicious, handcrafted pizzas made with the freshest ingredients. Our menu features traditional favorites like Margherita and Pepperoni, alongside inventive specialty pies that are sure to delight your taste buds. Beyond pizza, we offer a delectable selection of Italian dishes, including hearty pastas, savory calzones, and fresh salads, all crafted with love and care.

Welcome to Jersey Mike's Subs, your go-to destination for delicious, freshly made subs in Bohemia, New York! Conveniently located at 1500 Smithtown Avenue, our restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can enjoy a satisfying meal with friends and family. Known for our authentic East Coast-style subs, we pride ourselves on using only the freshest ingredients, including premium meats and cheeses sliced to order, and freshly baked bread that provides the perfect foundation for every sandwich. Whether you're looking for a quick meal takeaway or a comfortable place to dine, Jersey Mike's Subs has you covered. Our menu features a wide variety of options, from classic cold subs and hearty hot sandwiches to mouthwatering wraps and salads, ensuring there's something to satisfy every craving. Don't forget to pair your meal with our selection of sides and beverages for the complete Jersey Mike's experience.

Welcome to La Via Deli, your go-to destination for delicious and authentic culinary experiences in the heart of Brentwood, New York. Conveniently located at 1034-3 Suffolk Avenue, our charming deli and restaurant is dedicated to serving the community with a wide array of mouthwatering dishes that cater to every palate. At La Via Deli, we pride ourselves on offering a diverse menu that features a blend of traditional and contemporary flavors. Whether you're craving a hearty sandwich, a fresh salad, or a delectable hot meal, our expertly crafted dishes are made from the freshest ingredients, ensuring every bite is a delightful experience.

Welcome to Fratelli’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Mastic Beach, New York. Located conveniently at 351 Neighborhood Road, our family-owned establishment has been serving the community with delicious, homemade dishes that capture the essence of Italy. At Fratelli’s, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft our menu, featuring a delightful array of classic and contemporary Italian favorites. From our mouth-watering pizzas, baked to perfection in our traditional brick oven, to our savory pasta dishes and hearty entrees, every meal is a celebration of flavor and tradition.

Welcome to Pizza Time, your go-to destination for authentic Sicilian flavors in the heart of Mastic Beach, New York! Located at 273 Neighborhood Road, our cozy restaurant offers a delightful array of pizzas, pastas, salads, and more, crafted with the freshest ingredients and a touch of tradition. Indulge in our signature Sicilian pizzas, each topped with a unique combination of flavors that will transport your taste buds straight to Italy. From the classic medley of roasted vegetables, mozzarella cheese, and plum tomato sauce to the bold combination of fresh broccoli rabe, hot sausage, and mozzarella, our pizzas are a feast for the senses. For those who crave a crispy thin crust, try our Margherita pizza with crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil, and extra virgin olive oil.

Welcome to Uncle Joe's Famous Pizzeria (formerly Papa Nick's Pizza), your go-to destination for delicious, authentic pizza in Bellport, New York. Conveniently located at 117 South Country Road, our pizzeria offers a cozy atmosphere where you can enjoy a wide variety of mouthwatering pizzas, crafted with the freshest ingredients and a passion for perfection. Whether you're dining in, picking up, or having your meal delivered, Uncle Joe's Famous Pizzeria promises a delightful experience with every bite. Our extensive menu features classic favorites, gourmet specialties, and customizable options to suit every palate. In addition to our signature pizzas, we also offer a delicious selection of appetizers, salads, pastas, and desserts, ensuring there's something for everyone.

Welcome to Giovanni’s Pizzeria & Gelateria, your go-to destination for authentic Italian flavors in the heart of Patchogue, New York. Conveniently located at 522 East Main Street, our family-owned restaurant brings a taste of Italy to your neighborhood. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita pizza, a hearty pasta dish, or a refreshing scoop of gelato, Giovanni's offers a delightful culinary experience for everyone. At Giovanni’s, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft our mouth-watering pizzas and artisanal gelato. Our menu is a celebration of traditional Italian recipes, infused with a modern twist to cater to every palate. Dine in with us to enjoy a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for family gatherings, date nights, or catching up with friends.

Welcome to Alvarez Pizza - A Taste of Tradition in Patchogue! Nestled in the heart of Patchogue at 8 West 1st Street, Alvarez Pizza is your go-to destination for authentic, mouth-watering pizzas and a delightful array of Italian dishes. As a beloved local staple, we pride ourselves on serving the freshest ingredients and classic recipes that have made us a favorite among residents and visitors alike.

Welcome to Italiano Pizza & Food Co., your go-to destination for authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Patchogue, New York. Nestled at 75 East Main Street, our restaurant offers a delightful culinary experience that has everyone talking. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a leisurely dinner, we promise you'll leave satisfied. Indulge in our must-try dishes that have become local favorites. From our signature two-piece Chopmeat with garlic knots and fried onion drizzled in our secret sauce, to our 18-inch pizza topped with bleu cheese dressing, fried chicken, mozzarella, and buffalo sauce, each bite is a testament to our commitment to quality and flavor.

Welcome to Donatina Neapolitan Pizza Cafe, where we serve Long Island's best pizza, as recognized by Newsday from 2019 to 2023. Nestled in the heart of Patchogue at 18 West Avenue, our cafe is a haven for pizza lovers seeking an unforgettable dining experience. At Donatina, we take pride in crafting pizzas with a thick, airy base and a crunchy, crispy cheese crust, cooked to perfection in a steel pan. Our unique secret cheese blend complements a tomato sauce with just the right amount of kick, delivering a burst of flavor in every bite.

Welcome to Mary's Pizza and Pasta, your go-to destination for delicious Italian cuisine in Islip Terrace, New York. Conveniently located at 876 Connetquot Avenue, our family-owned restaurant offers a warm and inviting atmosphere where you can enjoy a wide variety of freshly made pizzas, pastas, and other Italian specialties. Whether you're dining in, ordering for takeout, or opting for our convenient meal delivery service, we are committed to providing you with a memorable dining experience. At Mary's Pizza and Pasta, we pride ourselves on using only the finest ingredients to create mouthwatering dishes that capture the authentic flavors of Italy. Our menu features a diverse selection of options, ensuring there's something for everyone to enjoy.

Welcome to KC's Pizza and Wings, your go-to destination for delicious dining in Islip Terrace! Located conveniently at 871 Connetquot Avenue, our restaurant is a local favorite known for serving up mouth-watering pizzas and irresistible wings in a warm and friendly atmosphere. At KC's Pizza and Wings, we pride ourselves on using only the freshest ingredients to craft our signature dishes. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita pizza, a spicy buffalo wing, or one of our unique specialty pizzas, our menu offers something for everyone. We also provide a variety of sides, salads, and beverages to complement your meal.

Welcome to Pizza Roma, your go-to destination for delicious and authentic Italian flavors in Deer Park, New York! Conveniently located at 786 Grand Boulevard, we specialize in bringing the taste of Italy right to your doorstep with our exceptional meal delivery service. At Pizza Roma, we take pride in crafting mouthwatering pizzas, pastas, and a variety of Italian specialties using only the freshest ingredients. Our menu offers a wide selection of classic and gourmet pizzas, each made with our signature hand-tossed dough, rich tomato sauce, and premium toppings. Whether you're in the mood for a classic Margherita, a savory Pepperoni, or something more adventurous, we have something to satisfy every craving.

Welcome to Furcis Pizza Inc, your go-to destination for mouthwatering pizzas and authentic Italian cuisine in Bayport, New York. Conveniently located at 271 Snedecor Avenue, our family-owned restaurant is dedicated to serving the local community with delicious food made from the freshest ingredients. At Furcis Pizza Inc, we pride ourselves on our extensive menu that features a wide variety of classic and specialty pizzas, each crafted with our signature dough, zesty tomato sauce, and premium toppings. Whether you're a fan of traditional Margherita or adventurous gourmet flavors, we have something to satisfy every palate.

Welcome to The Pizzeria of Bayport, your go-to destination for authentic and delicious pizza in the heart of Bayport, New York. Located at 606 Montauk Highway, our family-owned and operated restaurant proudly serves the Bayport community and beyond with a mouthwatering selection of classic and gourmet pizzas, made from the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes. At The Pizzeria of Bayport, we believe in creating memorable dining experiences with every slice. Our menu features a wide variety of options, from traditional favorites like Margherita and Pepperoni to unique creations that cater to all taste buds. In addition to our signature pizzas, we offer a range of appetizers, salads, pasta dishes, and desserts to complement your meal.

Welcome to Stella Trattoria & Bar, your premier destination for exquisite dining and vibrant nightlife in the heart of Blue Point, New York. Located at 7 Montauk Highway, our establishment seamlessly combines the charm of a traditional trattoria with the energy of a modern bar, offering a unique and inviting atmosphere for all occasions. At Stella Trattoria & Bar, we pride ourselves on delivering a culinary experience that celebrates the rich flavors of Italian cuisine. Our menu is thoughtfully curated with a diverse selection of authentic dishes, crafted from the freshest ingredients and inspired by time-honored recipes. Whether you're indulging in our handmade pastas, savoring our perfectly grilled meats, or enjoying a fresh seafood dish, each bite promises a taste of Italy.

Welcome to Gio's Pizza, your go-to destination for delicious Italian cuisine in East Islip, New York. Conveniently located at 213 Carleton Avenue, we offer a delightful dining experience that combines the warmth of a neighborhood restaurant with the convenience of meal delivery. Our menu features a wide array of mouth-watering pizzas, pastas, and classic Italian dishes, all crafted with the freshest ingredients and authentic recipes. Whether you're joining us for a family meal, a casual dinner with friends, or ordering in for a cozy night at home, Gio's Pizza is committed to providing exceptional food and service. Experience the taste of Italy right here in East Islip – dine in, take out, or have your favorite meals delivered straight to your door. Visit us today and savor the flavors that have made Gio's Pizza a beloved local favorite!

Welcome to Bono's Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic Italian cuisine in the heart of Bay Shore, New York. Conveniently located at 1397 Brentwood Road, our family-owned restaurant has been serving the community with passion and dedication. At Bono's Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients to craft our mouth-watering pizzas, pastas, and classic Italian dishes. Whether you're in the mood for a traditional Margherita pizza, a hearty lasagna, or a fresh salad, our diverse menu offers something for everyone.