Plato's Closet - Green Bay

"all of the staff is always very friendly! i go to platos often and i always feel welcomed. the manager paightn always goes above and beyond!"

"Always a great experience walking into this store. The girls are always friendly right when you walk in the door, they always have a upbeat personality which makes the shopping experience ten times better. Some of the items can be a little pricey but I always leave with a bunch of cute finds!"

"It was my first time trying to sell clothes at a Plato’s Closet, and it wasn’t a great experience. First off, it was not mentioned anywhere on the website that clothes could not be bagged and had to be in a hard container. So drove half an hour to the store and ended up having to go to Dollar Tree to buy a basket before coming back. I then waited 45 minutes, only to find that they would only take 5 items of the clothing in my big basket - for a little under $10. I do understand that you only get a percentage of the value of the item, but this still felt low to me for the quality and quantity of the clothing that they did accept. I was told that the rest of my clothes were outside of the 2 year style range, however, all of the clothing I had brought was purchased within the last year and included name brand items. I also noticed that while browsing the selection in the store that a lot of the items in there were very similar in style to what I had brought in - with many of the items definitely being even older in style than what I brought in. I ended up just donating my entire basket of clothes to St. Vincent de Paul. I only gave two stars because the girls in the store were very nice, and I understand they are just enforcing policy and the employees don’t make the rules. Still very frustrating though, and I am definitely curious on what this company define as “in-style” because I like to keep up with fashion trends and there was plenty in the store that was not “trendy.”"

"Buying policy has changed so much over the years… they take little to nothing when EVERYTHING I was selling was purchased from PC in the first place- rather ironic. I understand they have to be picky, but it’s gotten a little pathetic. The selection has really gone down hill as well. I have given up trying to sell after seeing multiple things from the early 2000s/2010s— including a (very worn and dirty) men’s pair of Nikes from 2008? Yet my clothes I purchased this year from them (!!) are “too old.” I think if their buying team gets on the same page as one another, customers may have less polarizing opinions about their buying process. Personally I would rather give to the homeless shelter than waste my time with their hypocrisy."

"Good selection of name brand clothes and shoes. The staff are also very nice. My only problem with plato's Closet is their selling process. The couple of times I have brought clothes into them they have bought so little of my clothes it's insane. I understand that they need to be picky but it is insane how little they will take. Other than that whenever I go there to buy it is always a good experience."