Benny's Pizzeria 3835 U.S. 209, Stone Ridge, NY 12484

"Benny's is a true treasure in Stone Ridge. Although it is not classic Italiano pizza, it is absolutely loaded with flavors and toppings that will not disappoint you."

"Stopped in after seeing rave reviews on Facebook - not from the area so was curious to try. Pizza was delicious! Toppings so generous and the owner was such a nice man and very kind to include some samples to try ! My whole family thoroughly enjoyed! Definitely will be back when I am in the area!"

"The pizza is the best in Ulster County, if not the entire state. I couldn't even get a picture of the pizzas before they were eaten up."

"Wanted to find something new after an away Field Hockey game. Definitely found the spot!! Walked into an amazing family atmosphere of warmness and positivity. The place smelt amazing and the food had generous portions for our main meals. Our two kids were picky eaters and were eating off our plates. From creamy Alfredo sauce with the chicken fettuccine Alfredo to the perfect blend of ricotta and mozzarella on the baked zita. The homemade garlic knots were huge and out of this world!!! We got a pie to go and it had a nice blend of sauce to cheese ratio with a crisp to the crust. Bonus slice of the Chicken bacon ranch on the way out can compare to no one!! Definitely worth the hour trip for us to be returning soon for more amazing food. Best eating experience of 2023 with a great outdoor seating setup that even has bands come play."

"Was a pleasant suprise ! Pizza was loaded with meats and was great. Had an antipast salad and my friends alsonhad salads. The quality was awesome, and the portions were huge! The tomatoes were freshly picked from their garden. I am looking forward to going there again in the future."