Tootie Pie Co. Boerne-Main Street 1445 South Main Street, Boerne, TX 78006

"After 10 years of shopping in TX, this was the rudest experience I’ve ever had. On 10/12/23 @ 4 pm I stopped in to pick up a couple 4” pies. The sales clerk was ridiculously rude. There were very few pies in the case. I asked her if she had any small pies in the back. She asked me what I meant by small, 4”, 8” or 12”? I said 4”. She began listing off what she had in the back. I asked if she had buttermilk. She said yes but we hold those back for the southern sampler. I then asked about the pie slices in the case and again met with rudeness. When I asked if a particular piece was coconut, she said NO, it’s cheesecake. Trying to make conversation, I said that I saw that Costco now sells a few of their pies online. She said that wasn’t her area that was Dripping Springs. No hello, how is your day, can I help you? I will never return to that store. It’s a shame because Tooties Pies are delicious. I guess instead of supporting a small local business, I’ll order my Tooties Pies online at Costco."

"I love this place. It was my first time going and I tried a few different pies and they all were delicious!!!"

"My cousins & I decided on a week long trip to Texas starting in San Antonio & ending our tour in Houston. Tootie Pie was a random last minute decision as we drove by & we were so happy we did. We sampled so many pies, & ate off them for the next 3 days. They are made fresh & then flash frozen to keep the taste & flavor living in our minds & bellies even longer. First off, the owners, two Brothers Mike & Brian we’re just just sweet souls. So forthcoming, honest, and real. We really appreciated getting to know them & learning about the history behind the place & the way the pies are made. For us, though, despite the friendly service, the buttermilk pie was the true star. I’m talking crème brûlée meets a basque cheesecake & has a baby star worthy! It was sooo amazing. We brought extra pieces to gift to friends we were to visit along the way & they loved it just as much as we did! The pecan, coconut, pumpkin & chocolate pie were all magnificent. Just know that in our total of 5 days on this trip, we still dreamed of this buttermilk pie. Do yourself a favor, & try it!!! Only negative, they need to be on every corner of Texas!"