Gus's New York Pizza,

7425 W Peoria Ave #100, Peoria, AZ 85345, United States

"First and last time from this place. The 3rd star is solely for the chick behind the counter doing her best by herself, who was friendly despite being out of a dozen plus ingredients (there's a list on the white board behind the counter). Both pizzas were missing ingredients and the outer crust was spicy which, in a wing place, smacks of cross contamination. Grease on the mushrooms tasted old. Sad because I love a local pizza place but there's just too many issues."

"Placed order online, was given 3 texts with time and updates. Went to pick up food within time frame given. Once there it took a few minutes for a worker to say anything to me while standing at counter. There is no bell or anything to get the workers in the backs attention. Once I finally talked to a worker she told me that the order was barley received and needs to be made! It took another 15 minutes for my order to be ready. So in total my order took an extra 30 minutes. Very disappointed and irritated in this encounter. If the time was going to be extended I can understand but I was told prior to driving there my order would be ready. Unfortunately will not be going back. Food was good but service and time wasted was not worth it."

"Purchased a pizza, taste was decent but when a couple slices turned over accidentally I saw what looked like a burn mark on the crust, but something about it didn't look right, I took a closer look and it was fuzzy mold starting to grow on the crust. From the prior reviews something ain't right about this place. Surprised it hasn't been shut down."

"Ordered the Medium pizza and 6 wing special. Melissa is apparently the new manager and she killed it. She awesome!! Great service and good food. Labor costs have made it very hard to run a restaurant these days so until the volume is higher I think they be slower on service and orders but they are focusing on consistency and quality."

"I ordered pizza and wings at your location on 75th Ave and Peoria. The wings we raw as seen in the photo and the pizza was gross. The sausage was not cooked well and taste old and moldy. I wouldn't recommend this place at all. I contacted the place and was not able to speak to the manager. Was told by the young lady that answered the phone that they could replace my order. If you gave me raw and moldy food, why would I want you to replace my order. I will never order from this place again."