Pasquale's

"Highly variable quality. We are local and order takeout here several times a month. The pizza quality varies. On a good day, the pizza is fantastic. Other times the pizza is just ok. Stromboli are always excellent, so sometimes we just order those to avoid risking getting an ok pizza. The salads range from great to fair. Most times the greens are very fresh and dry, other times the salads are soggy and slimy. Lately, salads have been more consistently good. Sometimes the person answering the phone is courteous and responsive. Other times they respond in only one syllable words or incomprehensible grunts. Most times I get home to discover my order was filled correctly. Occasionally my order is incorrect, perhaps as a result of variable phone responsiveness/miscommunication. Wings are always great...really great! When ordering fresh, I expect fresh made food and I don’t mind waiting, but the sliders taste like they sat out for a loooong time. Dry, lack flavor, and unsatisfying. I imagine freshly made sliders are excellent. I like Pasquales and will continue to patronize...because Lillos in Walden is no longer an option. Keep up the good work P... Note: Ca$h only."

"I was visiting Wallkill family for four days this past October 2023 and three of those nights I had their eggplant dish (enough for two meals). Amazingly delicious! I did not try any of the other Foods but they looked fantastic."

"Delicious food and large portions. If the prices were lowered, we would go more often."

"Dinner was excellent , server was polite and timely. Appetizers were very good . Portion size on soups and salads were great, calamari and fried was average . Dinner portions were very good ."

"This is what Pasquales in Wallkill, NY calls Chicken Frances. There was little chunks of I don’t know what in the sauce, which was brown and smelled rancid. I called and asked them to replace it, and the manager told me they would not do that unless I paid for something else since it wasn’t a mistake and I’m just unsatisfied. I was unsatisfied because it literally smelled rotten, had chunks of weird meaty pieces, and looked like chicken MarsaIa (I absolutely cannot eat or like the taste of mushroom). I paid $18 plus tax for this and didn’t eat it, get it replaced, or reimbursed. Disgusted."