Florida's best restaurants in Tavernier, Florida

Old Tavernier Restaurant & Lounge, located at 90311 Old Highway in Tavernier, Florida, is a beloved institution in the Upper Keys since its opening in 1988. Offering a warm and inviting atmosphere, locals and tourists alike flock to Old Tavernier for its fresh seafood, prime steaks, chicken, lamb, homemade Italian and Greek cuisine, and delicious pizza in the bar. Everything on the menu, from the bread to the desserts, is made with care and attention to detail, including the extra-virgin olive oil sourced from the family's own olive groves in Southern Greece. Generations of patrons have made memories at Old Tavernier, with some who were toddlers when the restaurant first opened now returning with their own children. The restaurant has even become a sentimental spot for some, with one patron expressing a desire to have their ashes scattered there.

Located in Tavernier, Florida, Capt Craig's Restaurant is a beloved Florida Keys destination specializing in seafood and sandwiches. Known for their famous Fish Sandwich, this restaurant offers a menu filled with fresh local grouper, yellow tail snapper, mahi-mahi, and other Florida Keys seafood specialties. With creative dinner options, fresh salads, a great wine selection, and the coldest draft beer around, Capt Craig's is a favorite among both tourists and locals. Whether you're passing through on your way to Key West or looking for a delicious meal, Capt Craig's Restaurant is a must-visit spot in the Florida Keys. They also offer catering services for special events.

Great Wall Chinese Restaurant is a top-notch dining establishment located at 91200 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This renowned restaurant specializes in serving up mouth-watering Chinese cuisine made with only the finest meats and freshest vegetables sourced from local farmers' markets. The expert chefs at Great Wall Chinese Restaurant cook all their dishes in pure vegetable oil to ensure the authentic flavors of Chinese cooking shine through. With an extensive menu featuring a wide range of traditional and modern dishes, there is something to please every palate. Diners also have the option to customize their entrees by requesting vegetarian-style or choosing from a selection of fresh meats. Come experience the delectable flavors of Chinese cuisine at Great Wall Chinese Restaurant today!

In-N-Out Keys is a charming institution located at 92200 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida, United States. This cozy establishment offers a unique and immersive experience for visitors looking to explore the beautiful Florida Keys. With a focus on providing exceptional service and delicious food, In-N-Out Keys is a must-visit destination for anyone looking to enjoy a taste of local cuisine and hospitality. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a relaxing meal with friends and family, In-N-Out Keys has something for everyone. Come and discover the magic of the Florida Keys at this hidden gem of a restaurant.

Florida Keys Food Tour is located at 152 Sioux Street in Tavernier, Florida, United States. Our original Islamorada tour combines gastronomy, culture, and history, taking you to local restaurants to taste island cuisine and learn about the Rayburns. Experience a fun happy hour stroll through a less touristy section of Islamorada, sampling unique tastes and cocktails while enjoying a beautiful Florida Keys sunset. Join a local guide on a golf cart ride through paradise for a fabulous food tour, discovering keys cuisine, culture, art, and history. Purchase a gift card for a memorable experience. Our founder, Sheryl, grew up in Islamorada and designed the tour to showcase the major influences of Florida Keys cuisine. With evening happy hour tours added, our goal is to provide a fun-filled experience and enlighten you to what "Keys people" are all about. Book now to enjoy delicious food, drinks, and local history on our tours!

KRUST pizza & pies is a charming bakery, food, restaurant, and store located at 91865 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. Known for its delicious and freshly made pizzas and pies, this institution offers a wide variety of mouthwatering options to satisfy any craving. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, KRUST is the perfect spot to enjoy a tasty meal with friends and family. Stop by and indulge in their delectable creations today!

HAM Seafood Express is a bustling food establishment located at 103 Sunshine Boulevard in Tavernier, Florida. This unique institution offers a variety of fresh and delicious seafood options, including shrimp, crab, lobster, and more. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or fresh seafood to take home, HAM Seafood Express has you covered. With friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere, this restaurant and store is a must-visit for seafood lovers in the area.

Calypso's is a charming restaurant located at 91940 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This cozy eatery offers a delightful dining experience with a menu that showcases a fusion of Caribbean and American cuisine. The vibrant decor and laid-back atmosphere make Calypso's the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or a romantic dinner for two. Whether you're craving fresh seafood, juicy burgers, or flavorful tropical cocktails, Calypso's has something to satisfy every palate. Come indulge in a taste of the islands at Calypso's in Tavernier, Florida.

Italian Food Company Express is a food institution located at 92330 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida, United States. We specialize in authentic Italian cuisine, with a focus on regional Neapolitan and Roman pizzas, pasta dishes, delicious entrees, appetizers, desserts, and more. Our Key Largo and Islamorada locations offer unique and beautiful settings that transport you to Italy in the Florida Keys. Whether you're looking to host a wedding rehearsal, anniversary, birthday, or milestone celebration, our restaurant is the perfect venue. Auguri! In addition to our dining options, we also offer a pantry full of kitchen essentials to elevate your own recipes at home. Come visit Italian Food Company Express for a taste of Italy in the heart of Florida.

Harbor Cafe 90 is a charming bakery, cafe, and restaurant located at 90311 Old Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This cozy establishment offers a wide range of delicious food and beverages, from freshly baked pastries to gourmet sandwiches and salads. With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, Harbor Cafe 90 is the perfect spot to relax and enjoy a meal with friends or family. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a leisurely dining experience, this quaint cafe has something for everyone. Additionally, Harbor Cafe 90 also features a small store where you can purchase specialty items and gifts to take home with you. Come visit Harbor Cafe 90 for a delightful dining experience in the heart of Tavernier.

Atlantic Bay Resort is a charming lodging institution located in Tavernier, Florida, right on the beautiful Sterling Road. This cozy resort offers guests a peaceful and relaxing getaway with stunning views of the Atlantic Bay. With comfortable accommodations and top-notch amenities, Atlantic Bay Resort is the perfect destination for those looking to unwind and enjoy all that the Florida Keys have to offer. Whether you're looking to relax by the pool, explore the nearby attractions, or simply soak in the sun on the beach, Atlantic Bay Resort has something for everyone. Book your stay today and experience the tranquility of this hidden gem in Tavernier.

What The Fish? Rolls & More is a popular restaurant located at 90775 Old Highway in Tavernier, Florida. Specializing in delicious seafood rolls and other mouthwatering dishes, this institution is a must-visit for seafood lovers in the area. With a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, What The Fish? Rolls & More offers a diverse menu filled with fresh and flavorful options that will satisfy any craving. Whether you're in the mood for a classic lobster roll or want to try something new like their signature fish tacos, this restaurant is sure to leave you coming back for more. Don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in some of the best seafood in town at What The Fish? Rolls & More.

Habanos On The Creek is a hidden gem located at 90800 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This charming restaurant offers great and affordable food, with lunch specials that are a favorite among customers. The portions are generous, the prices are reasonable, and the view is lovely. The service at Habanos On The Creek is top-notch, with customers raving about the quality of the food. Visitors have even brought their own catch of the day, only to have it expertly battered and fried by the talented chefs. The restaurant may be small and hard to find, but once discovered, it becomes a favorite spot to visit time and time again.

Café Moka is a charming bakery, cafe, and restaurant located at 91731 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This cozy establishment offers a wide variety of freshly baked goods, delicious breakfast and lunch options, and a selection of gourmet coffee and teas. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat or a leisurely meal with friends, Café Moka provides a welcoming atmosphere and top-notch service. Stop by to enjoy a tasty treat or pick up some freshly baked goods to take home.

Mom And Daughter Juice Bar is a charming and cozy food establishment located at 91200 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This family-run juice bar offers a variety of fresh and healthy juices, smoothies, and light bites that are perfect for a quick and nutritious meal on the go. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Mom And Daughter Juice Bar is the perfect spot to enjoy a refreshing beverage with your loved ones. Come visit us and taste the love and care that goes into every drink we make!

Gardenia's Bistro is a charming and inviting establishment located at 88720 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This versatile institution offers a variety of services including a bar, cafe, restaurant, and store all under one roof. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Gardenia's Bistro is the perfect spot to enjoy delicious food, refreshing drinks, and a relaxing dining experience. Whether you're looking for a quick bite to eat, a place to unwind with friends, or a unique shopping experience, Gardenia's Bistro has something for everyone. Come visit us today and see why we are a favorite destination for locals and visitors alike.

The Mar Bar is a lively and popular bar located at 90775 Old Highway in Tavernier, Florida. Known for its great atmosphere, friendly staff, and delicious drinks, The Mar Bar is a favorite spot for locals and tourists alike. Whether you're looking to enjoy a cold beer with friends, catch a game on the big screen, or dance the night away to live music, The Mar Bar has something for everyone. Come on down and experience the fun and excitement of this must-visit bar in the beautiful Florida Keys.

J-DAO Sushi Thai is a vibrant and inviting restaurant located at 91260 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. Specializing in a fusion of Japanese and Thai cuisine, this establishment offers a unique dining experience that combines the best of both worlds. From fresh and expertly prepared sushi rolls to flavorful Thai dishes, J-DAO Sushi Thai caters to a wide range of tastes and preferences. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, this restaurant is the perfect spot for a casual meal or a special celebration. Come visit J-DAO Sushi Thai and indulge in a delicious culinary journey that will leave you coming back for more.

City Hall Cafe & Wine Bar is a charming establishment located on the scenic Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This versatile venue offers a range of amenities including a cozy cafe, a well-stocked liquor store, a delicious restaurant, and a convenient meal delivery service. Whether you're looking to enjoy a relaxing cup of coffee, indulge in a gourmet meal, or savor a glass of fine wine, City Hall Cafe & Wine Bar has something for everyone. Come visit us at 88511 Overseas Highway and experience the perfect blend of food, drinks, and hospitality.

Payfair Supermarket is a one-stop shop for all your food and grocery needs in Tavernier, Florida. Located at 90164 Overseas Highway, this spacious and well-stocked store offers a wide variety of fresh produce, meats, dairy products, pantry staples, and more. With friendly staff and competitive prices, Payfair Supermarket is the go-to destination for locals and visitors alike looking to stock up on essentials or grab a quick bite to eat. Whether you're looking for a quick snack or ingredients for a gourmet meal, Payfair Supermarket has you covered.

Dillon's Pub & Grill is a cozy and inviting establishment located in Tavernier, Florida. Situated at 91200 Overseas Highway, this popular bar and restaurant offers a warm and friendly atmosphere for locals and visitors alike. With a diverse menu featuring delicious pub fare and grilled specialties, Dillon's is the perfect spot to enjoy a casual meal or drinks with friends. Whether you're looking for a hearty burger, fresh seafood, or a refreshing cocktail, Dillon's Pub & Grill has something for everyone. Come and experience the laid-back charm of this neighborhood gem in the heart of the Florida Keys.

Made 2 Order is a cozy cafe and restaurant located at Mile Marker 90.6 in Tavernier, Florida. We are open daily from 8:00am to 3:00pm, serving breakfast all day in a waterfront dining setting or air-conditioned comfort. We offer delivery services and accept all major credit cards for your convenience. Come visit us at 90691 Old Highway or call 305-852-3251 for more information. Enjoy delicious made-to-order meals in a beautiful location at Made 2 Order!

Over Easy is a charming and cozy restaurant located at 91200 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. Specializing in delicious breakfast and brunch dishes, Over Easy offers a wide variety of options to satisfy any craving. From fluffy pancakes and crispy bacon to fresh omelettes and decadent French toast, there is something for everyone to enjoy at this popular eatery. With a welcoming atmosphere and friendly staff, Over Easy is the perfect spot to start your day off right. Come visit us and experience the mouthwatering flavors that have made us a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Mangrove Marina in Tavernier, Florida Keys is a hidden gem tucked away from the hustle and bustle of city life. Situated on twenty acres of waterfront tranquility, this marina is protected by mangrove trees and serves as a natural "hurricane hole". As the largest full service marina in the upper keys, Mangrove Marina offers wet slips, dry racks, boat ramp, fuel facilities, bathhouse, ships store, mechanic racks, working yard, restaurant, and a freshwater swimming pool. Whether you're a fishing enthusiast, liveaboard boater, or looking to try houseboat lodging, Mangrove Marina has something for everyone. Come visit us at 200 Florida Avenue in Tavernier, Florida and experience a little bit of paradise.

Enrico's Pizza, located at 20 High Point Road in Tavernier, Florida, is a renowned pizza restaurant known for its authentic New York Style pizzas. Founded by Enrico Michael Calvano, a master of the art of pizza making, and his wife, the restaurant has been serving delicious pizzas since the early '60s. Enrico's legacy lives on through his family, who continue to uphold his standards of pride, passion, and quality in every pizza they make. At Enrico's, you can enjoy a variety of mouthwatering pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, and more, all made with the finest and freshest ingredients. With a combined family experience of over 100 years, you can trust that you're getting a true taste of Italy with every bite.

Sunrise Cuban Market & Cafe is a charming institution located at 91885 Overseas Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This establishment is a combination of a food market, grocery store, restaurant, and supermarket, offering a unique blend of Cuban cuisine and products. You can find a variety of traditional Cuban dishes such as Tortilla Española, Tortilla del Oeste, and Tortilla Vasca, all served with Cuban toast and your choice of hash browns or french fries. Other menu items include pancakes with bacon, ham, sausage, or eggs, as well as sandwiches with eggs, cheese, ham, bacon, or sausage. All dinner options come with your choice of two sides, including white rice, black beans, yuca, sweet plantains, or Moro. Additionally, Sunrise Cuban Market & Cafe offers party-sized portions of their authentic Cuban dishes. Whether you're craving a delicious meal or looking to stock up on Cuban groceries, this institution has you covered. Visit us or call (305) 852-7216 to experience the taste of Cuba right here in Tavernier.

Dairy Queen in Tavernier, Florida is a beloved food institution located at 1 Overseas Highway. Known for its delicious soft-serve ice cream, burgers, and other fast food offerings, Dairy Queen is a popular spot for locals and tourists alike. Whether you're craving a classic DQ Blizzard or a savory burger, this restaurant and store has something for everyone. With its friendly service and convenient location, Dairy Queen is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings while enjoying the sunny Florida weather.

The Friday Farmers Market is a seasonal institution located at 90055 Old Highway in Tavernier, Florida. This market offers a variety of fresh produce, locally sourced goods, and delicious foods from local vendors. Visitors can enjoy a wide selection of fruits, vegetables, baked goods, and more while supporting small businesses in the community. The market is a popular destination for food enthusiasts and those looking to experience the vibrant culinary scene of Tavernier. Whether you're looking for a quick snack or a full meal, the Friday Farmers Market has something for everyone to enjoy.

Ohana Sweet Shoppe is a charming food establishment located at 90451 Old Highway in Tavernier, Florida, USA. This delightful restaurant is a haven for those with a sweet tooth, offering a wide variety of delectable treats and desserts. From freshly baked pastries to decadent cakes and cookies, Ohana Sweet Shoppe is the perfect place to satisfy your cravings for something sweet. Whether you're looking for a quick snack or a special dessert for a celebration, this cozy shop has something for everyone. Come visit Ohana Sweet Shoppe and indulge in a delicious treat today!

Domino's Pizza in Tavernier, Florida is a popular food institution known for its delicious pizzas and fast delivery service. Located at 91200 Overseas Highway, this restaurant offers a wide variety of toppings and crust options to satisfy every pizza lover's cravings. Whether you prefer to dine in, take your meal to go, or have it delivered right to your doorstep, Domino's Pizza is the perfect choice for a quick and tasty meal. With a convenient location and a reputation for quality and convenience, Domino's Pizza is a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.