Valued Stay Mayflower 2509 Perry Street, Madison, WI 53713

"Horrible place, overpriced room price, lack of climate control, bugs of all sorts in room, Internet never works, tested was 0.5mb/down, up was non-existent. Loud tweaker roommates pounding on walls and floors at all hours, playing their loud coked up music. Stay far away."

"You will never get any service if you put the sign "Do not disturb" in front of the door. They never stay at the front desk. They lock the front desk, so they never let you out. You cannot control the AC, also. But the room is clean and neat, and the beds are large enough. The breakfast is good."

"If you're checking out before 10am before the front desk opens, consider staying at a different place. I was traveling with a family member and we were going to spend one night in Madison, after which we part our ways. We were told that if we were checking out before 10am, which is when the front desk opens, to leave our key in the room and lock the door behind us. I had to leave early in the morning around 5am, and he around 6am. My family member who did the checkout process unfortunately left the key in the original keybox next to the check-in counter; still, the key should've been there. However, the property told us that they couldn't find the key and we were charged $50 for the lock replacement fee. That's understandable and I should've made sure he left the key in the room; however, it is upsetting that he did leave the key inside the keybox (and he did it with great effort bc he was not used to those types of key boxes) but the property couldn't find it. I do appreciate that the property gave me a call before the $50 charge. It gave me a chance to follow up with my family member about the key. The person I spoke with was also polite, and she was apologetic for the confusion and the missing key. Overall, it's a decent place with a decent price, but the fact that there's no one at the counter until 10am means that there's a possibility that the key might get lost between the time you checkout and the staff come to the office. I would only recommend here if you plan to checkout after 10am when the staff are here."

"Stay far away from here. It reminded me of something out of a horror movie. Felt very unsafe. I stayed in the summer, you have no control over the temperature in the room. A gentleman was outside his room bathing his cat in a bucket, true story. Thankfully I was leaving very early in the morning or I would of stayed elsewhere."

"Nice and affordable place to stay. Bed and pillows are comfortable. No bugs or old sheets were seen which is a plus! Walk in shower is small and not my favorite but it does what it’s supposed to do. Overall nice people in the front desk and are there to help if needed."