Clemenza's Original Brick Oven

"Eating here was a treat. The pizza came fresh and super crispy with the perfect thickness of the crust. I was honestly surprised at how good this pizza was. The only downside that I will mention, is that there isn't really any place to park. You either have to park a block away or have a friend to order food while you keep your car out front. A solid 7.3/10 for the whole experience."

"I normally am not big on leaving reviews but sadly this place was our go to spot for some time since we moved to the area. Today was the last straw. Either they are under new ownership which is complexly clueless or no one cares anymore. Placed an order waited almost 2 hours even though the delivery estimate was 45min. Still not a big deal. Called them it’s on its way. Waited another 30 min about. Called again to let them know if it does not arrive within the next few I need to cancel and do something else for dinner with the kids. About 15min later driver arrives at my neighbors and finally realizes he is at the wrong house. Finally have the food, and as expected ice cold. Everything. But whatever we are all hungry and it’s late so we eat it. 15min later doorbell rings again. It’s the pizza driver again with a whole new order. Not sure who’s order but doesn’t even realize he was just here. At that point I decided to call and speak to the manager to explain what happens, who goes onto say he has no idea how this happened. But didn’t even care to respond to the fact the food was ice cold and was probably sitting the whole time it wasn’t getting delivered. Used to be great, but this downward spiral just seems to be a trend and we will no longer order from them."

"Hunting Pizza in Essex County, NJ for the Pizza Hunters App presented with Speed. Joe was awesome as he was very friendly upon walking in and was more than happy to talk about their Pizza. In fact, he even shared that his grandmother brother was in the Godfather movie. I had their grandma Pizza which was an excellent slice. I loved the grated cheese that was a topper. The slice itself was a nice thin pie with a very tasty crust. It all blended very well. Could have used some more of their sauce, but overall it was very good. Parking can be a little tough around Millburn, but was told that the Pizzeria parking is around the back of the building. Can't wait to go back again soon."

"First timer here. When I say I don’t usually do this, I don’t. This establishment is 5 star. To the staff, to how elegant and clean the place looks, the food? it’s really superb. I had a speciality slice, it was excellent. the bread was fresh, the pizza wasn’t oily and it passed the fold rest. 5 stars. The floors were clean, everything was organized and clearly posted. Even the glass was crystal clear (weird I know, but I notice these things) 5 star. The staff? Man, the best guys I’ve met so far in a pizza place to date. These guys move fast, have a sense of humor and portrayed a great sense of professionalism. 5 star. Overall this place is incredible. Masks were worn."

"Great place, just wish the pizza was as good. The dough had perfect flavor but other than that it was blah. Was in the area so decided to give them a try. This was their Margarita slice"