Mustachio's Pizzeria 2701 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14217

"Our family recently had a pizza contest and we ordered 6 different pizzas from places we never had before. Your pizza was an overwhelming winner congrats! Needless to say you won more clientele due to our taste test! Keep up the good work!"

"We both just got off work and we're super hungry, and with almost everything closed by 9pm on a Friday night our choices are limited to mostly fast food. We're very loyal to our local pizza place, but like I said sadly they close early. Looked on Google and seen that they were open till midnight. So with not expecting anything great we decided to give em a try. We ordered online a few surcharges but whatever there open and were hungry. Super easy ordering, my wife usually does it cause I get frustrated and end up throwing my phone. Said it would be delivered by 10:34 got there a little early so that's a plus. I ordered an assorted sub and my wife ordered a turkey club and we both got fries. Let me tell you this was by far BEST sub I've put in my mouth, wife backed me up with hers, fries were banging, yup a simple order of fries but man they weredelighted. So tonight, bills game what are we doing? Getting a pie and some wings. Youve set the bar high Mustachios lets see if you deliver. Lets gi Bills lets get this number 2 seed.."

"Not really a sit-down place, although there are a few seats. The guy at the counter was friendly and patient with my questions. The apple pie logs were great! Crispy dough with sweet tangy apple pie filling and a caramel dip - terrific! The salad was a good size and they topped it with a chopped burger as a special off-menu request. Love it when a restaurant is willing to be creative with a Customer!"

"Heard good things about this place so I decided to give it a shot and was highly disappointed. I ordered a large cheese and pepperoni pizza and the pizza wasn’t that good to me nor my girlfriend."

"The best pizza in Buffalo! Consistency is key for me and Mustachio’s delivers every time. The crust is next level with a great crunch, sauce is super flavorful and not too sweet/heavy, pepperonis get the perfect char and they don’t skimp like other places, and the proportion of cheese to sauce to dough is 10/10. We love all the wings too, huge and crunchy. Char BBQ are my favorite, but they have other great unique flavors like teriyaki and General Tao’s (you have to try either). Wife loves the Turkey subs too, also must try. The owner cares about his food/name and it shows. Keep it up Mustachio’s!"