Brooklyn Pizza 38 Chatham Road, Millburn, NJ 07078

"Ordered the little Italy panini. The fries were better than the panini and the fries could’ve been better. Little to no flavoring which was surprising being that the majority of the cooks in the back were Hispanic. Definitely not worth $15. The young girl in the front was also kinda rude but nothing I haven’t dealt with before. And yes I’m reviewing the right place, you can keep your sarcastic responses to yourself thanks!"

"Pizza is good, wings were underdone. For all the handwringing and complaining about "third party delivery apps" on their website, my order was actually cheaper through Door Dash. Identical orders. The compulsory tipping through their site to "help the team out" with stock team photos should be reigned in as well. Tipping shouldn't be forced, it's for outstanding service."

"Your pizza is as thin as a tortilla chip. I expect better value for $17 large pie. thank you for your response. glad people come from far to enjoy your thin thin pizza. just make your price match your thin thin pizza for a better value - i dont want to be hungry after spending $17 on a pie. let your price match the amount of food you provide."

"Cute restaurant right outside the train station, great spot to pick up a slice of pizza on your way into the city or back. I picked up a delicious chicken bacon ranch and enjoyed it my with friends. Food was prepared quickly and efficiently and I had a good experience speaking with employees there, they were friendly an attentive. I will be going back !"

"This place went above and beyond to provide outstanding customer service. They were not even officially open for the day and they offered to make a fresh pizza of my choice, just for a single slice. This has never happened before and made my experience that much better. Most places are trying to push old Pizza, not this place. I went with a Margherita Slice which was $4 even, which is one of the most expensive slices in the county, but they delivered a slice that was made with fresh ingredients. The sweer sauce was the star of the show. It was so good that it carried the rest of the Pizza ,which had a solid cheese and crust. Thjs could be a Sleeper for the 2021 Tournament of Pizza on the Pizza Hunters App."