La Piazza Westbury

"Mama Theresa's never disappoints! I particularly love this location. The staff is always so upbeat and friendly. How could you not love them? When I'm in town I have to stop by and get a grilled chicken caesar salad for my elderly father, and a Buffalo slice for me ( I had my first Buffalo slice ever from Mama Theresa's, and I haven't found anyone else who makes it like them). I always wanted to try a grandma slice, and since it looks just like a Sicilian slice to me I had a few questions that they had no issues answering for me. Whenever we order pizza for takeout, my parents always insist on getting it from here. I love this location, and I, of course, will be back next week for my dad's usual."

"absolutely the worst food and service today! I didn’t even want to complain because I could tell no one there actually cared! I have been a customer for over 30 years. When I’m paying $60 for two chicken dishes I expect service! The waiter threw the food at us, did not clear the table well between courses left dirty plates and extra silverware all over the place. When entrées came, he walked away quickly and never came back to ask how the food was. The two chicken dishes were barely warm and we could tell they had been sitting there for a while before they were brought to us. but we were so hungry we didn’t say anything and should have. The guys in the kitchen were singing, and were incredibly loud totally disturbing us in the dining room. And the staff were so busy doing side work they weren’t paying attention to anybody who was dining. Also making a ton of noise in the dining room thrashing silverware around totally unprofessional. I won’t be coming back anytime soon to this location. I went in there to enjoy a nice lunch with my mother and left completely annoyed."

"Guaranteed to enjoy your meal at Mama T's! Whether here or in East Meadow, you will not be disappointed. Very nice atmosphere, clean and neatly decorated a step above your typical pizzeria. This trip was just a couple slices, regular and Sicilian, both were cooked perfect... Excellent! Their entrees are all delicious as well. A must try. lmk what you think?"

"Came here for dinner with the family and everything was great. The service was exceptional. The staff treats their customers right and are very attentive. When they see you run out of complimentary bread they bring some more out. I got the buffalo pizzeta which is a "personal pizza"- and the reason why I use air quotes is because it's enough to feed at least 2 people. Maybe 3 depending on the appetite...which Hey I'm not complaining. I walked out of there with 2 days lunch. I wasn't a big fan of the leftover taste of the pizza but it's leftovers so. The rest of the family was pleased with what they ordered and had not complaints. One of the dishes was the fried chicken club which had lettuce, tomatoes, Mayo and Italian dressing. Another one was penne a la vodka but if you want chicken you have to pay extra. Then the other one was baked zitti."