Mama Mia's,

87 Main St, Geneseo, NY 14454, United States

"My nephew who goes to Geneseo took me here for a slice. The pizza was solid. Thin crust with decent sauce. The place looks like an old NYC pizza place with brick walls and high ceilings and darkly lit. The staff were college age kids. The only reason I give the service 3 stars is we ordered three pepperoni one cheese and they gave us three cheese one pepperoni. Wasn't a big deal but I really wanted to try both cheese and pepperoni. Next time I go I will get the pepperoni. Bathroom was clean and the atmosphere of the place was chill. Overall definitely recommend if you like thin crust David Portnoy style pizza."

"The kids enjoyed that they still use the big pepperoni slices on their pizzas, made this a unique memory for them! The staff was super friendly and amazing, great college town feel even at down times. Will be returning!"

"I had two experiences with Mama Mia's this past week, once in-store meeting with friends from high school for lunch, and once ordering delivery for dinner. This is a locally-owned pizza place on a college town's Main Street. It's been an institution here for a number of years. Set your expectations accordingly and don't expect gourmet-quality pizza. College students have to afford their food too, after all. The pizza is pretty good for what it is, though. It's thin crust, but not overly crunchy - whatever regional "style" that kind of pizza happens to be classified as. For dine-in, single slices of pizza are pretty large, so you do get your money's worth of pizza. For dine-in, you also get to enjoy music from the best decade - the '80's, naturally. Delivery is reasonably prompt, but if you get a dial tone when calling, just keep trying. They don't have a modern multi-line phone system so phone orders are taken one at at a time. My only complaint with the delivery order is that they brought the wrong size of soda. The fries have that overly crispy batter on the outside too, but I've come to expect that from most any pizza place that offers fryer food. An added bonus? They haven't partnered with Slice, or one of the major gig-delivery services that force you to use a card to order and tack on delivery fees. You can order over the phone and pay with cash when the driver arrives with your pizza - and there's something refreshingly nostalgic about that. For reasonably good and reasonably affordable pizza, it helps to go where the college students go - and Mama Mia's has been that place in town for years."

"Best NYC style pizza in upstate NY! Delicious crispy-chewy, thin slices, with the perfect ratio of dough:sauce:cheese. The type of pizza you fold in half to eat. Worth a stop if you’re driving through the area! Sides are quality too; we enjoyed our salads tossed in the house Caesar-vinaigrette dressing. And the fresh made coffee was strong and flavorful. Yum!"

"This is, in my opinion, the best pizza in Upstate NY. Geneseo is a college town and this place is right on Main Street. Sometimes it gets pretty busy but the prices are excellent and the pizza is outstanding. Typical New York, thin crust, pizza crispy crust on the bottom chewy throughout just the right amount of sauce and cheese."