Torte Jeff Pie Co. & Bakery 218 East Main Street, Port Jefferson, NY 11777

"Everything is so good !! I’ve been ordering their surprise bags , and I’ve gotten so many lovely things. The strawberry cake with icing was amazing and I just tried this corn muffin stuff with blueberry filing. Eveything seems to be made from scratch , it’s the best blueberry muffin I’ve ever had !!"

"I stopped here on my visit of Port Jefferson on May 24. I was picking up a custom 4 inch buttercream cake I had ordered. When I got there, I saw so many gorgeous looking pastries I just had to get more. I ended up getting a linzer tart, rainbow cookie, and crookie. Not pictured because they were so good I ate them immediately. I also got a Blueberry Pie, Chocolate Creme Pie, and Apple Galette. The Blueberry Pie and Apple Galette were filled with real fresh fruit, and massive. Her fruit pies are truly the best on the island. The chocolate creme pie I put back in my freezer and it was like 100 times better than those Burger King Hershey Pie’s. As for the custom 4 inch cake, the owner truly went above and beyond. My only directions were “4 inch chocolate buttercream”, but she decorated it gorgeously. It was also a lot larger than I expected. I was very pleasantly surprised. I was gonna eat the whole cake, but ended up sharing that one with my family as well. They usually don’t eat the chocolate cakes I bring, but they loved this one. I have to say, it was the most rich and fluffy chocolate cake I’ve ever had. The combination of different types of chocolate blended together very well. I will be coming here for all my future occasions. Everything they make is delicious."

"Took a tour of Port Jefferson yesterday, May 2. My first stop was this quaint little bakery. The cases were lined with a selection of colorful and enticing pastries of all kinds. I had my heart set on an apple pie since before I came in though. I was astonished to be given the most beautiful, massive fresh apple pie I had ever seen. This 9 inch pie had real weight to it; my arm was getting tired carrying it back to my car. When I got home and cut into it, I could see all the individual slices of apples, very large ones at that. It was the best apple pie I’ve ever had. I had stopped by Port Jeff last week as well and the owner had a collection of cute soaps in her shop as well as many other interesting gifts. That time I got a small chocolate cake type pastry. It was also truly delicious. Will be back for sure."

"Stopped in here on a whim last week and was surprised by how cute it was inside. It was my moms birthday, so I thought I’d bring her some extra sweets since everything looked good. I got 2 cupcakes, which were huge, and 2 slices of strawberry shortcake. Both of which looked lovely. I was blown away by the affordability, it was only $18 for all my items, bakeries near me would charge $30 at least. The quality for the price is amazing! Everything was really good and I will definitely come back in the future! Highly recommend!"

"So walking around in Port Jeff this morning looking for a store my daughter heard about we decided to stop in and check out Torte Jeff Pie Co. Again. When we walked in we were immediately greeted by a lovely young lady named Keri. We found out later that she is actually the baker. Each wanted something sweet and I knew I had to get some of the banana pudding to take home. Keri not only took her time to explain what each item in the case was but gave us recommendations based upon what we told her we like. She was spot on. This store is an eclectic collection of so many different items. Every time I looked on a shelf I found something else I wanted to try. We picked up three donuts, an order of cinnamon buns and a few other little things. The kids tore into the donuts before I could get some pictures so I apologize. Please excuse my half-eating donuts and children's faces. My something sweet was the banana pudding. The banana pudding is one of my favorite desserts no matter where it is but the one made here is out of this world great. If you are a fan of banana pudding definitely check out the one from here."