Enrico’s Pizza

"Have been waiting for almost 2 hours. Delivery still not here. Only ordered a pizza and 2 apps. Don't waste your time if you're hungry. After 2 hours order arrived, cold as I expected. Pizza was under cooked and dough stuck to paper in box. Soft and gooey just like they advertise... Not."

"We're surprised there are so many positive reviews because our experience at Enrico's Pizza last weekend was terrible. Our pizza was not good. The crust was undercooked, the amount of sausage was miniscule, a glass of red wine had less than 2 ounces for $7. We've never been served such a tiny amount of wine anywhere. (The attached photo makes it look larger than it actually was.) When we asked about having one pizza with veggie on one side and sausage on the other, we were told it was no problem, but NOT told that we'd be charge a ridiculous amount extra. If there had been a noticeable amount of sausage and the crust was not doughy, we would not have minded as much. Also, I am from New York and the claim they have NY style is way off. The waitress was kind and very apologetic, but the manager was not willing to be flexible. Never going there again."

"Popular place we are told. Good pizza. Okay flavor, definitely had better. Took awhile to get our food and last dish didn't come out until after the rest of us finished. And we had to ask if our food was ready, so it was no longer hot when we got it. We were the only customers there. Very casual atmosphere. Update: enjoyed the key lime pie. I'm on a quest to find the best one. The one is the only one with a unique crust with pecan. It is drizzled with carmel. The lime is nice and tart. I think the carmel adds a nice balance but could cut the amount in half so it's not so sweet altogether. The texture is a smooth and heavy. Portion size is a 1/4 pie so it's good for two but I ate the whole thing myself. At this point it's my favorite in the Keys."

"Living in Islamorada, we are so fortunate to have Enricos for our Pizza and Wings nights! We stopped by yesterday to pick up our kids dinner and it was perfect as always. Fast and easy and a great location for anyone living or visiting the keys! Menu has so many options and easy online ordering aswell"

"I have always passed Enrico's heading in and out of the Keys. I decided to finally stop with 10 hungry teenagers and so happy I did! Not only was the food great, the service was great also. Very friendly and very welcoming. The indoor decor is super cool with photos and memorabilia of the Bronx and the movie Rocky. We ordered a wide variety of food. Pasta, pizza, subs, salad and everything was delish! Definitely going back!"