Italian Village Pizza

"Eaten here for almost three years now, mostly ordering pizza for pickup. My favorite pizza in the neighborhood by far. Today it was cold and we got two orders of Alfredo pastas for pickup. We had an issue with the order and called the restaurant. After explaining they were very apologetic and wanted to make it right. They said they were happy to remake our food or any food we wanted. They remade our original meals and they were delicious. They have excellent customer service and treat their customers right."

"A neighborhood staple for pizza, Italian Village offers other dishes as well. Specialty slices are $5 each. The pizza has a good crust, decent sauce, and the best part is that they don’t skimp on the toppings."

"First time eating here via a suggestion, and the Shrimp Scampi was horrible. I prepare Shrimp Scampi and I have never once placed Olives in it. I didn't appreciate the taste. The cheesecake was iffy as well. The garlic bread was very good."

"First timer for lunch. Tried a plain cheese slice because if they can't do that right then there's no point. Clean place, busy, attentive & friendly staff. Lots of room to sit in the back. Crushed red peppers were hot/fresh. My wife tried a pineapple-ham slice. She liked it. The cheese slice was excellent, a solid four star pizza. Took some Sicilian slices to go. Heated them up the next day and while not a "true" Sicilian pie it was very good. Again a solid four star slice. Solid NYC pizza joint. Give it a try."

"I love this place! It's been 3yrs and the pizza is still amazing. They survived Covid-19 and still pumping out the best pizza in NYC. If you are staying in the upper Eastside of Manhattan you have to stop by and grab a slice."