#1 Brothers Pizza

"We've visited the Peoria location for their lunch special a few times over the past year. We've also gone with friends for dinner a couple of times. The lunch special is an awesome deal! The pizza and calzones are great. We've had good service every time - friendly staff! The times we've gone, there hasn't been a wait, there is plenty of seating available in the dining room, and the food is ready and on the table fairly fast. We sit outside on the side patio when the weather is perfect. The tables have umbrellas, and since there isn't a lot of parking lot traffic, it's a nice spot to enjoy our meal. The restaurant is always very clean."

"Great customer service! Pizza was delicious! Tried garlic knots and they were so good! Prices are very reasonable! Would definitely recommend! Can't wait to come back for more awesome pizza!! Great flavorful crust too!!"

"I was excited to try this place but I ended up be very disappointed. I ordered a small pepperoni and they had given me a medium instead so Immediately thought oh that was nice of them. I walked out and first noticed the box looked damaged and I was like oh I hope this wasn’t someone else’s pizza and they just gave it to me and that’s why they gave me a medium instead of the small I ordered. Well I got home to eat and took a bite and got a mouth full of flour so I looked at the pizza slices and noticed a majority of them had a ton of flour caked on the bottom and some on the top. I was going to immediately return it for a refund but now they are closed so I’m sure I won’t get a refund now. I was hoping to love this place but was bummed when I got a very disappointing pizza."

"Very disappointed with our experience on Halloween. We ordered 2 pizzas (gluten free and an 18 in) and both pizzas were overcooked. We couldn’t eat the crust on either pizza because it was either burnt or way too hard. We called the store within 10 minutes of our pizzas being delivered to express our disappointment with our order and we were told that the owner would call us. It’s several days later and we still haven’t received a call. We will be finding a new place to order pizza from next time."

"We read the reviews, but we wanted to check it out firsthand. Total disappointment and waste of money. I ordered over the phone for take out and the girl didn't even get my name. She seemed lost. Now to the food. The pizza was horrible it was like eating cardboard. Our 5 and 7 year old said it was the worst pizza they've had and didn't finish eating it. The flavor of the wings was on point, but the wings were tiny. We won't be eating #1 Brothers Pizza again."