Francesco's of Farmingdale

"Just picked up 2 pies from Francesco's, Grandma Vodka Sicilian style & buffalo chicken Sicilian both pies where excellent. Anthony the owner & his staff are always super friendly. Anthony always does right with his customers & I'm very greatful. I definitely recommend my friends & family at Francesco's."

"Dropped in to have a regular slice. The woman behind the counter was super nice so I am giving them 4 stars in service but their pizza was extremely bland if not bad. I don’t think I have ever tasted a slice of pizza where the crust literally tasted like nothing at all. The cheese was super bright orange/oily although did taste ok so that was weird but the sauce and the crust had no taste whatsoever."

"Tried for the first and will not go back. The large pizza had very little sauce, the cheese was minimal and the crust was tough to eat. It was not a great pizza pie. I was hoping it would be moist as a result of the cheese and sauce but it was very dry."

"I really want to like this place because we support local businesses in our town. Unfortunately, the past three orders were messed up. From not bringing sodas or dressings that were ordered on the side, to a pizza ordered with half pepperoni and half sausage only to get pepperoni and sausage on one side and plain the other to finally today where we placed an order online and when we called up an hour later to see where our order is they told us it was marked as a pickup when we didn’t order it as a pick up and already included a tip with our order. I don’t know how many more chances we are going to give them. Very frustrating."

"The owner seems very nice and the food is good. It really seemed like a “when life gives you lemons” experience. They are currently running different promotions since they’re new. Unfortunately, their online ordering system doesn’t take into account the business during the promos, but the owner and staff were courteous and generous. They turned what could’ve been a disaster into a positive experience."