TOP 30 Best Local pizzeria favorites in New York

Independent Pizzeria Phoenix is a cozy and welcoming restaurant located at 20 Bridge Street in Phoenix, New York. Specializing in delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients and traditional recipes, this pizzeria is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a diverse menu including a variety of toppings, salads, and appetizers, Independent Pizzeria Phoenix offers something for everyone. Whether you're dining in, taking out, or ordering for delivery, you can always count on a satisfying and tasty meal from this beloved establishment. So come on in and enjoy a slice of Phoenix's best pizza at Independent Pizzeria Phoenix!

The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst is a beloved restaurant located at 177 South Wellwood Avenue in Lindenhurst, New York. Known for its delicious pizzas, pastas, and Italian dishes, this cozy eatery offers a welcoming atmosphere and friendly service. Whether you're dining in or taking out, The Pizzeria of Lindenhurst is the perfect spot for a tasty meal with family and friends. Come and experience the mouthwatering flavors of authentic Italian cuisine at this local favorite.

Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Deli is a charming eatery located at 32 Main Street in Sparrow Bush, New York. This family-owned establishment offers a delectable menu featuring authentic Italian pizzas and deli sandwiches made with the freshest ingredients. With a cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, Mamma Grace Pizzeria & Deli is the perfect spot to enjoy a delicious meal with friends and family. Come visit us and experience the warm hospitality and mouthwatering flavors that have made us a local favorite.

Firehouse Pizzeria is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 1192 Washington Street in Brushton, New York. Specializing in delicious, freshly made pizzas, this establishment is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, Firehouse Pizzeria is the perfect spot to enjoy a casual meal with family and friends. In addition to their mouth-watering pizzas, they also offer a variety of other Italian dishes and appetizers to satisfy any craving. Whether you're looking for a quick lunch or a relaxing dinner, Firehouse Pizzeria is the ideal choice for a satisfying meal in Brushton.

Sal's Pizzeria of Bainbridge is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 21 West Main Street in Bainbridge, New York. Known for their delicious pizzas and Italian cuisine, Sal's offers a wide variety of options to satisfy your cravings. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni pizza or a hearty pasta dish, Sal's has something for everyone. With a friendly staff and a welcoming atmosphere, Sal's Pizzeria of Bainbridge is the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or family. Come visit us and experience the mouthwatering flavors that have made us a local favorite.

Welcome to Tony's Pizzeria, your go-to destination for delicious, authentic pizza in the heart of Herkimer, New York. Conveniently located at 435 Mohawk Street, Tony's Pizzeria has been serving the community with mouth-watering pizzas, delectable pastas, and a wide variety of Italian favorites. Our passion for quality ingredients and traditional recipes ensures that every bite is a delightful experience. At Tony's Pizzeria, we pride ourselves on offering a warm and welcoming atmosphere, perfect for family gatherings, casual dinners, or quick takeout. Our menu caters to all tastes, featuring classic and specialty pizzas, fresh salads, savory appetizers, and sumptuous desserts. We also offer a selection of gluten-free and vegetarian options to accommodate diverse dietary preferences.

Welcome to Paesano's Pizzeria! Nestled in the heart of Mohawk, New York, Paesano's Pizzeria has been a cherished culinary destination since 1994. Located at 8 West Main Street, our family-owned and operated restaurant has been serving the Mohawk Valley with delicious, quality meals for nearly three decades. Whether you're passing through on your way to Cooperstown or looking for a quick and tasty family dinner, Paesano's offers a wide array of fresh and fast options that are sure to satisfy.

Francesca’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a cozy Italian eatery located at 3 Main Street in Delhi, New York. Serving up delicious pizzas, pastas, and other classic Italian dishes, this restaurant is a favorite spot for locals and visitors alike. The warm and inviting atmosphere makes it the perfect place to enjoy a casual meal with friends or family. With friendly staff and mouthwatering food, Francesca’s Pizzeria & Restaurant is a must-visit dining destination in Delhi.

Welcome to Sal's Pizzeria of Cooperstown, where the heart of Italy meets the charm of small-town America. Located at 110 Main Street in the picturesque village of Cooperstown, New York, our family-owned restaurant has been serving mouthwatering pizzas and authentic Italian dishes for over a decade. At Sal's, we pride ourselves on using the freshest ingredients and traditional recipes passed down through generations to bring you a true taste of Italy. Whether you're stopping by for a quick slice, enjoying a leisurely dinner with family, or picking up a takeout order, our friendly staff is committed to making your experience memorable. Our menu features a wide variety of pizzas, from classic Margherita to specialty creations, as well as a selection of pastas, salads, and appetizers to satisfy every palate.

Stefano's Pizzeria brings a taste of New York City to the heart of Warsaw, New York. Located at 12 North Main Street, this cozy restaurant offers authentic New York Style pizza and Italian cuisine in a welcoming atmosphere. Whether you're craving a classic cheese pizza or a gourmet specialty pie, Stefano's has something for everyone. With friendly service and fresh ingredients, this pizzeria is a must-visit for locals and visitors alike. Come experience the flavors of the Big Apple right here in Upstate New York at Stefano's Pizzeria.

L'Industrie Pizzeria is a cozy and inviting restaurant located at 254 South 2nd Street in the heart of New York City. Specializing in delicious and authentic Italian pizzas, this eatery is a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The menu features a variety of gourmet pizzas made with fresh ingredients and cooked to perfection in a traditional wood-fired oven. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, making it the perfect spot for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner with friends and family. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita or a unique specialty pie, L'Industrie Pizzeria has something to satisfy every pizza lover's cravings. Come visit us and experience the true taste of Italy right here in the United States.

EJ's Bistro Pizzeria & Restaurant is a cozy eatery located at 33 Market Street in the heart of Poughkeepsie, New York. Serving up a delicious blend of bistro-style dishes and mouthwatering pizzas, this restaurant is a popular choice for locals and visitors alike. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, EJ's is the perfect spot to enjoy a casual meal with family and friends. Whether you're craving a classic pepperoni pizza or a gourmet bistro entree, you'll find something to satisfy your taste buds at EJ's Bistro Pizzeria & Restaurant. Come dine with us and experience a culinary delight in the heart of Poughkeepsie.

New York Pizzeria is a popular restaurant located at 11376 Main Street in Cato, New York. Known for their delicious authentic New York-style pizza, this institution offers a wide variety of toppings and specialty pizzas to satisfy every craving. With a cozy and welcoming atmosphere, New York Pizzeria is the perfect spot to enjoy a casual meal with friends or family. In addition to their mouthwatering pizzas, they also serve a selection of appetizers, salads, and pasta dishes. Whether you're a local resident or just passing through, be sure to stop by New York Pizzeria for a taste of the Big Apple right in the heart of New York State.

New York Pizzeria is a popular dining destination located at 111 West Main Street in Waterville, New York. This cozy restaurant offers a wide variety of delicious pizzas made with fresh ingredients and a traditional New York-style crust. In addition to their mouthwatering pizzas, they also serve a selection of appetizers, salads, and sandwiches. Whether you're dining in or taking out, New York Pizzeria is the perfect spot to satisfy your pizza cravings in the heart of upstate New York.

Cecilia's Pizzeria is a beloved local institution located at 1716 Utica Avenue in New York, United States. Known for their X-Large Cheese Pizza, 8 Wings & Garlic Knots Special and other mouth-watering deals, this pizzeria offers a wide variety of toppings including pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, peppers, onion, and tomato. Supporting local businesses has never been more delicious than at Cecilia's Pizzeria, where Brooklyn residents flock for some of the best pizza in the area. With a menu that goes beyond just pizza to include sandwiches, salads, calzones, and more, there's something for everyone to enjoy. Don't forget to add on a side of french fries to complete your meal!

La Citta Pizzeria is a cozy and inviting restaurant located in the heart of New York City. Situated at 162 3rd Avenue, this pizzeria is a popular spot for locals and tourists alike. La Citta offers a wide variety of delicious pizzas, made with fresh and high-quality ingredients. From classic Margherita to unique specialty pizzas, there is something for everyone at this establishment. The warm and friendly staff are always ready to provide excellent service, making your dining experience a memorable one. Whether you're looking for a quick bite or a leisurely meal, La Citta Pizzeria is the perfect place to satisfy your pizza cravings.

Located in New York, United States, Doña Cuquita Pizzeria is a popular food institution offering a variety of delicious pizzas and Mexican dishes. From classic cheese or create-your-own pizzas to unique options like grilled chicken with buffalo sauce and ranch dressing, there is something for everyone to enjoy. With fresh ingredients like plum tomatoes, mozzarella cheese, and jalapenos, each dish is bursting with flavor. Supporting local businesses, Doña Cuquita Pizzeria has become a favorite in Queens for its top-quality pizzas and Mexican specialties. Whether you're in the mood for a traditional cheese pizza or want to try something new like a Quesabirra taco, there is a dish to satisfy your cravings. Don't forget to add a 2-liter soda to your order for the perfect pairing.

Frank's Pizzeria is a beloved institution located at 2 West Cross Street in Croton Falls, New York. This cozy restaurant and store offers delicious pizzas and other Italian dishes for both delivery and takeaway. With a warm and inviting atmosphere, Frank's Pizzeria is the perfect spot to enjoy a satisfying meal with friends and family. Whether you're craving a classic Margherita pizza or a hearty pasta dish, Frank's Pizzeria has something for everyone. Visit us today and experience the mouthwatering flavors that have made us a local favorite.

Casaletto Pizzeria, located at 70 Beekman Avenue in Sleepy Hollow, New York, is a popular local restaurant serving up some of the best pizzas in town. Support local businesses and indulge your taste buds with a visit to this beloved establishment. Casaletto Pizzeria has been a favorite among residents for years, offering a variety of delicious dishes that showcase the flavors of Sleepy Hollow. Be sure to add a side of french fries to your order, a local favorite that you won't want to miss. With convenient curbside pickup options, getting your hands on a tasty meal from Casaletto Pizzeria is a breeze. Whether you're a local or just passing through, make sure to stop by and see what all the fuss is about at Casaletto Pizzeria.

Linda's Riverside Pizzeria & Cafe is a popular food establishment located at 100 Riviera in Kings Park, New York, United States. They offer a variety of delicious meals including crispy onion slices, cheesy pizzas, flavorful salads, and mouthwatering sandwiches. Their family packages and touchdown packages are perfect for sharing with loved ones. Customers can also enjoy a selection of pasta dishes, seafood entrees, and specialty pizzas. The restaurant has been a local favorite for years and is known for their top-quality food and excellent service. With curbside pickup available, ordering from Linda's Riverside Pizzeria & Cafe is convenient and easy. Don't miss out on trying their famous Cheese Pizza and be sure to follow them on social media for updates on deals and specials. Visit Linda's Riverside Pizzeria & Cafe today to experience the best of Kings Park's cuisine.

Luigi's Italian Specialties Deli & Pizzeria is a charming establishment located at 199 New York 299 in Highland, New York. This institution offers a delightful combination of authentic Italian cuisine, including delicious deli sandwiches, freshly made pizzas, and a wide variety of specialty groceries. Whether you're looking to dine in, take your meal to go, or stock up on ingredients for a homemade Italian feast, Luigi's has you covered. Come experience the warm hospitality and mouthwatering flavors that have made Luigi's a beloved local favorite.

Amore's Pizzeria & Restaurant, located at 182 West Main Street in Goshen, New York, is a popular spot for delicious food and meal delivery. They offer a variety of specials, including the Large Cheese Pie, 12 Wings, 12 Knots & 2 Liter Soda Special, as well as other options like Eggplant Rollatini, Garlic Knots, and Zeppoles. Their menu also features items like a spiced beef patty with melted mozzarella cheese, fresh mozzarella salad, buffalo chicken salad, and an antipasto platter. Known for serving some of the best pizzas in Goshen, Amore's Pizzeria & Restaurant is a favorite among locals for its fresh ingredients and classic flavors. Whether you're in the mood for pizza, salads, or appetizers, Amore's has something for everyone. With curbside pickup available, ordering takeout is easy and convenient. Plus, with regular special offers, you can enjoy great deals on your favorite dishes. Don't forget to try their french fries for a tasty addition to your meal. Visit Amore's Pizzeria & Restaurant today and experience the best that Goshen has to offer.

Il Cantuccio Pizzeria Restaurant is a popular food establishment located at 1638 3rd Avenue in New York, New York, United States. Known for their delicious pizzas, they offer a variety of toppings including fresh mozzarella, plum tomato sauce, basil, olive oil, pepperoni, sausage, meatball, onion, mushroom, green peppers, spinach, broccoli, black olives, and more. Their Buffalo Chicken Pepperoni & Ranch Grandma Pizza Slice is a must-try for pizza lovers. In addition to pizzas, they also serve pasta dishes with sautéed broccoli, garlic, and olive oil. The restaurant has become a favorite among locals, offering a wide range of classic dishes that are sure to satisfy any craving. Their Regular Cheese Pizza is a crowd pleaser, and their french fries are a delicious addition to any meal.

Seaport Pizzeria is a charming eatery located at 64 Fulton Street in the bustling city of New York, New York. Known for its delicious and authentic pizzas, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it the perfect spot for a casual meal with friends or family. Whether you're craving a classic margherita pizza or a specialty pie, Seaport Pizzeria has something for everyone. Stop by and enjoy a slice of New York's finest pizza today!

D-Ray's Pizzeria is a popular eatery located at 215 Broad Street in Oneida, New York. Known for its delicious pizzas and casual dining atmosphere, this restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. With a wide variety of toppings to choose from and a welcoming staff, D-Ray's Pizzeria is the perfect spot to enjoy a tasty meal with friends and family. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni pizza or a specialty pie, you're sure to find something to satisfy your cravings at this cozy pizzeria.

Pizzeria Italia is a charming Italian restaurant located at 2644 Genesee Street in Utica, New York. Serving up delicious and authentic Italian cuisine, this cozy pizzeria is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. From mouthwatering pizzas to savory pasta dishes, there is something for everyone to enjoy at Pizzeria Italia. Come experience the warm atmosphere and friendly service at this beloved neighborhood spot.

Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria is located at 330 White Plains Road in Eastchester, New York, and is known for serving some of the best pizzas in the area. This popular establishment offers finely chopped or ground meat mixed with seasoning, as well as a variety of delicious dishes. One must-try item on the menu is the White Pizza, a local favorite that has made Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria famous. Customers can also add soda to their order for a more satisfying meal. The restaurant offers curbside pickup for convenience, and accepts credit card payments for an easy ordering process. Whether you're a local or just passing through, Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria is a must-visit for delicious pizza in Eastchester.

Talluci's Pizzeria, located at 1249 Melville Road in Farmingdale, New York, is a popular food establishment known for its delicious pizzas and classic Italian dishes. Their garlic knots, Caesar salad, and wedge salad are just a few of the mouthwatering options on their menu. Customers rave about their Grandma Pie, a local favorite that is a must-try when visiting the pizzeria. Talluci's Pizzeria also offers curbside pickup and accepts credit card payments for added convenience. With special offers and a wide variety of menu items to choose from, Talluci's Pizzeria is the perfect spot for a satisfying and affordable meal in Farmingdale.

Located in New York, United States, Danny Pizzeria & Restaurant offers a wide variety of delicious food options for customers to enjoy. From traditional pizzas like Neapolitan style with fresh mozzarella to unique creations like a sauceless pie topped with ricotta, mozzarella, and parmesan cheese, there is something for everyone to enjoy. In addition to pizza, the restaurant also offers a range of appetizers, salads, pasta dishes, and desserts. With a focus on quality ingredients and flavorful combinations, Danny Pizzeria & Restaurant has become a popular choice for locals and visitors alike. Customers can also enjoy curbside pickup and convenient payment options for a hassle-free dining experience. Explore the menu and discover your new favorite dish at Danny Pizzeria & Restaurant today!

Located at 1700 Washington Avenue in Seaford, New York, Lombardo’s Of Seaford Pizzeria is a popular food institution offering a variety of delicious options. From their Monday to Wednesday specials featuring large cheese pizzas, garlic knots, salads, and more, to their unique Vodka-Drunken Grandma Pizza, there is something for everyone to enjoy. In addition to their tasty pizzas, Lombardo’s also serves pasta, sandwiches, and other side dishes. Known for their friendly service and quality food, Lombardo’s is a favorite among locals. With convenient curbside pickup and occasional special offers, dining at Lombardo’s Of Seaford Pizzeria is both easy and affordable. Whether you're looking for a quick slice or a full feast, Lombardo’s has you covered. Experience the best of Seaford's pizza scene at Lombardo’s Of Seaford Pizzeria.