Casa di Fratelli

"The food here is delicious. We went here prior to seeing a show at the NYCB theater in Westbury. Which is a five minute ride from this restaurant so an excellent choice for out-of-towners going to that venue. Back to the food. They start you out with bruschetta and warm bread. Both were very good and the bruschetta was a nice surprise. We split a meal of Chicken Francais which was tender in a delicious lemon sauce. It came with mashed potatoes and sauteed vegetables. They do charge $8 for sharing a meal, but do a really nice job of splitting the meal in two and serving it in 2 different dishes. For dessert we had the pistachio tartufo and the homemade tortoni which was out of this world - the best tortoni I've ever had. The restaurant is warm and inviting and was very festively decorated for Christmas. Someone obviously spent a lot of time on the lights, Christmas trees, Christmas village, etc... Very nice! The service was effective and friendly and we felt welcomed. They do charge a surcharge for paying with a credit card, but unlike many other restaurants, this is listed right at the top of the menu which was appreciated. I highly recommend Casa di Fratelli."

"I’ve come here so many times. Family run old school Italian, beautiful ambiance, great cocktails, reasonable and delicious. I can’t stop coming here. This is the ideal place for large parties or small, beautiful at Christmas time as well! It does not have that commercial feel. I will always be coming here"

"I have visited this establishment 3 times & every time I go the food & service is always superb! My niece originally took me here for a valentines dinner during restaurant week in 2022 which featured their $35 3 course prixe-fixe dinner menu which had great choices. Since then I’ve been back 2X for dinner whether it was birthdays or just a week night out & the food, ambience & service is always great! I definitely recommend this restaurant & will be back! I think I may even inquire about hosting a dinner party & see what options are available! Love it!"

"This place is a hidden gem. Staff is amazing. Food is delicious. I can't wait to go back."

"A hidden gem on Westbury. My friend recommended it as an impromptu choice for some out-of-town guests craving Italian and even though I've driven past it dozens of times, I never even noticed it. Portions are generous and the prices are very fair for this area of town. $40 for a NY strip with two full sides, $30 for a half duck and $28 for a very large pork chop. We had fried zucchini flowers and calamari for an appetizer. The calamari was a bit dry but passable. The zucchini flowers were very tasty. The duck entrée (pictured) was seasoned with orange and cranberries. The steak, cooked medium rare was a requested and even without being finished with butter ( at the diner's request), was tender and juicy. They were out of several deserts such was a disappointment but my friends said the tiramisu was delicious. Overall, we had a good meal and didn't break the bank."