Stefanina's Pizzeria

"Carry out Chef salad and Tuesday Special a party size pizza for the price of a large. The carry out box was "packed" full and barely able to close. Loaded with ham, salami, boiled eggs, tomato, etc... Lettuce nice and crisp. This salad is huge, easily 4 meals for me. Sausage pizza had a good amount of sausage but, IMHO lacked sufficient cheese. Love the thin crust."

"Not a fan of the food. I had spinach feta pizza. It was a nice thin crust but otherwise not good in my opinion. We also had an appetizer that was not great. The salad that came with the lunch pizza was the best part of the meal. The service was great though and the atmosphere is nice and unique. It may be worth going once but try something other than the pizza. Maps may try to take you to the empty building next door."

"***UPDATE*** Now that you replied back, I have to respond. But people, make sure you look into the responses they give back on customer complaints. Almost all of them blame the customer in some way. Asking them if you had a problem, did you ask for a manager? Well, I guess when you don't get that fork you need or you received the wrong flavored soda, YOU HAVE TO MAKE THEM GET A MANAGER. And do that for every single thing that is wrong, otherwise it's on you buddy!!! Read them for yourselves. As far as your reply, my wife told you her name and number, AS I STATED. Because you can't fix that in your system when placing the order is on you. They should have seen the discrepancy and asked or changed it. Second, as for blaming us for not having a hot box or bag, it was placed in an empty cooler, in a warm car to keep it warm and we have never had any other pizzas we bought, getting cold as a problem. The only problems with any pizzas we have received are from restaurants that can't make a simple pizza the right way. And finally, yes we ordered extra cheese, as YOU AND I BOTH STATED, and if the people look at my pics of the pizzas that I received, and any other posts from other restaurants and customers, you would see the difference. Extra cheese should have almost completely covered the other ingredients. That would have kept it oily and moist enough from drying out, even when your cooks overcooked it this time. That is the only reason I get extra cheese on a thin pizza. But I guess your restaurant is so greedy in my opinion, they skimped on the cheese and it dried them both out. To all the people reading this, you work hard for your money and so do we. I didn't ask you for a refund or replacement pizzas. They are edible. I gave you 2 stars. If you look at my other reviews, I have good and bad reviews. I try to post pics of the food I received. I tell a complete story. But I personally would never blame the customer in my replys back to them from a complaint. Stefanina's said their pizza must not be my cup of tea. Well, I have eaten pizzas from NY to Chicago, from gourmet to a cheap chef boy r dee pizza out of a box before, and yours was worse than the box pizza. AND YES, THEN I WOULD AGREE WITH YOU, YOUR DRIED OUT OVERCOOKED PIZZA IS NOT MY CUP OF TEA, MA'AM, AS YOU STATED. People you should go spend your hard earned money somewhere else and not deal with such a let down and hassle just to get a couple pizza pies. ***ORIGINAL POST""" Stefanina's had a post today on their Facebook page of a beautiful "stefanina's special" pizza. And you could buy a large pizza and get it at a small pizza price. Never been there. It had great reviews. My wife ordered on phone on way there and talked to a very pleasant woman named Hannah. Took her order and helped her get what we wanted. Wife went in to pickup and couldn't find order. After a bit, even though she told her her name and number, she found it under our daughters name who ordered one 20 years plus ago. Wife brought it home immediately. It was overcooked and dried out. Not enough sauce or cheese and keeping it moist and hot. It was barely warm. I told wife it tastes like back when I was 13, now 55, and we would get those chef boy r dee's pizzas in a box and you would have to make it yourself. Then you overcook those and dry them out. Absolutely terrible taste. If this is what wentzville has as a gourmet pizza shop over fast food restaurants, god help this area. I would take Imos over this anyday. And to think, I didn't want her to drive an extra 15 miles to go to Pantera's and get a hunk because she has been working hard. Sorry honey that this didn't work out for us. I'll try and do better next time. Guys take your money and tastebuds somewhere else for your deserving wife."

"This is a family owned restaurant. The quality of their food was fresh and delicious. Staff were friendly and attentive."

"Everything was great with the service, drinks and the food! The service was fast, friendly, and attentive. The garlic pizza was really delicious. My hubby wasn’t too crazy about the spaghetti and meatballs but he’s a little picky when it comes to his favorite dish. They even had a decent bar to make your favorite adult beverage. A great place if you have a pizza craving!"