Mary's Pizza and Pasta 876 Connetquot Avenue, Islip Terrace, NY 11752

"I’ve had Mary’s in Islip Terrace more than a few times as my close friends live in the area. Always wonderful. The day I found out about my father’s death I was on my way there to get a slice. I was visibly out of it looking distressed. They made sure I ate had a glass of wine and were supportive just checking to see if I was ok. That’s a good group of people and a fine establishment. I can’t thank them enough for that humanity it restored my faith in people. Great food always!"

"I drive past 10 pizzerias to go here. We live in Bayport, but this pizza is so good. It’s worth a trip. Just waiting for Dave Portnoy to review it. He is a fake Dave Portnoy review."

"We ordered several items including a grilled Chicken Panini. When I took the panini out of its tray, the lower section stuck to the tray's bottom. I looked down and thought I was looking at -extra bread-as the color was similar to bread-until I grabbed it and realized it was the chicken-uon the bottom of the actual bread. As you can see, it doesn't look like grilled chicken-and upon closer inspection it doesn't even look like cooked chicken. Regardless, I ate half....Now, in the past months I seem to have developed a sensitivity to not-well-cooked-chicken and have vomited and "past" -via my bowles- such chicken twice in the last two months. In the middle of the night-after eating this chicken I was forced from my bed and had to RUN to the bathroom as I was about to vomit-this chicken....I wrote the business and I'm writing this review for two reasons, 1, they served uncooked food and 2, they didn't have the decency or respect to respond to me. So now they've lost customers."

"While in Islip looking for to go pizza slices, I came across this place on Google. I am a pizza snub and really like NY style. This place was on the higher side of my expectation outside of the city."

"Let me start off by saying that the food still taste the same. Marys is my go to place in long island for many years now. Over the past 2 years or so the prices have increased. However we never wavered because the quality and portions did not change. The quality has been definately downgraded, within the last few orders. the pizza is now more of a thin crust pizza and it no longet comes with the special crust that they would use. They use to give you a 5 topping price but now your charged per topping and served an inferior pizza . The pizza was half pepperoni and sausauge and half ham and mushroom all with extra cheese. All of the toppings seemed to be chopped smaller or something like that, like mini toppings . 40 dollars. The side portions were still 8 dollars but also noticibly difference in the usual portions. Again what i ordered still tasted good. Just downgraded from what Marys was well known for."