Pizza and Shakes 209 West 57th Street, Manhattan, New York 10019

"The pizza is fast, fresh and FANTASTIC!! We have been trying different options each time we order from them. It's cool to have such a variety to pick from."

"Not traditional NYC pizza, but good pizza here. They have oval pizzas that one would expect from the &pizza chain and is more colloquially known as Pizza alla Pala. Most run about $15 each. I tried three types: -country style: signature tomato basil sauce, pepperoni, bacon, meatballs, mozzarella, sweet onion sauce -quatreto: white garlic sauce, shredded mozzarella, ricotta cheese, fresh mozzarella, Parmesan cheese, garlic Parmesan sauce -the swift: spicy tomato sauce, Parmesan cheese, pepperoni, jalapenos, roasted red peppers, Nashville hot sauce My favorite was the country style. Good amount of the topping and the sweet onion sauce brings it out together. The quatreto was also good. Had an interesting mesh of cheeses joined together by the garlic sauce. The swift was okay. It needs a bit more flavorful Nashville hot sauce IMHO. I'd come back and try the other pies."

"The best pizza I've ever had in New York, why? Simple, it is made when you order it, nothing is better than a freshly made pizza. Wide variety of ingredients to choose from. An excellent service. The place is clean. I recommend it 100%."

"I ordered the Swift pizza, and it was delicious. The pepperoni was fresh, and the pizza had a really nice cheese pull. The jalapeños on the pizza were also spicy, which was a plus for me. The staff was really nice and the establishment itself was really clean. They also serve freshly made gelato. The coconut and passion fruit flavors were my favorite."

"My friends and I were gonna picnic at Central Park and decided to grab food here to go. The pizzas were DELICIOUS! And can we talk about the “I LOVE YOU” wall? So cute! Definitely recommend."